the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
The role of secondary ice production in shaping the microphysical evolution of orographic clouds: A RAMS-ICLAMS modeling study
Abstract. Secondary ice production (SIP) strongly influences ice crystal number concentrations (ICNCs) and cloud microphysical properties, with important implications for radiative forcing, thermodynamics, cloud evolution, and precipitation. Here, we investigate four SIP mechanisms—rime splintering, collisional breakup, rain droplet shattering during freezing, and sublimation breakup—in the Integrated Community Limited Area Modeling System, a specialized version of the Regional Atmospheric Modeling System (RAMS-ICLAMS), during winter storms observed in November–December 2024 as part of the Cleancloud Helmos OrograPhic sIte experimeNt (CHOPIN). Activating SIP increases ICNCs by two to three orders of magnitude and enhances ice water content by up to a factor of 2–3, substantially modifying cloud structure, including a 25–35 % reduction in liquid water path and a doubling of ice water path. These changes improve agreement with observed radar signatures and precipitation patterns and alter the amount of precipitation reaching the ground. Among the represented mechanisms, collisional breakup is dominant, followed by rime splintering. Sublimation breakup is locally intense but at least one order of magnitude weaker, while droplet shattering is the weakest and is mainly activated in regions rich in raindrops. The simulated systems encompass synoptic-scale, convective, and stratiform clouds, including snowfall-producing and seeder–feeder configurations. These results highlight the importance of representing SIP—particularly collisional breakup and rime splintering—for realistic simulations of diverse orographic clouds and precipitation in weather- and climate-scale models.
- Preprint
(2253 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(1624 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 25 Nov 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4645', Anonymous Referee #1, 16 Oct 2026 reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4645', Anonymous Referee #2, 18 Nov 2026
reply
Review – The role of secondary ice production in shaping the microphysical evolution of orographic clouds: A RAMS-ICLAMS modeling study
The authors analyze the impact of including four secondary ice production (SIP) mechanisms in the RAMS-ICLAMS model for two case studies observed during the CHOPIN campaign. In both the convective and the stratiform case, activating SIP leads to a modified cloud structure with increased ice crystal number concentrations, higher ice water paths, and lower liquid water paths. The authors compare observed cloud radar reflectivities to reflectivities that were forward modelled based on the RAMS-ICLAMS model output. They conclude that the inclusion of SIP leads to more realistic radar reflectitivies.
While the presented work is interesting and in scope of ACP, I have some major concerns that need to be addressed before the paper can be considered for publishing. This concerns on one hand the structure of the paper, which is overly long and heavily relies on figures in the supplements. On the other hand, the presented comparison to observations does not support the claim that “updated model demonstrates substantial improvements”. I therefore highly recommend major revision.
General comments
- While the comparison to the MIRA cloud radar and the PVM-100 cloud probe make up a large part of the study, both instruments and respective data sets are poorly described. For example, descriptions of calibration and uncertainties are missing. For cloud radar, an offset of multiple dBZ can be due to calibration and it is therefore crucial to discuss data quality and expected uncertainty ranges before comparing to forward simulations.
- The manuscript is rather long and repetitive. At the same time, it heavily relies on the Supplementary Material. I strongly recommend to restructure and make sure that the Supplementary Material is truly a supplement to the main manuscript and not needed for the argumentation throughout.
- The results do not support the conclusion that the addition of SIP makes the resulting clouds more realistic. In both CONTROL and ALL SIP, the forward modelled radar reflectivities compare rather poorly to the radar observations and by eye, I don’t see significant improvements. Throughout the manuscript, the comparison to observations is done primarily qualitative instead of quantitative. A quantitative, statistical comparison would highly strengthen the analysis.
- The model output is described in much detail, but I am often missing an interpretation of the differences/outputs in terms of which physical processes lead to the differences/outputs. This also holds for the comparison to observations. For example in Fig. 9: what are potential reasons the model is producing a cloud at 15:00 on 06/12 and why is the cloud structure on 07/12 more realistic? At 06:00 on 07/12, the CONTROL run looks closer to MIRA than the ALLSIP run, what does that mean for the way SIP is represented in the model? Etc.
Specific comments
- L27: “alter the amount of precipitation reaching the ground” is too vague; please be more specific
- L41: "especially in the warmer temperature below -15C" is a very confusing phrasing; please rephrase
- L49: “over five decades” followed by one citation from 2017 seem weird; please include more references going further back
- L52: a discussion of HM should include the more recent work by Seidel et al. (2024); https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-24-5247-2024
- L81 (and later): do you mean forward modelled radar reflectivity profiles?
- L87 (and later): “more realistic” and “better match” is vague; please quantify
- Sect. 2.1: I suggest sub-chapters on remote sensing, in-situ, and general campaign info to improve readability
- L127 (and later): Since MIRA is a spectral radar, why don’t you investigate radar spectra for signal of SIP. In my opinion, this would greatly strengthen your work.
- Fig. 1 (and following figures): please make sure that all abbreviations in the figure captions are spelled out. Many people will first scan figures and captions before reading the text and it makes your work more accessible.
- L156 (for example): please avoid )( and use ; instead
- Fig. 2: please include a label for the colorbar
- L276: “accounting for their particle size distributions and dielectric properties” where is this described? What about mass-size relations for the respective categories?
- L284 (and later): please remove all cases of “in-situ” before cloud radar; this is highly confusing
- L291: this is very confusing. Was the MIRA data corrected for attenuation? Or did you add attenuation to the forward modelled reflectities? If the latter is the case, what was considered for the calculation (gas & liquid droplets or also snow?)
- Fig. 3: do you have precipitation measurements you could compare the model output to?
- L364: why would you have a more pronounces overestimation in regions of enhanced sedimentation?
- Fig. 4 (and others): why don’t you plot as one continuous figure instead of two panels?
- Fig. 4: why are the temperature contours not the same for model and observations? Where are they taken from for the observations panels?
- Fig. 4: why is the radar data to discontinuous? It looks like there are steps?
- Fig. 5 (and description in text): which LWC is compared here, i.e., is it the lowest height grid of the model output?
- Fig. 7: SC has not been discussed yet; please restructure
- L652: a sentence is repeated here
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4645-RC2
Data sets
CleanCloud CHOPIN - radar data & code N. Clerx et al. https://zenodo.org/records/21245825
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 433 | 247 | 72 | 752 | 127 | 83 | 64 |
- HTML: 433
- PDF: 247
- XML: 72
- Total: 752
- Supplement: 127
- BibTeX: 83
- EndNote: 64
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Please find my review attached.