An Expanded Methanosphere: Methane Oxidation and Methanotrophs Surrounding Cold Seeps Across Oxygen Gradients on the Southern California Margin
Abstract. Marine methane (CH4) seeps are dynamic biogeochemical systems that regulate carbon and sustain high-biomass communities through microbial CH4 oxidation. While most CH4 is consumed anaerobically in sediments, a fraction escapes into the water column, where aerobic methanotrophs act as a biological filter limiting atmospheric flux. However, the spatial extent of CH4 influence beyond active seep zones remains poorly constrained, with implications for deep-sea food webs and carbon cycling. We investigated microbial CH4 turnover and methanotroph distribution across three seep sites on the Southern California margin (Del Mar (1020 m), Santa Monica Mound (800 m), and Lasuen Knoll (400 m)) focusing on extent of horizontal transport, presence of vertical gradients, and oxygen controls. Using radiotracer (3H-CH4) incubations, CH4 concentration profiles, 16S rRNA gene sequencing, and particulate methane monooxygenase (pmoA) gene quantification, we characterized CH4-fueled processes along vertical and lateral transects, including near-bottom waters sampled via HOV Alvin. CH4 oxidation was active both within seep plumes and in off-seep waters extending hundreds of meters from the source, with maximum rates reaching 454 nmol L⁻¹ d⁻¹ in a CH4-rich bubble plume. Methanotrophic communities showed vertical structuring, with higher diversity near the seafloor. pmoA gene abundances remained consistent across seep and seep-adjacent environments, indicating widespread oxidation potential. Environmental controls were site-specific: oxidation correlated positively with CH4 and negatively with oxygen at some sites, whereas oxygen enhanced oxidation at others. These findings support an expanded “methanosphere,” in which CH4-driven microbial processes extend beyond seep boundaries, linking local seep activity to broader deep-sea biogeochemical dynamics.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Biogeosciences.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
Review of "An Expanded Methanosphere: Methane Oxidation and Methanotrophs Surrounding Cold Seeps Across Oxygen Gradients on the Southern California Margin" but Klonicki-Ference et al.
This study presents a comprehensive dataset of water column methane concentrations, methane oxidation rate, microbial community composition (including methanotrophic/methylotrophic genera), and pmoA gene abundance via qPCA, in the vicinity of cold seeps on the Southern California Margin. The work is overall of very high quality, with rigorous methodology, properly motivated and yielding interesting and robust results. I have only a couple of conceptual comments that I would ask the authors to address, and some minor additional corrections or requests for further information.
General comment 1.
The study uses the combination of available data to speculate on the causes of heterogeneity in methane oxidation rates and fractional turnover around the seeps, including vertical profiling of the whole water column and lateral passes of the near-bottom environment with submersible and rosette sampling. Significant heterogeneity in oxidation is indeed observed between sampling locations, and the roles of CH4 and O2 availability, and pmoA gene abundance, in controlling this are summarized in the Spearman correlation matrices of Figure 7. The authors conclude that at least at SMM, there is evidence for a strong negative relationship between O2 and k, the rate constant for CH4 oxidation. This concept is also found in one of the listed hypotheses at the start of the study. This inverse relationship seems counterintuitive because O2 is a participant in the oxidation reaction, although admittedly is not the limiting reactant under any of the studied conditions. But still, it requires some elaboration why such a relationship should exist, both in the hypothesis forming and in the discussion of the results. Is it so that the environments with the lowest (although not rate-limiting) O2 conditions are also those where sediment redox gradients are closest to the surface and therefore methanotrophic communities can more easily and permanently establish, thus yielding relatively efficient oxidation rates in the data?
General comment 2.
I found it intriguing how little variability there is in the pmoA abundance throughout the water column and between sites (Figure 6). I wonder how such profiles look in areas much further away from the seeps? ie. to what extent is the community of methanotrophs observed in the water column really related to the presence of the seeps, or would it be considered typical of an OMZ water column anywhere in the oceans? Some of the text in the discussion and conclusions implies that these communities might be mobilized into the water column from the seeps after the passage of currents, but the homogeneous distribution in Figure 6 argues for a high background of pmoA-carrying microbes in this region, Can the authors comment on this, and how e.g. metatranscriptomics approaches might yield more illustrative data.
General comment 3:
Maximum methane concentrations and oxidation rates are in several cases observed some tens to hundreds of meters above the seafloor rather than directly adjacent to it (Figure 2). Is there a role of dissolution of rising gas bubbles after ebullition, leading to high availability of CH4 at these depths? There is some discussion about bubble transport in the text, but dissolution of rising bubbles is also an important part of the methane cycle in ebullitive systems (see e,g, Hermans et al., STOTEN 945, 2024).
Line-by-Line:
Introduction: please give more background to the overall geological setting and origin of the methane seeps in this region, e.g. age and depth of the source material for methanogenesis.
73: Include acronym in brackets after first use of methane monooxygenase
123: grammatical error
178: grammatical error
214: Lasuen or Lausen?
402 and throughout: By convention, should not use "PSU"
723: what does "planktonic" mean in this context? should it read "pelagic"?