the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Phytoplankton size structure in the northwestern Weddell Sea
Abstract. The size of phytoplankton is a key metric that influences organic carbon production in the ocean and its transfer efficiency through marine food webs. There is evidence that the size structure of phytoplankton in Antarctic waters differs markedly from that in tropical oceans. However, logistical challenges have left many Antarctic regions poorly sampled. Here, we explore a dataset collected during an austral summer research cruise to the rarely sampled northwestern Weddell Sea continental shelf and open waters near the eastern Antarctic Peninsula. The dataset includes discrete measurements of size-fractionated chlorophyll-a concentration (pico- <2 μm, nano- 2–20 μm, and microphytoplankton >20 μm) obtained using in vitro fluorescence and sequential size-fractionated filtration (SFF), phytoplankton pigments measured by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), and in situ radiometric (ocean-colour) observations. We find broad agreement between HPLC-based (using diagnostic pigment analysis) and SFF-based estimates of total and size-fractionated chlorophyll-a, but with systematic differences for some size classes depending on the technique used. Ocean-colour chlorophyll-a algorithms developed in other regions of the Southern Ocean perform well in the northwestern Weddell Sea and outperform standard global algorithms, which systematically underestimate chlorophyll-a. SFF measurements indicate that medium-sized phytoplankton (nanophytoplankton) dominate both shelf and open waters of the northwestern Weddell Sea. We fitted a simple three-component model to the SFF data describing the partitioning of chlorophyll-a among the three size classes as a function of total chlorophyll-a. Model parameters were similar to those derived from an independent dataset from the western Antarctic Peninsula, supporting the broader dominance of nanophytoplankton around the entire Antarctic Peninsula, but differed markedly from parameters derived from lower-latitude tropical and subtropical (50° N to 50° S) Atlantic waters, where picophytoplankton dominate. Finally, we combined satellite-derived estimates of total chlorophyll-a during the cruise period with the tuned model parameters to map the spatial distribution of phytoplankton size classes across the broader northwestern Weddell Sea region, which confirmed the widespread dominance of nanophytoplankton. These datasets provide a valuable baseline for quantifying the rate and fate of organic carbon production in this rapidly changing region.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Ocean Science.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.- Preprint
(9127 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4398', Anonymous Referee #1, 08 Sep 2026
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Robert J. W. Brewin, 19 Oct 2026
Please find the authors reply on RC1 in the attached PDF file.
-
RC2: 'Reply on AC1', Anonymous Referee #1, 21 Oct 2026
Thanks to the authors for the careful reply to the comments and for addressing all points raised. I do think referring the reader to figures R1 and R2 and is suggested in the response could be valuable, should readers be interested to see the implications of using the regional tuned algorithm, which are notable.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4398-RC2 -
AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Robert J. W. Brewin, 21 Oct 2026
We thank Referee #1 for their positive and constructive feedback. We appreciate this suggestion and are happy to refer readers to Figures R1 and R2 to illustrate the implications of using the regionally tuned algorithm.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4398-AC2
-
AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Robert J. W. Brewin, 21 Oct 2026
-
RC2: 'Reply on AC1', Anonymous Referee #1, 21 Oct 2026
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Robert J. W. Brewin, 19 Oct 2026
-
RC3: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4398', Christina Schallenberg, 10 Nov 2026
General comments:
This is a fine paper describing a thorough analysis of a regional dataset (from the northwestern Weddell Sea), while drawing on a wider data set to put the findings into context. It is interesting, well written, the analyses are clear and meaningful, and the results make a valuable addition to the body of knowledge. I only have very minor comments for improvement. The paper was a pleasure to read.
Scientific comments:
L111 and 115: it’s definitely 0.1 um? In the introduction it’s 0.2 um (L46).
L137: So data between 0.0001 and 0.001 were kept, but if equal to 0.001 they were excluded? That doesn’t sound right.
L146-152: For the cruises that had the “wrong” pore size for the micro fraction (i.e. 5 or 10 um rather than 20), only the pico-data can be used, correct? Could that skew your data set, i.e. because you have way more pico data than any other size class? Or asked differently, how different would the results be if you only used data from the AMT cruises with the all the correct filters?
L235 (eqn 16): It would be good to add a reference for this equation (is it the Mobley (1999), or is that just for the value? It’s unclear), and also a word of explanation (e.g., what is corrected with the 0.028 factor?). And is the Rrs then directly comparable to satellite Rrs?
L275: what was the maximum time elapsed between CTDs that were matched in this way?
L359-363: suggest merging this content into the paragraph L340-352
L430: reword to “less nutrient limited”? Under nutrient replete conditions I would expect microphytoplankton dominating?
L424-442: This paragraph is not entirely convincing as it doesn’t currently explain why nanophytoplankton dominate in the Weddell Sea (Southern Ocean) in the low-Chl regimes, rather than picophytoplankton (as observed on AMT). It offers some general concepts but doesn’t mention iron limitation (which is likely shaping phytoplankton communities in the regions of interest) at all, so that’s one point to be addressed. And a more direct explanation of the nanophytoplankton dominance would also be useful, even if it’s just in the form of a hypothesis.
L469-470: I think this sentence should be qualified by “at Chl concentrations <2 mg m-3” (or thereabouts), I and also suggest referring to Figure 5 here as it illustrates the difference between the Weddell and the lower-latitude regions
L480-481: For someone not familiar with the concept of these slopes, this is difficult to follow. Maybe insert a sentence to explain the concept a bit? Does the slope relate to all biomass, not just phytoplankton?
L503-505: As above, please qualify at what Chl concentrations this is true
Minor technical comments:
L94: refer to table 1 as well? That’s the only place where the time of year gets mentioned
Figure 1: Consider giving the ice shelf a colour different from land? Make the land grey?
L163: include “and” after (Fn)
L167: Remove “be” between “can” and “then”
L169: “derive” not “derived”
L187: missing a verb between “reconstructed” and “the weighted”?
L197, L204, L219: “…in each size class…”
L211: “…albeit with a different…”
L216: remove “to”
L245: “…using a commonly…”
L253: remove “the” before “Southern Ocean waters”
L333: specify “picophytoplankton” (replace “phytoplankton”)
L336: “Methods” is the wrong word at the beginning of the sentence; do you mean “Correlation coefficients”?
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4398-RC3 - AC3: 'Reply on RC3', Robert J. W. Brewin, 11 Nov 2026
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 377 | 205 | 53 | 635 | 38 | 51 |
- HTML: 377
- PDF: 205
- XML: 53
- Total: 635
- BibTeX: 38
- EndNote: 51
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
The manuscript presents an analysis of ship-based data that are used to evaluate the contribution of different phytoplankton size classes to total chlorophyll concentration in the northwestern Weddell Sea region of the Southern Ocean. The work is well-written and thorough and the authors have considered a variety of methods in their modeling of different phytoplankton size classes, and total chlorophyll concentration from reflectance measurements. The manuscript is an effective contribution to the body of knowledge on phytoplankton ecosystems in a specific region of the Southern Ocean.
Main comments:
As a reader I am curious how the regional-specific methods to separate size classes from satellite data would be relevant to other regions of the Southern Ocean; recognizing that the data are specific to the northwestern Weddell Sea, but it does beg the question of whether the differences observed between AMT and PICCOLO/Rothera also apply to other parts of the high latitude Southern Ocean? Maybe the authors could comment on the recommended use of the size class equations (i.e., should application of the Table 2 to satellite OC data be limited to the geographic region shown in Figure 6?). Relatedly, it could be worth commenting on, if not showing, how different the satellite maps looks when using the tuned PICCOLO coefficients vs previously published coefficients (or the standard Chl-a algorithm for total Chl-a).
The methods and Table 1 indicate that samples from a range of depths were used in the analyses – perhaps it could be worth testing a re-calculation of the parameters in Table 2 using only near-surface data, for application to satellite OC data. Or at least testing the surface vs. full water column values and commenting on whether they are significantly different (i.e., do the PICCOLO curves in Figure 5g-i change noticeably if only near-surface samples are used?).
Minor/Technical comments:
Figure 1 – Suggest including an inset map of location of the peninsula.
L169 – should be ‘to derive’
L245 should be ‘a commonly-used’
L333 should be ‘picophytoplankton’
L275 Re: “Depth matching was performed using the nearest available sampling depth.” Perhaps include statistics on this - how far apart are the matches at most?