the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Nitrogen fixation and atmospheric deposition influences on Mediterranean surface and intermediate water nutrient dynamics
Abstract. The Mediterranean Sea is an oligotrophic basin characterised by anti-estuarine circulation and low productivity. In comparison to the global average, nutrients in the upper water column have high nitrate: phosphate ratios (or N*, nitrate minus phosphate x 16), suggested to arise from high external nutrient inputs. Modified Atlantic Water (MAW) enters with a low inorganic/organic nitrogen ratio, becomes saltier and denser moving eastwards, sinks to form Levantine Intermediate Water (LIW) ultimately feeding the Mediterranean Overflow Water (MOW), supplying nutrients to the Atlantic. This study employed stoichiometric and isotopic analyses of nitrate, dissolved organic nitrogen (DON), and particulate nitrogen to assess the roles of atmospheric deposition and nitrogen fixation on nutrient dynamics within MAW and LIW formation regions.
In the western basin, atmospheric deposition, primarily from anthropogenic sources, dominates nitrogen inputs, maintaining a high N:P ratio (N*) and low δ15N (~3.5 ‰) in MAW. Moving eastward, anthropogenic nitrogen inputs decline, lowering the atmospheric N:P contribution, allowing dust-derived phosphorus to be increasingly important and potentially stimulating nitrogen fixation. This further decreases δ15N (< 3 ‰) while altering MAW nutrient stoichiometry (lower N* and nutrient concentrations, higher organic contributions), passing these into initial LIW properties. During LIW formation, dissolved organic phosphorus (DOP) concentration decreased, suggesting DOP hydrolysis via high alkaline phosphatase activity could support nitrogen fixation along with a dust-derived nutrient source. This could contribute 54.94 ± 29.03 Gg N of new nitrogen, alongside direct atmospheric nitrogen inputs (7.4–37.2 Gg N). These new nitrogen additions are transferred to depth, forming the source composition of the LIW and influencing the properties of subsequent water masses formed further along the LIW pathway. At the basin scale, the LIW nitrogen content is largely determined by Atlantic DON, modified by changes in nitrogen inputs from atmospheric nitrogen deposition and nitrogen fixation to the surface water, controlled by phosphorus availability.
- Preprint
(2498 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4372', Anonymous Referee #1, 17 Oct 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4372', Anonymous Referee #2, 29 Oct 2026
The manuscript addresses an interesting question in Mediterranean biogeochemistry by combining nutrient distributions, nitrogen isotopes, organic nutrient measurements, and atmospheric deposition data. However, the quantitative attribution of nitrogen fixation to newly formed Levantine Intermediate Water (LIW) remains uncertain. I have the following comments.
Major comments
- Nitrogen fixation estimate: The isotope mass balance compares δ¹⁵N-DON in incoming water with δ¹⁵N-NO₃ in LIW, assuming a nitrogen-fixation endmember of −1‰. These pools are not directly equivalent, and atmospheric nitrogen deposition may have a similar isotope signature. The authors should test the sensitivity of the estimate to endmember selection and acknowledge that the sources cannot be uniquely distinguished.
- Water-mass transformation and nitrogen budget: The comparison between pre-formation and post-formation waters relies on samples collected at different locations and times. Mixing, remineralisation, and seasonal variability could contribute to the observed differences. The authors should clarify these limitations and provide a more transparent mass-balance framework, including the transport timescale and uncertainty propagation.
- Nitrogen fixation and isotope evidence: The direct nitrogen-fixation measurements show decreasing rates from west to east, whereas the isotope-based interpretation needs to be reconciled with this pattern. As nitrogen-isotope endmembers overlap, δ¹⁵N-POM alone cannot uniquely establish the contribution of nitrogen fixation.
- Phosphorus limitation: High N:P ratios alone do not establish P limitation. Absolute nutrient concentrations, bioavailability, and the biological process being considered are also relevant. The authors should clarify what is supposedly P-limited and provide stronger support for this interpretation.
- DOP removal and nitrogen fixation: The observed decrease in dissolved organic phosphorus (DOP) is consistent with phosphorus regeneration but does not demonstrate that this process stimulated nitrogen fixation. This mechanism should be presented as a hypothesis unless supported by direct evidence.
- Seasonal extrapolation: The study uses summer observations to infer nitrogen cycling during winter LIW formation. The authors should justify this extrapolation and qualify the resulting nitrogen budget accordingly.
Specific comments
- Lines 31–33: “This could contribute 54.94 ± 29.03 Gg N of new nitrogen, alongside direct atmospheric nitrogen inputs (7.4–37.2 Gg N).” There is no clear timescale. I would advise expressing these quantities in flux terms, with the relevant integration period specified.
- Line 40: “Significant external nutrient inputs.” The word significant is vague here. Rather, provide the magnitude of the inputs.
- Lines 40–41: “High nitrogen (N) to phosphorus (P) (N:P) ratios.” Please mention the median value or a range.
- Line 60: “2.5–3.3 times higher primary production.” Are these numbers precise to the first decimal place? If not, I would suggest “2–3 times higher.”
- Lines 60–64: How do high N:P ratios alone indicate P limitation? Shouldn't the absolute P concentration also matter? Many oligotrophic regions have low surface-water P concentrations but remain N-limited. Please clarify what process is supposedly P-limited and support this interpretation.
- Line 80: “δ¹⁵N signals could arise from isotopically depleted DON entering via the Strait of Gibraltar.” What is the nature of this DON? How labile is it, and how could its isotopic signature be transferred to phytoplankton and measured in POM?
- Line 81: Change “tracers” to “tracer.”
- Lines 72–86: I do not think these are necessarily contrasting results. Direct measurements are not a substitute for proxy results, but both must be considered. The direct measurements show decreasing nitrogen-fixation rates from west to east. Given the overlap in nitrogen-isotope endmembers, I would be cautious about relying on δ¹⁵N-POM alone to infer nitrogen fixation.
- Line 138: Please define DOCN at first use and clarify how it differs from DON and total dissolved nitrogen.
- Line 386: “The increased anthropogenic sources of nitrogen in the west.” Do you mean increased anthropogenic nitrogen inputs? If so, what evidence supports this interpretation?
- Lines 387–388: “Increased mixing in the western basin.” Where is the analysis of mixing presented that supports this conclusion?
- Line 391: “Where nutrient requirements are not exceeded.” How were these requirements calculated, and what evidence supports this statement?
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4372-RC2 -
RC3: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4372', Anonymous Referee #3, 05 Nov 2026
General comments:
The manuscript by Francis et al. presents how nitrogen inputs from nitrogen fixation and atmospheric deposition, and other N:P sources, modify the biogeochemistry of the modified Atlantic water (MAW) and Levantine Intermediate Water (LIW) around the Rhodes gyre in the eastern Mediterranean Sea. They provide a detailed investigation of potential sources and nitrogen cycle processes by comparing concentrations of dissolved organic nutrients and inorganic nutrients, partly together with their nitrogen isotopic composition of inflowing MAW with the outgoing MAW and the outgoing LIW. The paper targets the question about anthropogenic pollution in the Mediterranean Sea from a different angle, but lacks, in some parts, the full consideration of isotope effects and internal processes.
Major comments:
- LIW formation occurs during winter months, while this manuscript is based on cruises, which happened in late-spring/summer. The authors clearly state that the Rhodes gyre may be affected by different seasons, but still draw conclusions for the winter season based on their results from summer. The authors need to elaborate more on this connection and discuss potential effects in winter. For example, dry deposition is most important of atmospheric deposition in summer, while wet deposition plays an increasing role in winter (Mara et al., 2009), which hasn’t been discussed at all. Another example is the depth change of the nitracline and phosphacline with seasons. Please compare the depths from the summer cruise with other seasons to provide a robust interpretation of the seasonal supply of nitrogen but not phosphorus from deeper waters.
- LIW appears to be defined only by depth (>150 m), although the LIW depth varies throughout the Mediterranean Sea. The authors even give a formation depth from 150 to 700 m, which is quite a large depth range, in which the nutrients concentrations change a lot due to remineralization. I would suggest to define the LIW by potential density rather than depth, unless there is a clear explanation for this. This will most likely also affect the results of Figure 2 on the inflowing and outgoing MAW. And furthermore, mixing with deeper waters for surface would be a additional supply to surface waters in multiple regions of the Mediterranean, which has only been mentioned for the western Mediterranean near the Strait of Gibraltar.
- The Mara et al. (2009) paper does not say that the anthropogenic N deposition is greater in the western basin. In line 99, the authors should explain in more detail what greater impact means. But higher δ15N values should have a lower effect on the higher δ15N values that are observed in the western basin. The reasoning of increased anthropogenic sources in the western basin has also been used in the discussion (e.g., lines 386ff, 446-449, 554ff) and appears to be the foundation for their interpretation.
- The introduction is too general to prepare the reader for the following discussion about the LIW formation site. Until line 126, it is not obvious that the discussion will focus only on the surface processes, mainly in the far eastern Mediterranean.
- The authors make really strong conclusions without justifying their statements multiple times in the manuscript. For example, towards the end of section 3.1.2, they draw conclusions on the evolution of DON* and TDN* based on the poorly presented figure 2. In section 3.3 and 4.1, they set δ15N-PN of the outgoing MAW equal to the δ15N-PN inflowing MAW, although no measurements were possible here.
Minor comments:
- Be consistent with how to call the western and eastern Mediterranean. Sometimes it is east and west, sometimes it is west and east basin and sometimes W(w)estern and E(e)astern basin. The same holds true for nitrogen fixation: Please stick to nitrogen fixation and do not use fixation alone.
- The authors should specify atmospheric deposition. Do they only talk about anthropogenically sourced deposition? If not, Saharan dust is also part of the natural atmospheric deposition. What is the contribution of natural deposition and/or ammonium cycling with between the atmosphere and the surface waters as described in Altieri (2014, 2016)?
- Comparison of data to the Atlantic: In Figure 1a, it seems that seawater samples from the North Atlantic have been taken, too. It would be of great value if the authors could compare their Mediterranean data to the ones from the Atlantic in figure 2 and also in the discussion. In lines 207-208, the authors only mention that Atlantic data are not shown, but have δ15N values of 4.3-4.4‰. It is not clear which δ15N data the authors talk about: Is it TDN or nitrate or something else? Are these values actually from this cruise or taken from another reference? Depending on that, it is questionable if the Atlantic data represent the same season. Additionally, (if the values are δ15N-TDN), the data represent only minor changes and it is not clear how the authors link this to moderate productivity, except fluorescence. In line 585, the authors should mention what the DON concentration of the Atlantic is and set it in relation to their results.
- PN: It is also not clear, how the concentration-weighted δ15N-PN has been calculated. If I understood correctly the concentrations of the DCM were also taken into account, which introduces a large propagated uncertainty due to variable concentrations along the pathway in a pronounced peak at station 17. Additionally, the authors should explain in more detail how they interpret the δ15N-PN peak. Do they align the peaks with productivity due to full N consumption? Which seems unlikely due to the P-limitation.
Line 40: Please provide references for significant external nutrient inputs.
Line 50: … main intermediate water mass, and its formation site…
Lines 66-67: Wald et al., (2025) has conducted detailed analyses on nitrate δ15N and δ18O, which should be cited here, too.
Line 73: (as well as consuming phosphorus)? Do they mean even?
Lines 79-80: Please specify which depleted δ15N signals. And please include reference(s) here.
Line 97: …and large coastal cities contributes….
Line 119: Seasonal variability is not discussed.
Line 135: In my perspective, it is not needed to mention “full-depth water column samples” when the paper only focusses on the surface waters and the LIW formation. For what has these been used?
Line 138: What is DOCN? Please introduce. The concentrations of DOCN are not further discussed.
Line 141, Figures 2 and 4: The statements regarding nitrogen isotopes of nitrate are confusing. The caption of Figure 2 says that it was not measurable in surface water samples, Figure 4 shows one data point for the outgoing LIW and the methods section describes that 23 samples were measured. I understand that the nitrate concentration may have been too low to be analyzed in surface waters, but the effort of measuring nitrogen isotopes on nitrate for one single datapoint does not feel fair. Please describe what the data points in Figure 4 show. For nitrate δ15N, is it the average of these 23 samples, which were mentioned in the methods and/or is it an average of multiple stations and depths? Does the δ15N-PN also represent the concentration-weighted value?
Line 147: Do the standard deviations of repeat standards apply to every N form?
Lines 164ff/section 3.2: It appears that all data about the atmospheric aerosol samples come from Shelley et al. (2025). Why is this described in the methods and results sections then? Maybe I understand something wrong, but in my opinion, it is enough to compare their data to the atmospheric input data in the discussion without describing the methods. It also takes too much space relative to the points made in the discussion.
Line 176/178/185: Figure 1?
Figure 1b: It is not clear to me why the arrow directly south of Sicily is colored as incoming. Is this because it enters the western basin? I understood the colors as incoming/outgoing to/from the Rhodes gyre region.
Line 202-203: Please refer to figure.
Line 204-205: Please provide errors on Figure 2 to be able to judge on this conclusion of TDP.
Line 206: How do the authors link productivity to the nutrient concentrations and the δ15N values?
Line 212-213: Please explain how DON/P and TDN/P were calculated?
Line 217: What do you mean with “overall” δ15N? Only TDN is shown.
Line 217-218: Be more specific what you mean with the last sentence of this section.
Figure 2: The figure can be improved quite a lot. First, I would suggest to keep the axes the same for the same incoming and outgoing proxy, which would make it easier to compare the differences. Equally, keep the symbols and colors equal between the figures (figure 4 has different symbols or colors for the same proxy). Second, it should be explained what “average” means. Is it the average over multiple stations (within a specific radius) or depths (top 150 m?)? These averages should come with an error. The DOP concentration in the ingoing flow is equal to the one that is mentioned as a DOP peak in the outflowing path. This should be explained more. Or is all this within the error? Another point that the authors should think about is the decrease in δ15N-TDN in the incoming waters, which is not observed in the outgoing waters. It is expected that the preferential degradation of DOP to DIP would encourage N2 fixation, which should drive δ15N-TDN towards lower values on the outflowing path, which is not seen.
Line 232: Please add a comma after 4500 km. This would make the sentence easier to read.
Line 233: I wouldn’t call DON and DOP stable here. DON concentrations vary from 5 to 10 uM and DOP even more than double.
Lines 235ff: What is the advantage of using DON* and TDN* over N*? N* doesn’t look too different. And why are these parameters only calculated for the return path? Later in the paper, the authors talk about refractory DON, how does this affect their calculation?
Line 244ff: The authors call δ15N-TDN stable across the Mediterranean and directly afterwards they say that δ15N-TDN increases in the western basin. The errors of these measurements are quite big and the difference to what the authors call initial MAW input from the Atlantic appears to be within this error.
Lines 251ff: Please refer to figure A1.
Figure 3: Please adjust the color scale according to the data.
Line 356f: The depth range of 150-700 m is quite large and includes higher nitrate concentrations and low δ15N-NO3 due to remineralization in intermediate waters, which seems to be shown in figure 4b. The authors should take this into account when interpreting their data.
Line 376: Rephrase dissolved surface waters ratios.
Line 419f: How does the δ15N-TDN decline in the western basin match higher DIN deposition in that basin? Atlantic δ15N (not specified which N speciation, see comment further up) and the δ15N from atmospheric deposition are both high.
Figure 6: How does the seasonal variability look like as it is mentioned in line 528? Please provide the equation which is mentioned in line 531. Please check if a x-axis break or a logarithmic scale would make sense here. The DIP input is so low relative to the maximum value of 350 nM.
Section 4.2: In my opinion, it makes more sense to talk about the origin of DOP first before talking about its breakdown and contribution in driving N2 fixation. Then the authors could also take into account the degradation of DOP by APA from European aerosols, which contribute about 110-230 nmol m-2 d-1 to the Mediterranean based on their calculation in lines 566f.
Lines 582-583: Do the authors mean that PN in consumed or exported out of the surface waters?
Lines 587ff: The authors should take more caution here in explaining the δ15N-NO3 to lie between the δ15N of DON and PN. DON and PN degradation come with isotope effects, which should be taken into account.
Eq. (1): The rationale of the equation is not laid out well. Above the equation, the authors point out that PN apparently has a greater influence on the formation of δ15N-NO3, but this is not taken into account in the equation.
Lines 610 and 612: The values provided do not have the same units and are therefore complicated to compare. Related to this, in line 618, the authors talk about 1 uM.
Line 601: δ15N is not presented as a green square in Figure 4e.
Figure A1: it would be easier to have the distance along the MAW path instead of station numbers. Does the δ15N peak in the western basin correspond to station 17?
Figure A3 caption: Chapter 3? This should be “section” I guess.
Figure A4: R2 is much worse than in Figure 5 and deserves some discussion about alternative explanations.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4372-RC3
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 297 | 168 | 66 | 531 | 60 | 53 |
- HTML: 297
- PDF: 168
- XML: 66
- Total: 531
- BibTeX: 60
- EndNote: 53
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Please see attached pdf for comments