the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Detecting glacier-scale mass-balance heterogeneity using ASTER DEM differencing
Abstract. Glaciers in the Southern Andes show substantial spatial variability in mass balance, reflecting the combined effects of spatial variations in climate forcing and differences in glacier geometry. This study analyses elevation change patterns and climatic drivers for two contrasting glacier systems in southern Chile: the Queulat Glacier Complex and the stratovolcano Melimoyu. Elevation changes from 2000 to 2026 were derived from multi-temporal digital elevation models and analysed using a hypsometric approach to resolve elevation-dependent mass balance.
The results present a pronounced contrast between the two glacier systems. The Queulat Glacier Complex experiences consistently negative mass balance throughout the study period, with a rate of mass loss increasing from approximately −0.23 ± 0.39 to −0.63 ± 0.19 m w.e./yr. In contrast, Melimoyu maintained positive or near-balanced conditions in the early 2000s, followed by a transition to slightly negative mass balance in recent years. Elevation-dependent analyses show that mass loss in Queulat is predominantly associated with extensive low-elevation glacier tongues, while Melimoyu is characterised by a top-heavy hypsometry with a large accumulation area at high elevations.
Examination of downscaled ERA5 reanalysis data shows a consistent regional warming and a decrease in solid precipitation over the study period, while differences in total precipitation between the two sites remain small. This suggests that the contrasting glacier behaviour is not primarily driven by differences in climatic forcing, but rather by differences in glacier geometry and elevation distribution, which modulate the sensitivity to warming.
These results underline the key role of hypsometry and spatial glacier structure in determining individual glacier responses to climate change. The study indicates that glaciers under similar climatic conditions can exhibit substantially different mass-balance trajectories due to their geometry.
- Preprint
(16834 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: closed
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4284', Luc Girod, 14 Oct 2026
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Mariia Usoltseva, 02 Nov 2026
Dear Dr. Girod,
Thank you for reviewing the manuscript and offering suggestions for improvement. We appreciate the opportunity to improve the manuscript and have addressed all comments in detail below
1. We thank the reviewer for this detailed comment and for highlighting the limitations of the standard AST14DEM products. We fully acknowledge that AST14DEM products are known to contain artefacts related to image matching quality and satellite attitude jitter and that dedicated processing pipelines such as MMASTER can significantly improve DEM quality.
The primary objective of this study, however, was not to develop an optimal ASTER DEM processing workflow, but rather to evaluate whether long-term glacier elevation-change signals and glacier-scale contrasts can be retrieved from the existing AST14DEM dataset using a multi-temporal regression algorithm. The methodology is based on the use of multiple DEM acquisitions over extended periods (up to 26 years), reducing the impact of random errors and scene-specific artefacts through temporal averaging and robust regression rather than relying on elevation differences derived from individual DEM pairs.
Despite the limitations of the AST14DEM products, the resulting elevation-change patterns, glacier mass-balance estimates, and their temporal evolution are physically consistent and show strong agreement with independent regional observations reported in previous studies cited throughout the manuscript.
We agree that reprocessing the original ASTER scenes using MMASTER or a similar state-of-the-art workflow would likely reduce noise levels and improve data quality. However, given the objectives of the present study, we do not expect that such reprocessing would fundamentally alter the observed glacier-scale trends or the main conclusions regarding the role of glacier geometry and hypsometry.
To better acknowledge this limitation in the revised manuscript, we will expand the discussion section to explicitly discuss the known limitations of AST14DEM products, the potential benefits of dedicated photogrammetric processing workflows such as MMASTER, and the implications for future work.
2. The study uses a hypsometric gap-filling approach following common practice in geodetic glacier mass-balance studies. We agree that the original manuscript did not sufficiently describe the adopted methodology or place it within the context of the existing literature. In the revised manuscript, we have expanded the methods section to provide a detailed description of the gap-filling procedure and discuss the approach in the context of previous evaluations, including McNabb et al. (2019).
3. We agree that additional documentation would improve the transparency and reproducibility of the study. In the revised manuscript, we will provide a complete inventory of the ASTER scenes used in the analysis, including acquisition dates and scene identifiers. This information will be added as supplementary material due to the large number of used DEMs.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4284-AC1
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Mariia Usoltseva, 02 Nov 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4284', Anonymous Referee #2, 19 Nov 2026
This manuscript presents a time-series analysis of two glacier complexes in the Northern Patagonian Andes using ASTER-derived DEMs and climatological data, with the aim of investigating glacier-scale variability and the influence of glacier geometry and hypsometry on mass-balance patterns.
While the scientific questions are relevant, I have substantial concerns regarding the way the scientific gap is established, the selection of the study region, and, most importantly, the suitability of the dataset and methodology adopted.
In particular, the manuscript does not adequately acknowledge previous studies that have already provided individual glacier elevation-change and mass-balance estimates at regional and global scales. Furthermore, it relies on standard AST14DEM products despite their well-documented limitations for glacier elevation-change studies. These concerns were also raised by Reviewer 1, but I find that the authors' responses do not adequately address the fundamental methodological issues.
My main concerns are detailed below, following the arguments presented in the introduction to justify the study.
Major comments
- Scientific gap and previous studies (L23)
The authors state that existing regional and global datasets rely on spatial averaging and methodological generalization, which limits their ability to capture glacier-scale variability. I do not agree with this characterization, at least regarding Dussaillant et al. (2019), Brun et al. (2017), and Hugonnet et al. (2021). These studies provide elevation-change estimates and mass-balance calculations for individual glaciers across the Andes, Mountain Asia, and the complete Planet, respectively. They therefore do not simply rely on regional spatial averages, as suggested in the manuscript.
Furthermore, these studies developed and validated the methodological framework adopted by the authors, but over substantially larger geographical domains and glacier populations. Importantly, they also identified the limitations of standard AST14DEM products and used dedicated photogrammetric processing workflows to generate more reliable DEMs.
I therefore find the scientific motivation insufficiently established. The authors need to clarify what genuinely new knowledge this study provides compared with these previous assessments, particularly considering that they apply a less suitable version of the same underlying methodology to a much smaller number of glaciers.
- Selection of the study region and glaciers (L33 and L49)
I agree that neighbouring Patagonian glaciers can exhibit substantial differences in their response to similar climatic conditions, and that glacier geometry, hypsometry might be important factors in explaining this variability.
However, I question whether the selected Melimoyu and Queulat glacier complexes are particularly suitable for investigating these questions. Other regions of the Southern Andes, particularly the Southern Patagonia Icefield and Cordillera Darwin, exhibit much stronger contrasts between neighbouring glaciers, including advancing glaciers alongside others experiencing some of the highest rates of mass loss in the world. These regions would provide much more compelling examples for investigating the influence of local glacier characteristics under similar regional climatic conditions.
By comparison, the selected glacier complexes do not appear to exhibit similarly pronounced contrasts in their overall response. I therefore find that the choice of study region is not sufficiently justified in relation to the scientific questions posed by the authors.
- Suitability of the ASTER dataset (L40; and response to Reviewer 1, comment 1)
This is my most important methodological concern. The limitations of standard AST14DEM products for glacier elevation-change studies have been extensively documented, particularly the systematic artefacts associated with satellite attitude jitter and image matching (Girod et al., 2017).
As correctly pointed out by Reviewer 1, dedicated photogrammetric workflows such as MMASTER were specifically developed to address these limitations and have been used in previous regional and global assessments, including Hugonnet et al. (2021).
In their response, the authors acknowledge these limitations but argue that their multi-temporal regression and averaging approach sufficiently reduces their influence. I do not find this justification convincing. While temporal averaging may reduce random errors, it does not necessarily eliminate systematic errors introduced during the original DEM generation process. The authors do not provide a quantitative assessment demonstrating that their approach can reliably overcome these limitations.
Moreover, the argument that the resulting trends are physically consistent and agree with previous regional estimates does not independently validate the accuracy of their individual glacier estimates, particularly when comparisons involve products derived from the same underlying ASTER imagery but processed using more appropriate photogrammetric workflows.
I therefore consider the choice of AST14DEM products a fundamental weakness that directly affects the reliability of the main results. Given the relatively limited geographical extent of the study, reprocessing the original ASTER scenes using an established workflow would be a much more appropriate approach.
- Relevance of GlaMBIE and comparison with previous estimates (L45)
I do not find the reference to GlaMBIE (The GlaMBIE Team et al., 2025) particularly relevant to the argument developed here. GlaMBIE compares regional glacier mass-change estimates obtained using different observational methods, including glaciological, geodetic, altimetric, and gravimetric approaches. It does not provide individual glacier-scale information to support the argument concerning discrepancies between individual glacier estimates.
If the authors intend to discuss differences between individual glacier estimates obtained using different datasets or methodologies, comparisons with Dussaillant et al. (2019) and Hugonnet et al. (2021), alongside independent estimates such as Braun et al. (2019), would be more appropriate, especially for the Andes. The methodological comparisons presented in the supplementary material of Dussaillant et al. (2019) would also provide relevant context.
- Response to Reviewer 1: methodological concerns remain unresolved
I fully agree with Reviewer 1's concerns regarding DEM generation, gap-filling methodology, and data transparency. However, I find that the authors' responses do not adequately resolve the most fundamental issues.
Regarding DEM generation, the authors acknowledge the limitations of AST14DEM and the benefits of reprocessing the original imagery, but maintain their original approach without demonstrating that systematic errors are adequately addressed. Regarding gap filling, referencing McNabb et al. (2019) and providing a more detailed methodological description would improve the manuscript, but cannot compensate for potential systematic errors in the input DEMs. Similarly, providing a complete inventory of ASTER scenes would improve transparency and reproducibility but would not resolve the underlying data-quality concerns.
Overall, the responses mainly propose acknowledging the limitations and expanding the discussion, rather than addressing the methodological weaknesses themselves.
Final recommendation
I appreciate the effort invested in this analysis and agree that understanding glacier-scale variability in the Andes is an important scientific objective. However, I am not convinced that this manuscript provides a sufficiently robust or novel contribution compared with existing regional and global assessments.
The scientific gap is not adequately established, the selected glaciers do not provide particularly compelling examples for investigating the proposed questions, and the use of standard AST14DEM products introduces fundamental uncertainties that the authors have not demonstrated they can overcome.
These are not simply issues of documentation or presentation. Addressing them would require reconsidering the input dataset and potentially the study design itself. I therefore do not believe that the proposed revisions are sufficient to resolve the fundamental weaknesses of the manuscript.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4284-RC2
Status: closed
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4284', Luc Girod, 14 Oct 2026
This paper presents a time-series analysis of two glaciers in the Andes using ASTER DEMs and climatological data. The authors justify the work by pointing out that existing global compilations (e.g., Hugonnet et al., 2021) are relatively coarse and lack recent updates, which is a reasonable premise for a regional study.
However, there are major methodological and literature-related limitations that need to be addressed:
-
DEM Generation and Comparison: The study relies on standard AST14DEM products, which are well-documented to be unsuitable for detailed elevation change studies. As established by Girod et al. (2017, https://doi.org/10.3390/rs9070704), the automated SilcAst algorithm used to generate standard AST14DEMs lacks key corrections for satellite attitude jitter and uses a poor image correlation implementation. This routinely results in systematic cross- and along-track undulations adding to up to 20m in amplitude, severe vertical blunders ("salt-and-pepper"), and widespread matching failures over low-contrast snow and ice surfaces. Attempting to filter out these biases and artifacts post-hoc is a flawed strategy when dedicated pipelines—such as MMASTER (Girod et al., 2017), which was designed specifically to correct payload jitter and optimize matching over glaciated terrain—are publicly available and were used to create the input ASTER DEMs for Hugonnet et al. (2021).
Furthermore, comparing heavily post-filtered AST14DEMs against the global Hugonnet dataset—which derived its ASTER inputs from the same raw scenes processed with a jitter-corrected photogrammetric pipeline—is a methodologically flawed comparison. It essentially evaluates the success of post-hoc filtering against a dataset that solved the underlying photogrammetric errors at the source, but subsampled and time-interpolated its output for the sake of global homogeneity.
Given that the study focuses on only two glaciers, the number of ASTER scenes involved is likely quite small and manageable (the exact scene IDs or even the scene count are missing from the paper). The authors should re-process the raw ASTER L1A scenes using a tailored photogrammetric workflow rather than relying on uncorrected standard AST14DEM data. Complete documentation and setup instructions for the MMASTER workflow are freely available online (https://mmaster-workflows.readthedocs.io/en/latest/setup.html). If the authors encounter technical hurdles setting up the processing pipeline, I would be happy to point them in the right direction to help get their dataset properly processed.
-
Gap-Filling Methodology and Literature: While extensive effort appears to have been placed on gap filling, the specific interpolation algorithms used lack formal justification against established methodological literature. Most notably, the paper omits reference to key foundational work evaluating DEM gap-filling techniques, error propagation, and interpolation biases in glaciated terrain—specifically McNabb et al. (2019, https://doi.org/10.5194/tc-13-895-2019). While regional ASTER studies like Brun et al. (2017) demonstrate the necessity of gap filling, McNabb et al. (2019) provides the standard benchmark for evaluating which interpolation methods (e.g., hypsometric, local spatial, or temporal) minimize systematic elevation bias. The authors should explicitly define their gap-filling workflow and contextualize their chosen methodology against these established standard practices.
- Data Transparency and Filtering Documentation: The manuscript lacks essential documentation regarding the ASTER dataset selection and filtering pipeline. For a multi-temporal elevation change study, it is standard practice to include a comprehensive table detailing all acquired and selected scenes (including IDs, acquisition dates, cloud cover percentages, and whether each scene was retained or rejected with the rejection reason)
Addressing these core methodological and literature gaps will significantly strengthen the manuscript before the remainder of the analysis can be fully evaluated.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4284-RC1 -
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Mariia Usoltseva, 02 Nov 2026
Dear Dr. Girod,
Thank you for reviewing the manuscript and offering suggestions for improvement. We appreciate the opportunity to improve the manuscript and have addressed all comments in detail below
1. We thank the reviewer for this detailed comment and for highlighting the limitations of the standard AST14DEM products. We fully acknowledge that AST14DEM products are known to contain artefacts related to image matching quality and satellite attitude jitter and that dedicated processing pipelines such as MMASTER can significantly improve DEM quality.
The primary objective of this study, however, was not to develop an optimal ASTER DEM processing workflow, but rather to evaluate whether long-term glacier elevation-change signals and glacier-scale contrasts can be retrieved from the existing AST14DEM dataset using a multi-temporal regression algorithm. The methodology is based on the use of multiple DEM acquisitions over extended periods (up to 26 years), reducing the impact of random errors and scene-specific artefacts through temporal averaging and robust regression rather than relying on elevation differences derived from individual DEM pairs.
Despite the limitations of the AST14DEM products, the resulting elevation-change patterns, glacier mass-balance estimates, and their temporal evolution are physically consistent and show strong agreement with independent regional observations reported in previous studies cited throughout the manuscript.
We agree that reprocessing the original ASTER scenes using MMASTER or a similar state-of-the-art workflow would likely reduce noise levels and improve data quality. However, given the objectives of the present study, we do not expect that such reprocessing would fundamentally alter the observed glacier-scale trends or the main conclusions regarding the role of glacier geometry and hypsometry.
To better acknowledge this limitation in the revised manuscript, we will expand the discussion section to explicitly discuss the known limitations of AST14DEM products, the potential benefits of dedicated photogrammetric processing workflows such as MMASTER, and the implications for future work.
2. The study uses a hypsometric gap-filling approach following common practice in geodetic glacier mass-balance studies. We agree that the original manuscript did not sufficiently describe the adopted methodology or place it within the context of the existing literature. In the revised manuscript, we have expanded the methods section to provide a detailed description of the gap-filling procedure and discuss the approach in the context of previous evaluations, including McNabb et al. (2019).
3. We agree that additional documentation would improve the transparency and reproducibility of the study. In the revised manuscript, we will provide a complete inventory of the ASTER scenes used in the analysis, including acquisition dates and scene identifiers. This information will be added as supplementary material due to the large number of used DEMs.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4284-AC1
-
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4284', Anonymous Referee #2, 19 Nov 2026
This manuscript presents a time-series analysis of two glacier complexes in the Northern Patagonian Andes using ASTER-derived DEMs and climatological data, with the aim of investigating glacier-scale variability and the influence of glacier geometry and hypsometry on mass-balance patterns.
While the scientific questions are relevant, I have substantial concerns regarding the way the scientific gap is established, the selection of the study region, and, most importantly, the suitability of the dataset and methodology adopted.
In particular, the manuscript does not adequately acknowledge previous studies that have already provided individual glacier elevation-change and mass-balance estimates at regional and global scales. Furthermore, it relies on standard AST14DEM products despite their well-documented limitations for glacier elevation-change studies. These concerns were also raised by Reviewer 1, but I find that the authors' responses do not adequately address the fundamental methodological issues.
My main concerns are detailed below, following the arguments presented in the introduction to justify the study.
Major comments
- Scientific gap and previous studies (L23)
The authors state that existing regional and global datasets rely on spatial averaging and methodological generalization, which limits their ability to capture glacier-scale variability. I do not agree with this characterization, at least regarding Dussaillant et al. (2019), Brun et al. (2017), and Hugonnet et al. (2021). These studies provide elevation-change estimates and mass-balance calculations for individual glaciers across the Andes, Mountain Asia, and the complete Planet, respectively. They therefore do not simply rely on regional spatial averages, as suggested in the manuscript.
Furthermore, these studies developed and validated the methodological framework adopted by the authors, but over substantially larger geographical domains and glacier populations. Importantly, they also identified the limitations of standard AST14DEM products and used dedicated photogrammetric processing workflows to generate more reliable DEMs.
I therefore find the scientific motivation insufficiently established. The authors need to clarify what genuinely new knowledge this study provides compared with these previous assessments, particularly considering that they apply a less suitable version of the same underlying methodology to a much smaller number of glaciers.
- Selection of the study region and glaciers (L33 and L49)
I agree that neighbouring Patagonian glaciers can exhibit substantial differences in their response to similar climatic conditions, and that glacier geometry, hypsometry might be important factors in explaining this variability.
However, I question whether the selected Melimoyu and Queulat glacier complexes are particularly suitable for investigating these questions. Other regions of the Southern Andes, particularly the Southern Patagonia Icefield and Cordillera Darwin, exhibit much stronger contrasts between neighbouring glaciers, including advancing glaciers alongside others experiencing some of the highest rates of mass loss in the world. These regions would provide much more compelling examples for investigating the influence of local glacier characteristics under similar regional climatic conditions.
By comparison, the selected glacier complexes do not appear to exhibit similarly pronounced contrasts in their overall response. I therefore find that the choice of study region is not sufficiently justified in relation to the scientific questions posed by the authors.
- Suitability of the ASTER dataset (L40; and response to Reviewer 1, comment 1)
This is my most important methodological concern. The limitations of standard AST14DEM products for glacier elevation-change studies have been extensively documented, particularly the systematic artefacts associated with satellite attitude jitter and image matching (Girod et al., 2017).
As correctly pointed out by Reviewer 1, dedicated photogrammetric workflows such as MMASTER were specifically developed to address these limitations and have been used in previous regional and global assessments, including Hugonnet et al. (2021).
In their response, the authors acknowledge these limitations but argue that their multi-temporal regression and averaging approach sufficiently reduces their influence. I do not find this justification convincing. While temporal averaging may reduce random errors, it does not necessarily eliminate systematic errors introduced during the original DEM generation process. The authors do not provide a quantitative assessment demonstrating that their approach can reliably overcome these limitations.
Moreover, the argument that the resulting trends are physically consistent and agree with previous regional estimates does not independently validate the accuracy of their individual glacier estimates, particularly when comparisons involve products derived from the same underlying ASTER imagery but processed using more appropriate photogrammetric workflows.
I therefore consider the choice of AST14DEM products a fundamental weakness that directly affects the reliability of the main results. Given the relatively limited geographical extent of the study, reprocessing the original ASTER scenes using an established workflow would be a much more appropriate approach.
- Relevance of GlaMBIE and comparison with previous estimates (L45)
I do not find the reference to GlaMBIE (The GlaMBIE Team et al., 2025) particularly relevant to the argument developed here. GlaMBIE compares regional glacier mass-change estimates obtained using different observational methods, including glaciological, geodetic, altimetric, and gravimetric approaches. It does not provide individual glacier-scale information to support the argument concerning discrepancies between individual glacier estimates.
If the authors intend to discuss differences between individual glacier estimates obtained using different datasets or methodologies, comparisons with Dussaillant et al. (2019) and Hugonnet et al. (2021), alongside independent estimates such as Braun et al. (2019), would be more appropriate, especially for the Andes. The methodological comparisons presented in the supplementary material of Dussaillant et al. (2019) would also provide relevant context.
- Response to Reviewer 1: methodological concerns remain unresolved
I fully agree with Reviewer 1's concerns regarding DEM generation, gap-filling methodology, and data transparency. However, I find that the authors' responses do not adequately resolve the most fundamental issues.
Regarding DEM generation, the authors acknowledge the limitations of AST14DEM and the benefits of reprocessing the original imagery, but maintain their original approach without demonstrating that systematic errors are adequately addressed. Regarding gap filling, referencing McNabb et al. (2019) and providing a more detailed methodological description would improve the manuscript, but cannot compensate for potential systematic errors in the input DEMs. Similarly, providing a complete inventory of ASTER scenes would improve transparency and reproducibility but would not resolve the underlying data-quality concerns.
Overall, the responses mainly propose acknowledging the limitations and expanding the discussion, rather than addressing the methodological weaknesses themselves.
Final recommendation
I appreciate the effort invested in this analysis and agree that understanding glacier-scale variability in the Andes is an important scientific objective. However, I am not convinced that this manuscript provides a sufficiently robust or novel contribution compared with existing regional and global assessments.
The scientific gap is not adequately established, the selected glaciers do not provide particularly compelling examples for investigating the proposed questions, and the use of standard AST14DEM products introduces fundamental uncertainties that the authors have not demonstrated they can overcome.
These are not simply issues of documentation or presentation. Addressing them would require reconsidering the input dataset and potentially the study design itself. I therefore do not believe that the proposed revisions are sufficient to resolve the fundamental weaknesses of the manuscript.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4284-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 357 | 210 | 53 | 620 | 58 | 59 |
- HTML: 357
- PDF: 210
- XML: 53
- Total: 620
- BibTeX: 58
- EndNote: 59
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
This paper presents a time-series analysis of two glaciers in the Andes using ASTER DEMs and climatological data. The authors justify the work by pointing out that existing global compilations (e.g., Hugonnet et al., 2021) are relatively coarse and lack recent updates, which is a reasonable premise for a regional study.
However, there are major methodological and literature-related limitations that need to be addressed:
DEM Generation and Comparison: The study relies on standard AST14DEM products, which are well-documented to be unsuitable for detailed elevation change studies. As established by Girod et al. (2017, https://doi.org/10.3390/rs9070704), the automated SilcAst algorithm used to generate standard AST14DEMs lacks key corrections for satellite attitude jitter and uses a poor image correlation implementation. This routinely results in systematic cross- and along-track undulations adding to up to 20m in amplitude, severe vertical blunders ("salt-and-pepper"), and widespread matching failures over low-contrast snow and ice surfaces. Attempting to filter out these biases and artifacts post-hoc is a flawed strategy when dedicated pipelines—such as MMASTER (Girod et al., 2017), which was designed specifically to correct payload jitter and optimize matching over glaciated terrain—are publicly available and were used to create the input ASTER DEMs for Hugonnet et al. (2021).
Furthermore, comparing heavily post-filtered AST14DEMs against the global Hugonnet dataset—which derived its ASTER inputs from the same raw scenes processed with a jitter-corrected photogrammetric pipeline—is a methodologically flawed comparison. It essentially evaluates the success of post-hoc filtering against a dataset that solved the underlying photogrammetric errors at the source, but subsampled and time-interpolated its output for the sake of global homogeneity.
Given that the study focuses on only two glaciers, the number of ASTER scenes involved is likely quite small and manageable (the exact scene IDs or even the scene count are missing from the paper). The authors should re-process the raw ASTER L1A scenes using a tailored photogrammetric workflow rather than relying on uncorrected standard AST14DEM data. Complete documentation and setup instructions for the MMASTER workflow are freely available online (https://mmaster-workflows.readthedocs.io/en/latest/setup.html). If the authors encounter technical hurdles setting up the processing pipeline, I would be happy to point them in the right direction to help get their dataset properly processed.
Gap-Filling Methodology and Literature: While extensive effort appears to have been placed on gap filling, the specific interpolation algorithms used lack formal justification against established methodological literature. Most notably, the paper omits reference to key foundational work evaluating DEM gap-filling techniques, error propagation, and interpolation biases in glaciated terrain—specifically McNabb et al. (2019, https://doi.org/10.5194/tc-13-895-2019). While regional ASTER studies like Brun et al. (2017) demonstrate the necessity of gap filling, McNabb et al. (2019) provides the standard benchmark for evaluating which interpolation methods (e.g., hypsometric, local spatial, or temporal) minimize systematic elevation bias. The authors should explicitly define their gap-filling workflow and contextualize their chosen methodology against these established standard practices.
Addressing these core methodological and literature gaps will significantly strengthen the manuscript before the remainder of the analysis can be fully evaluated.