Integrating predictive uncertainty into satellite-based flood mapping
Abstract. Flood extent maps derived from satellite imagery are increasingly important for flood response and risk management. Although recent deep learning models have substantially improved segmentation accuracy, they typically provide deterministic predictions without indicating their reliability. This limits their operational value in regions affected by cloud contamination, spectrally ambiguous floodwater, or environmental conditions insufficiently represented in the training data. This study develops an uncertainty-aware flood mapping framework by integrating Evidential Deep Learning (EDL) into an operational cloud-aware mapping workflow. The proposed framework simultaneously generates flood extent and pixel-level predictive uncertainty, enabling uncertainty information to be incorporated directly into the mapping process. Its performance is evaluated against a deterministic UNet++ baseline and two established uncertainty estimation approaches, Deep Ensemble and MC Dropout, using the extended WorldFloods dataset. Across the test dataset, the three uncertainty-aware methods achieved comparable IoU values, all consistently outperforming the deterministic baseline, indicating that predictive uncertainty can be incorporated without degrading segmentation performance. Their uncertainty behaviour and computational requirements, however, differed substantially. Among the evaluated approaches, the evidential formulation provided the most favourable operational trade-off by preserving segmentation performance, producing stable epistemic uncertainty estimates across diverse flood events, and requiring only a single model evaluation per image tile. These findings demonstrate that uncertainty quality should be regarded as a complementary evaluation criterion alongside segmentation accuracy. By combining competitive segmentation performance, informative uncertainty estimates, and computational efficiency, the proposed framework provides a practical framework for operational uncertainty-aware satellite-based flood mapping.
The abstract requires improvements in writing style and clarity. The abstract should provide a concise description of the proposed method, including its novelty.
The paper mainly focuses on deep learning and segmentation for flood mapping. The core of this article is the DL component. However, it is unclear how this study makes contributions in this areas. The framework seems to be largely derived based on Portalés-Julià et al., 2023, and the core technical component, i.e., EDL, is from Sensoy et al. 2018. As a result, the paper does not seem to offer a new method, but is an application of existing methods in flood mapping. Similar applications of EDL for segmentation exist.
From an application perspective, the results presented require major improvements:  the PAvPU results are difficult to interpret because the thresholds appear to be selected from retention curves on the same test set; thresholds should be fixed using validation data before test-set evaluation. Further, EDL’s IoU (0.8117) exceeds the deterministic baseline (0.7992) but is below Deep Ensemble (0.8299) and MC Dropout (0.8218), and the comparison is confounded by the EDL model’s different cloud-class weight.