Performance of a 2.05 µm coherent DIAL-Doppler Lidar for CO2 eddy-covariance turbulent flux measurements
Abstract. Understanding the global carbon cycle requires observation of carbon diffusivity within the convective boundary layer (CBL). In particular, observations of the vertical evolution of CO2 turbulent flux would enable the evaluation of the spatial representativeness of in situ flux measurements and the quantification of entrainment-flux impacts on such measurements. Coherent lidar is a promising technology for this purpose, as it can perform ground-based range-resolved measurements of CO2 mixing ratio and vertical wind speed along the height of the CBL. Still, achieving a sufficiently low statistical error in the CO2 mixing ratio measurement is a key challenge in CO2 turbulent flux measurements. For this purpose, a 2.05 µm coherent differential absorption lidar (CDIAL) has been developed. This lidar features a hybrid fiber/bulk amplification chain that provides 20 kHz high pulse repetition frequency and 1 mJ pulse energy. These characteristics allow for a random error of about 30 ppm in CO2 mixing ratio measurements and 0.01 m s-1 in wind velocity, with a spatiotemporal resolution of 13 s and 115 m, enabling turbulent flux measurements. This paper presents a performance assessment of CO2 turbulent flux measurements with this CDIAL lidar, under typical meteorological conditions of CO2 uptake by photosynthesis. A new expression for random error after spatial averaging is introduced, that is verified using Monte Carlo simulations and statistical analysis on experimental measurements. CO2 fluxes measured by the lidar are discussed with respect to flux measurements made by in situ instruments. The lidar enables flux measurements over the convective boundary layer height (around 1000 m), and achieves a minimum flux detection limit of 11 µmol m-2 s-1 at a spatiotemporal resolution of 350 m and 4 hours, making it well suited for future geophysical studies of CO2 turbulent fluxes.
The manuscript “Performance of a 2.05 μm coherent DIAL-Doppler Lidar for CO2 eddy-covariance turbulent flux measurements,” submitted by Mathys Thiers et al. describes an investigation that is relevant to Atmospheric Measurement Techniques in the field of remote sensing technique regarding a 2-μm coherent differential absorption lidar (CDIAL) for CO2 and wind measurements. The paper provides a detailed description of the instrument, the new expression for random error after spatial averaging, and measurement performance of CO2 turbulent flux with focusing on the detection limits and measurement biases using the CDIAL. The derivation of new expression for random error is interesting approach. Overall, the paper is well structured, readable and will be valuable to the scientific community. I believe that the manuscript will be of interest to the readers of Atmospheric Measurement Techniques. I therefore recommend the publication after revision according to the minor comments given below.