Snow–Ice Morphological Relationship under Sea Ice Surface Topographic Control: Evidence from In Situ RTK Measurements
Abstract. Sea ice surface roughness plays a critical role in snow redistribution and accumulation; however, the spatial scale at which its influence is most effective remains poorly constrained by field observations. During the 15th Chinese National Arctic Research Expedition in 2025, synchronous measurements of ice surface elevation and snow depth were conducted using a lightweight Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) Real-Time Kinematic (RTK) system. Observations were collected over multi-year sea ice in the central Arctic north of 85° N, encompassing both level ice and deformed ice regimes. Multi-scale moving-window analysis revealed a strong scale dependence in the statistical relationship between sea ice surface roughness and mean snow depth. The ensemble-mean correlation coefficient reached a maximum at a window radius of approximately 7–10 m (r ≈ 0.56), indicating that this scale dominates the coupling between surface roughness and snow redistribution. At this characteristic scale, rougher ice surfaces generally corresponded to greater snow depths, reflecting the enhanced trapping and retention of wind-blown snow by complex surface topography during wind-driven transport. These findings provide observational constraints for parameterizing snow redistribution processes on sea ice and offer guidance for selecting appropriate spatial resolutions in remote-sensing products aimed at resolving roughness-controlled snow processes.
Sea ice surface topography plays an important role in the snow redistribution process. A clear relationship between snow and ice morphology would be very beneficial for improving the formulation of the snow redistribution process. In this paper, the authors tried to use in situ measurements from the Arctic together with GNSS to quantify such a relationship. The content of the paper falls clearly within The Cryosphere scope and is believed to be helpful to relevant snow studies. The Introduction, and Observations and Data Processing are very well written.
However, as can be seen from Figure 6, almost all the snow depth is about 5 cm, except for the station nice0201. Such a small snow depth generally has very limited effects on the snow morphology, as it basically mimics the underlying ice surface morphology. As a result, the correlation between the snow surface morphology and the underlying ice surface morphology would be very close to 1, see detailed explanations in the General Comments 4 and 6. My opinion is that the present data is not sufficient to achieve solid meaningful conclusions for the studying topic. I suggest the authors either find more similar observations with larger snow depths, or change the topic of the study.
General comments:
Specific comments: