the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Improvements of a subcanopy snow model and its interception conveyed by observations from a mid-altitude alpine site
Abstract. Understanding the accumulation and melt of snow is essential to capture the hydrology of mountainous areas. Forests impact significantly the amount of snow on the ground through diverse processes, including the interception of snowfall. The Multi-Energy-Balance (MEB) module within the SURFEX/ISBA surface model has been designed to capture these impacts for climate applications. However, the original version of MEB coupled with the physically-based snow model Crocus (MEB/Crocus) fails to reproduce the subcanopy snow dynamics observed at Col de Porte, a mid-altitude alpine snow observatory. In this study, based on new observations at Col de Porte and recent literature, we propose an enhanced version of MEB/Crocus by revisiting solid interception processes: maximum interception, interception rate, unloading and melt. This new version reduces the positive bias of subcanopy simulations by at least 40 % for snow water equivalent and snow depth, through an enhanced interception, longer interception duration and associated sublimation and melt. The wide range of observations at Col de Porte furthermore confirms that MEB/Crocus has a satisfactory representation of the different processes involving the forest cover, including vegetation temperatures, ground temperatures and radiation under forest. With this new version of MEB/Crocus, the model’s net performance remains unchanged -or is even slightly improved- at boreal sites. We also take the opportunity to use new observations to explore the sensitivity of the model to a top-of-canopy forcing in wind and air temperature. While forcing the model with air temperature from above the canopy is found to have no significant impact, having a top-of-canopy wind is key to the representation of the evolution of snow under forest as it strongly affects the sensible and latent heat fluxes. The improvements and enhanced understanding of the model sensitivity pave the ground to extending the applications of MEB, from climate to the hydrology of mid-latitude mountainous areas.
- Preprint
(4218 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(434 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4137', Anonymous Referee #1, 26 Oct 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4137', Anonymous Referee #2, 10 Nov 2026
Pauze et al. evaluate an operational snow-hydrological model with and without new parameterizations of the mass and energy balance of snow intercepted by the canopy, using novel observations of throughfall, unloading, and snow depth beneath the canopy. They also investigate the influence of the microsite location of the meteorological forcing measurements. The observational dataset is compelling, but I found the paper's structure and approach difficult to follow. With substantial restructuring and a stronger emphasis on process evaluation, these observations could make an important contribution to the forest hydrology literature. In its current form, however, the paper's contribution appears primarily relevant to users of the operational model. My comments below address the framing, descriptions of hydrological processes, and analysis.Major comments1. Framing and scientific contributionThe title and emphasis on the new throughfall and unloading observations led me to expect a stronger evaluation of the processes governing canopy snow interception and release. Instead, the paper primarily implements existing parameterizations and demonstrates improvements in an operational model. The study needs a clearer scientific question and a stronger explanation of how its findings advance understanding beyond this particular application. The framing around more of an operational report should be revised to make the contribution to the broader hydrological community explicit.The unique observations provide an opportunity to test the assumptions and relationships underlying the parameterizations. Why does model performance improve, and which processes account for that improvement? A process-level evaluation would help answer these questions. I suggest reframing the study around the evaluation of existing relationships for snow interception, maximum canopy snow load, unloading, and temperature-index melt. Then use this comparison to justify the use of certain parameterizations that are available (e.g., those of Storck et al., 2002;Hedstrom & Pomeroy 1998; Roesch, 2003; Cebulski et al., 2025; 2026).2. Description of hydrological processesThe introduction and model description need more precise terminology and clearer explanations of the relevance of the processes discussed. Several processes are listed without establishing their connections to hydrological or climate applications. Although the observations are presented as an opportunity to advance understanding, the specific knowledge gaps concerning interception and unloading remain unclear.Please clarify terms such as "non-interception" and "canopy simulations," consider if canopy-snow interactions are relevant to an alpine setting, and describe the interception parameterization more precisely. In particular, how does wind speed influence interception in the model? The definition and use of Kn also need to be checked and clarified compared to the original formulations Hedstrom and Pomeroy (1998) paper.3. Correspondence between model setup and manual observationsThe figures and statistics make it difficult to assess model performance against the ensemble of manual observations collected across a range of canopy densities. What canopy density was used in the model, and how does it relate to the locations sampled? Consider configuring the model using the mean canopy density of the observation locations, or otherwise explaining how the model configuration represents those locations. A closer correspondence between the model setup and the observational sampling would make the comparison easier to interpret.More generally, the paper would benefit from shorter, more focused sections and a table comparing performance statistics across model configurations. Each section should make clear which question it addresses and what the reader should conclude from the analysis.4. Direct evaluation of throughfall and unloadingFigure 6 explains the simulated mass-balance changes responsible for improved snowpack performance. However, improved agreement in snow depth and SWE does not establish whether the individual canopy processes are represented correctly. Stronger evaluation against the throughfall and unloading observations, accounting for their sampling intervals and limitations, would help determine whether the improvements arise for the right physical reasons. The observations of throughfall and unloading offer an opportunity to evaluate these fluxes directly. Can the corresponding simulated fluxes be compared with the measurements? Please explain how the timing and duration of bucket sampling affect the attribution of collected snow to throughfall and unloading, and whether an event-based analysis would be more appropriate. Could these observations be included in Figure 6? Do the buckets hold liquid meltwater? In that case you have observations of throughfall, unloading and drip.5. Meteorological forcing and order of the resultsThe comparison of forcing data measured above the canopy and in gaps is a useful component of the study. However, the scientific question addressed by the first results section is unclear. This section could be shortened substantially: a concise statistical summary, or scatter plots with regression lines where appropriate, would likely be more effective than a full page describing average meteorological conditions. I think this section would also be best suited at the end of the results, once you justify your model choices, then look at the sensitivity analysis of the forcing data at the end once your unknowns are better constrained.Minor commentsThe opening pages contain several unclear expressions and statements that need stronger support or more precise descriptions of hydrological processes. The manuscript also needs careful editing for grammatical errors and incomplete sentences.- Lines 1–2: Explain how canopy interception influences snow accumulation and persistence on the ground.- Lines 3–4: Specify what is meant by "climate applications."- Line 6; lines 69–71: Explain how the recent literature informs the selected parameterizations.- Line 8: Clarify what is meant by "subcanopy simulations" and specify the simulated variables being discussed.- Lines 35–38: Explain how the "canopy effects" influence albedo and specify which albedo is being discussed.- Line 76: Define "non-interception" or replace it with a more precise term.- Lines 81–83: Clarify what is meant by "alpine forest and climate conditions." Distinguish forests in the Alps from the alpine zone above treeline.- Lines 140–142: Clarify whether the "poles" are snow-depth stakes, locations for manual SWE sampling, or both, and describe how each variable is measured.Given the major comments above I have stopped my detailed minor revisions here. Once the major comments are addressed, I would be happy to provide additional minor comments on the manuscript.Citation: https://doi.org/
10.5194/egusphere-2026-4137-RC2
Data sets
Supplement to : Improvements of a subcanopy snow model and its interception conveyed by observations from a mid-altitude alpine site T. Pauze et al. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21264265
Model code and software
SURFEX software supplement for "Improvements of a subcanopy snow model and its interception conveyed by observations from a mid-altitude alpine site" T. Pauze et al. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21263777
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 327 | 203 | 62 | 592 | 83 | 66 | 66 |
- HTML: 327
- PDF: 203
- XML: 62
- Total: 592
- Supplement: 83
- BibTeX: 66
- EndNote: 66
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Please find my comments in the attached document