the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Wintertime VOC concentration measurements in a Northern traffic supersite demonstrate the strong role of anthropogenic terpene emissions in VOC chemistry
Abstract. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are key drivers of urban atmospheric chemistry, acting as precursors to ozone and secondary organic aerosol (SOA). Terpenes, typically considered biogenic, may also have important anthropogenic sources in cities, although distinguishing these contributions remains challenging.
We measured terpenes and other VOCs (C6–C15) using in situ TD-GC-MS at a traffic supersite in Helsinki during winter 2022, when biogenic emissions were minimal. Additional offline measurements of lighter hydrocarbons (C2–C5) were conducted at residential and urban background sites. Most VOCs, including benzene, furfural, naphthalene, and p-cresol, showed higher concentrations at the residential and background sites, indicating a strong influence from wood combustion. In contrast, terpenes were elevated at the traffic site, suggesting emissions from other anthropogenic activities.
At the traffic site, terpenes had a mean concentration of 164 ng m⁻³, contributing less than 1% of total measured VOC mass. Despite their low abundance, they played a significant role in atmospheric chemistry due to high reactivity, accounting for 7 % of hydroxyl radical reactivity, 59 % of ozone reactivity, and 65 % of nitrate radical reactivity among the measured VOCs. Combined with their strong SOA formation potential, this highlights the importance of anthropogenic terpene emissions for urban air quality.
Intermediate-volatility VOCs (IVOCs, C11–C15) were present at low concentrations and generally had minor contributions, although undetected compounds may still be relevant. Among them, sesquiterpenes showed notable ozone reactivity (23 %) despite concentrations below 3 ng m⁻³.
- Preprint
(1046 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(469 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4128', Anonymous Referee #1, 16 Sep 2026
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Heidi Hellén, 30 Oct 2026
We thank the referee for the valuable comments and suggestions. We have carefully considered all comments and revised the manuscript accordingly. Detailed responses are provided below.
Summary: This study investigates wintertime volatile organic compound (VOC) and intermediate-volatility organic compound (IVOC) concentrations (C2–C15) in Helsinki, Finland, using in situ TD-GC-MS at an urban traffic supersite alongside offline canister/tube sampling at residential and background sites in winter 2022. The authors show that while terpenes comprise <1% of total measured VOC mass at the traffic site, their high reactivity causes them to dominate nitrate radical (65%) and ozone (59%) reactivity, while serving as potential precursors for wintertime secondary organic aerosol (SOA) formation. Conversely, residential and urban background sites are dominated by biomass burning markers (e.g., benzene, furfural, naphthalene) from wood combustion.
This is an important and high-enough quality data set of wintertime urban measurements, particularly for speciated monoterpene and sesquiterpenes, that it will be of great use and interest to the greater scientific community. The primary evidence for anthropogenic monoterpene emissions from VCP usages presented by the authors is a higher average monoterpene concentration at the traffic site than the “urban background” and residential sites. While this is interesting, I don’t feel like it is a compelling enough argument to support the thesis in the title – “the strong role of [wintertime] anthropogenic terpene emissions in VOC chemistry.” I recommend that a more through analysis be complete before resubmission.Response: Thank you for this valuable overall assessment. In response to the comment, we have removed the word “strong” from the title.
General Comments
Comment: The primary conclusion for anthropogenic monoterpenes at the traffic site is comparison to the other two sites; however, there is a large imbalance in the number of samples collected between the various sites. The primary in situ dataset spans over a month (N=609), whereas the spatial comparison across sites (residential vs. background vs. traffic) and C2–C5 NMHC data rely on a 4-day offline sampling window (N=4 canisters). Drawing seasonal or city-wide spatial conclusions from a 4-day window introduces substantial temporal bias.Response: As the reviewer points out, the imbalance in the number of measurements among the sites is unfortunate. However, the data from the residential and urban background sites were used only as supplementary evidence and did not form the basis of our primary conclusions. To make this clearer to readers, we have restructured the Abstract.
Our main findings are based on the in situ measurements conducted at the Traffic supersite. The cold weather conditions during the campaign, under which biogenic emissions were expected to be negligible, allowed us to conclude that the observed monoterpenes were predominantly of anthropogenic origin.
Comment: The analysis relies on the use of OH-, O3-, and NO3-reactivities and SOAP comparisons. Can the author’s also provide more context for the relative importance of the observed reactivities? The overall abundance of the reactive VOCs is low to moderate at best and one would expect the oxidants to also be in low concentration given the low-temperature and low-light conditions. Would one reasonably expect a significant amount of ozone or SOA production under these conditions?
Response: We thank the reviewer for this important comment. We agree that the calculated reactivities and SOAP values require additional context regarding oxidant availability and secondary aerosol formation, and we have expanded sections 3.4.1 and 3.4.2 accordingly.
Although photochemical OH production is expected to be reduced under low-light winter conditions, ozone concentrations were not particularly low. The mean O₃ concentration during this campaign was 42 µg m⁻³, comparable to 41 µg m⁻³ measured during our summer/autumn 2019 campaign (Saarikoski et al., 2023), when terpene ozonolysis was identified as a major pathway producing VOC oxidation products. Thus, O₃ was readily available for VOC oxidation also during winter. Combined with the high calculated O₃ reactivity of mono- and sesquiterpenes, this suggests that terpene ozonolysis can remain relevant despite relatively low terpene concentrations. We added discussion on this into section 3.4.1. (lines 370-384).
Furthermore, independent aerosol mass spectrometer (AMS) measurements showed that SOA constituted on average 67.7% of the organic aerosol during the campaign, while SV-OOA, representing less-aged and more locally influenced SOA, accounted for approximately 15% (Teinilä et al., 2025). Although the total SOA fraction may include aged and regionally transported aerosol, these observations indicate that secondary aerosol was abundant and are consistent with ongoing secondary processing during the winter campaign. We added discussion on this into section 3.4.2. (Lines 414-421).
We have now clarified in sections 3.4.1 and 3.4.2 that the calculated OH-, O₃-, and NO₃-reactivities and reactivity-scaled SOAP values describe the relative importance of compounds and oxidation pathways, rather than absolute oxidation or SOA production rates. We also emphasize that we do not imply substantial local O₃ production; rather, the measured O₃ concentration demonstrates that sufficient O₃ was present for oxidation of highly reactive VOCs.Comment: A more in depth comparison to the summer time monoterpene composition measured at the same site as presented in Saarikoski et al. 2023.
Response: We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We added a discussion of this topic and a new Figure 4 to new section 3.2.2 (lines 277-283):
‘In an earlier campaign conducted at the same site in summer/autumn 2019 (Saarikoski et al., 2023), monoterpene concentrations were, on average, three times higher than those observed in the present study. The difference was particularly pronounced for α-pinene, β-pinene, and Δ3-carene, for which concentrations were 4, 14, and 4 times higher, respectively, in summer/autumn 2019 (Figure 4). The elevated concentrations during the summer period are consistent with a strong contribution from biogenic sources, as these compounds are among the typical monoterpenes emitted by boreal trees (e.g., Hakola et al., 2001, 2006, 2022; Hellén et al., 2018). For limonene only 1.5 times higher concentrations were measured.’Comment: Comparison of the monoterpene composition (not just the overall abundance) to the other sites in winter 2022 study.
Response: We thank reviewer for the suggestion. We now added a new figure 4 to describe monoterpene composition at the sites and discussion of compositional differences into section 3.3 ‘Comparison of traffic supersite concentrations to residential and urban background sites.’
Comment: Including more discussion on the potential emission sources of anthropogenic VCPs near the traffic site. A Google Earth view shows potential for restaurants/cooking and pedestrian traffic, are there traffic counts that can be compared to summertime or diel activity rates (i.e, business district that is only busy during the daytime or mixed use of some residential and business).
Response: We thank reviewer for the suggestion. We have added description on traffic counts and possible other sources into section 2.1 (lines 78-84).
Comment: Authors could compare observed monoterpene distribution to other studies of indoor air or common VCP products.
Response: We found that limonene made a particularly large contribution to the monoterpene concentrations at the Traffic Supersite. This is consistent with observations from indoor environments and many VCP products, such as cleaning agents. We have added a discussion of this to Section 3.2.2 (Lines 267–268).
Comment: Can the authors present contrasting evidence for possible contributions of monoterpenes from woodsmoke that impacted the other measurement sites, etc?
Response: We thank the reviewer for raising this point. We agree that residential wood combustion is a potential source of also monoterpenes during winter.
At the residential site lot of houses are using wood as additional heating during cold winter months and it is known to be impacted by wood combustion emissions. Impact of wood combustion has been detected earlier for example in higher particulate PAH concentrations than at the traffic site (Hellén et al. 2017).
However, in the current study terpene concentrations at this residential site were lower than at the traffic site. Even though monoterpenes are known to be emitted from the wood combustion (Hartikainen et al. 2018), their emissions are lower than emissions of benzene, furfural, naphthalene and p-cresol, which showed higher concentrations at the residential and urban background sites than at the traffic.
We added a comment on the wood combustion as a monoterpene source into the new version of the manuscript section 3.3 lines 335-336.
Hellén, H., Kangas, L., Kousa, A., Vestenius, M., Teinilä, K., Karppinen, A., Kukkonen, J., and Niemi, J. V.: Evaluation of the impact of wood combustion on benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) concentrations; ambient measurements and dispersion modeling in Helsinki, Finland, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 17, 3475–3487, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-17-3475-2017, 2017Comment: More in depth analysis of the timeseries and diel profiles for the monoterpenes. For instance, in Saarikoski (2023) Figure 3d. the, the monoterpenes have a diel profile that I would typically expect for monoterpenes with highest concentrations during the morning “burst” when natural emissions kick-off and the boundary layer is still quite low. This contrasts nicely with the anthropogenic diel profile shown in Figure 3b. The wintertime study presented here shows that the monoterpenes and aromatics have a very similar diel profile lending evidence of the anthropogenic sources. For the timeseries, one would expect that monoterpene emissions from anthropogenic sources will differ in composition, magnitude, and timing from biogenic sources. Biogenics are dependent on tree-type and meteorology (temperature, light, boundary layer) vs. anthropogenic monoterpene sources which depend on type and timing of human activities (rush hour, mealtimes, etc.). One would expect to see sharp/variable changes in the monoterpene concentration AND composition as different sources impact the measurement site. Can the author’s see any of these anomalies in their dataset?
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. We have expanded the analysis of the temporal behaviour and diel profiles of the monoterpenes. We added more detailed diel profiles of aromatic hydrocarbons and terpenes to the Supplementary Information (Fig. S2) and now discuss their contrasting diurnal behaviour in more detail in section 3.2.2 lines 252-260.
We also examined the temporal behaviour and composition of the individual terpenes. The terpene composition varied during the campaign, with particularly pronounced contributions from limonene during the daytime/afternoon period. The elevated 3-carene concentrations may additionally indicate contributions from local wood material related or some other sources, as biogenic emissions are expected to be very low during this winter campaign.
We have added this discussion to the revised manuscript (Section 3.2.2, lines 264-270) and added the diel profiles as Fig. S2.Comment: A PMF or other statistical analysis could be useful to identify the VOC emission profiles for sources impacting the traffic site.
Response: We agree that PMF or other statistical analyses could provide valuable insights into the VOC source profiles at the traffic site. However, a separate study is ongoing to investigate VOC source contributions using PMF, together with AMS measurements of PM₁ chemical composition and other pollutant data. In the present study, we aimed to highlight the importance of anthropogenic terpene concentrations using this unique wintertime dataset, collected under cold conditions (temperatures below 0 °C), when biogenic emissions were expected to be negligible.
Technical Comments
Comment: Please provide a brief meteorological discussion in the experimental section. Including discussion of average temperatures, shifts in weather patterns, precipitation events, etc. as these are critical to better understanding of the ambient observations.
Response: We added a new section 3.1 ‘meteorology and air mass characteristics’ into to the manuscript with the reference to Teinilä et al. (2025), where meteorology and air mass characteristics during the campaign are described in more detail.
Comment: A bit more discussion on the technical aspects of the TD-GC-MS measurements would be helpful rather than just referring to another paper. Including a very brief overview of the calibration and instrument blanks would be useful here. Were blanks collected (sending zero air or nitrogen through the sampling inlet to the instrument) during this experiment to account for any instrument artifacts for possible contamination? Please include the number of samples for each site in the text portion of the manuscript in addition to the table header.
Response: A description of the calibration procedures, blank measurements, and the number of in situ samples has been added to Section 2.2 (Lines 114–120). The numbers of canister and sorbent tube samples are also provided in the manuscript text.
Comment: For the canister samples, it sounds like you had to dilute the ambient air samples with nitrogen to get enough pressure to analyze them on the GC system. How did you account for this dilution factor? What was the final pressure in the canisters prior to analysis? Did you run any blanks of just the nitrogen in a cleaned canister? Was ozone removed before the canister sample collection?
Response: We added a description of the canister pressurizing into the manuscript in section 2.2 (lines 128-130) ‘Before analysis, the canisters were over pressurized with pure nitrogen (99.9999%) to ~1.6 bar above the atmospheric pressure. Pressure of the canisters were measured before and after the pressurizing. Dilution factor was calculated by the ideal gas law.’ Blank canisters with nitrogen 99.9999% are run regularly with our system. Ozone was not removed.
Comment: Whenever possible in the text, please be as specific as possible. For instance, you say on L157 that the “contribution of PAHs was very low.” Just state the number (overall abundance and/or percentage of total measurements).
Response: We added specific percentage for PAHs (line 184) and went through the manuscript adding specific numbers whenever suitable.
Comment: There isn’t much discussion of “Episodes 1-3” in the manuscript. If they are significant events, I would include more discussion; otherwise, remove.
Response: More description on the episodes were added to the new section 3.1. Meteorology and ai mass characteristics’ (Lines 171-181).
Minor typos/errors:Comment: Journal formatting instructions were accidentally left in the text at Lines 72–75 ("The headings of all sections... Footnotes should be avoided...") and must be removed.
Response: We have removed these text fragments from the revised manuscript.Comment: Subsection numbering under Section 2 is broken (e.g., "1.1 Measurement sites" appears under "2 Methods"). Section headings throughout the manuscript need consistent hierarchical numbering.
Response: This has been correctedComment: Figure 2. Can you post these in log scales so the reader can better see the small values? At least for panels a and b.
Response: Panels a and b have been converted to logarithmic scales.Comment: Figure S1, it would be best to show the time series with gaps, better representing times when the instruments were not running.
Response: Figure S1 has been revised to show the time series with measurement gaps.Comment: Line 172: Duplicate word in caption ("supersite in during the 2022").
Response: This has been correctedComment: Line 280: Reference misspelling ("Shauer et al., 2001" vs. "Schauer et al., 2001" in reference list).
Response: This has been correctedComment: Line 378: Grammatical error ("participated the data analysis" should read "participated in the data analysis").
Response: This has been correctedCitation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4128-AC1
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Heidi Hellén, 30 Oct 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4128', Anonymous Referee #2, 22 Sep 2026
Summary
This study measures VOCs using TD-GC-MS in urban Helsinki during winter supplemented by offline measurements of hydrocarbons at other residential and urban background sites with a focus on implications for air quality. Multiple VOCs were elevated at the background sites and associated with biomass burning sources, while highly reactive terpenes, usually associated with biogenic sources in the literature, were elevated at the traffic site.
The authors provide a general overview of the important role of VOCs in urban atmospheric chemistry, how policy has improved air quality, and how the contribution of sources has shifted over time, while also emphasizing the general difficulty of source attribution. The wintertime focus is important for isolating the contribution of biogenic emissions. The paper is easy to read and has notable findings, but would benefit from further analysis, organization, and more quantitative reporting.
General Comments
A summary table of the available instruments, their temporal range, and sampling frequency at each site would be useful either in the manuscript or supplemental information.
How comparable is the air mass history of 3 sites? The traffic supersite and urban background supersite are close enough together that they likely receive identical air masses, but comparisons to the residential site may differ for that reason alone. Air mass history appears to be discussed in Line 160 to 168 to explain episodes of increased concentrations.
Have you looked into techniques such as Positive Matrix Factorization for stronger source attribution?
Alternatively, have you looked into proxies for residential wood combustion such as heating degree days? A comparison with a simple linear regression would better support the association of specific species to residential wood combustion.
Overall, please be more quantitative with your findings and avoid the use of dominant, higher, or lower without providing numbers in text rather than leaving it up to the reader to dig through tables. Please see specific comments.
Specific Comments
Line 157, please quantify how much lower in text.
Line 158, citation needed.
Line 160, please quantify the variability in text.
Line 168, please quantify how much higher in text.
Line 193, please quantify what is meant by dominant.
Line 198, please provide citation for weekend elevated residential wood combustion.
Line 202, please quantify how much higher in text.
Line 227, please provide the correlation in text.
Lines 246 and 247, please quantify how much higher in text.
Line 287, please quantify how much higher n text.
Technical Corrections
Lines 71-76 need to be removed.
Are paragraph breaks required for Lines 142 and 146?
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4128-RC2 -
AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Heidi Hellén, 30 Oct 2026
We thank the referee for the valuable comments and suggestions. We have carefully considered all comments and revised the manuscript accordingly. Detailed responses are provided below.
General Comments
Comment: A summary table of the available instruments, their temporal range, and sampling frequency at each site would be useful either in the manuscript or supplementary information.
Response: We have added a table summarizing the instrumentation, measurement periods, and sampling frequencies to the Supplement (Table S2).
Comment: How comparable is the air mass history of the three sites? The traffic supersite and urban background supersite are close enough together that they likely receive identical air masses, but comparisons to the residential site may differ for that reason alone. Air mass history appears to be discussed in Lines 160–168 to explain episodes of increased concentrations.
Response: Simultaneous VOC measurements were conducted at the three study sites (urban background, residential site, and traffic supersite) during a four-day period (14–18 February). This period coincided with a long-range transport (LRT) episode of PM₂.₅ (Episode 3), during which air mass back trajectories originated from Eastern Europe (see Teinilä et al., 2026, Fig. S8). PM₂.₅ concentrations increased at all air quality monitoring stations across the Helsinki metropolitan area during this LRT episode, supporting the assumption that the regional background conditions and long-range transported air masses were similar at the three study sites, despite the maximum distance of 8.5 km between them.
Comment: Have you looked into techniques such as Positive Matrix Factorization for stronger source attribution? Alternatively, have you looked into proxies for residential wood combustion such as heating degree days? A comparison with a simple linear regression would better support the association of specific species to residential wood combustion.
Response: We agree that PMF and other statistical analyses could provide additional insights into VOC source profiles at the traffic site. However, a separate study is currently underway to investigate VOC source contributions using PMF in combination with AMS measurements of PM₁ chemical composition and other pollutant data.
In the present study, our aim was to highlight the importance of anthropogenic terpene concentrations using this unique wintertime dataset collected under cold conditions (temperatures below 0 °C), when biogenic emissions were expected to be negligible.Comment: Overall, please be more quantitative with your findings and avoid the use of dominant, higher, or lower without providing numbers in the text rather than leaving it up to the reader to dig through tables. Please see specific comments.
Response: We agree with this suggestion and have revised the manuscript to include quantitative values in the text wherever appropriate.
Specific Comments
Comment: Line 157, please quantify how much lower in text.
Response: We added “< 0.5%” to the text (Line 184).Comment: Line 158, citation needed.
Response: We added the references of Gu et al. (2021) and Aas et al. (2026) at Line 186.Aas, W., Salameh, T., Wegener, R., Hellén, H., Jaffrezo, J.-L., Roldin, P., Alonso-Blanco, E., Alastuey, A., Amelynck, C., Arduini, J., Bergmans, B., Bertrand, M., Borbon, A., Bourtsoukidis, E., Bouvier, L., Butterfield, D., Buxbaum, I., Ceburnis, D., Claude, A., Colette, A., Colomb, A., Darfeuil, S., Dernie, J., Desservettaz, M., Díaz-Ramiro, E., Dufresne, M., Dubus, R., Duval, M., Dury, M., Font, A., Fossum, K. N., Freney, E., Gangoiti, G., Ge, Y., Gomez, M. C., Gómez-Moreno, F. J., Gohy, M., Gros, V., Hamer, P., Hellack, B., Herrmann, H., Holla, R., Holubová, A., Jensen, N. R., Jokinen, T., Jones, M., Käfer, U., Kesper, L., Klemp, D., Kubistin, D., Marinoni, A., Mazzini, M., Thuy Dinh, V. N., Ovadnevaite, J., Petäjä, T., Portillo-Estrada, M., Přívozníková, J., Putaud, J.-P., Reimann, S., Renzi, L., Riffault, V., Ritchie, S., Robins, C., Rodríguez de Torres, B. A., Poulain, L., Rüdiger, J., Sanocka, A., Saez de Camara Oleaga, E., Schoon, N., Seco, R., Simmons, I., Simon, L., Simpson, D., Solberg, S., Tison, E., Thomasson, A., Tsyro, S., Twigg, M., Tykkä, T., Verreyken, B., Watne, Å., Williams, K., Yáñez-Serrano, A. M., Yeung, K., Ylivinkka, I., and Yttri, K. E.: Measurement report: Spatial variability of VOCs, ozone, and carbonaceous aerosols during the 2022 European summer heatwave, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 26, 8717–8751, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-26-8717-2026 , 2026.
Gu, S., Guenther, A., and Faiola, C.: Effects of Anthropogenic and Biogenic Volatile Organic Compounds on Los Angeles Air Quality, Environ. Sci. Technol., 55, 12191–12201, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.1c01481, 2021.
Comment: Line 160, please quantify the variability in text.
Response: We added that VOC concentrations were, on average, 1.1 times higher on weekdays than on weekends (Line 188). Compound-specific ratios are provided in Table 1.Comment: Line 168, please quantify how much higher in text.
Response: We added that the mean PM₂.₅ concentration was 1.4, 2.2, and 1.9 times higher during Episodes 1, 2, and 3, respectively, compared with the campaign average (Line 172).Comment: Line 193, please quantify what is meant by dominant.
Response: We revised the sentence and added the contribution of aromatic hydrocarbons to the total VOC concentration (Line 220).Comment: Line 198, please provide citation for weekend elevated residential wood combustion.
Response: We added the following reference (Line 224):Kangas, L., Kukkonen, J., Kauhaniemi, M., Riikonen, K., Sofiev, M., Kousa, A., Niemi, J. V., and Karppinen, A.: The contribution of residential wood combustion to the PM2.5 concentrations in the Helsinki metropolitan area, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 24, 1489–1507, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-24-1489-2024, 2024.
Comment: Line 202, please quantify how much higher in text.
Response: We added that the concentrations were 1.8 times higher (Line 229).Comment: Line 227, please provide the correlation in text.
Response: The reported correlation and the associated explanation from Savolainen et al. (2025) have been added to the text (Lines 260–261).Comment: Lines 246–247, please quantify how much higher in text.
Response: We added the contribution of hexane (Line 301) and the concentration range for higher alkanes (>C10) (Line 301-303).Comment: Line 287, please quantify how much higher in text.
Response: We added that higher alkanes were 1.3 times higher at the Traffic Supersite (Line 353).Technical Corrections
Comment: Lines 71–76 need to be removed.
Response: These lines have been removed.Comment: Are paragraph breaks required for Lines 142 and 146?
Response: These paragraph breaks have been removed.Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4128-AC2
-
AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Heidi Hellén, 30 Oct 2026
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 294 | 172 | 58 | 524 | 81 | 56 | 58 |
- HTML: 294
- PDF: 172
- XML: 58
- Total: 524
- Supplement: 81
- BibTeX: 56
- EndNote: 58
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Toni Tykkä
Elli Suhonen
Kimmo Teinilä
Teemu Lepistö
Jarkko V. Niemi
Topi Rönkkö
Hilkka Timonen
Arnaud P. Praplan
This study presents a new approach to quantify anthropogenic terpene emissions by measuring VOCs during winter, when biogenic emissions are negligible. Measurements in Helsinki showed that although anthropogenic terpenes accounted for less than 1 % of VOC mass, they made a disproportionately large contribution to atmospheric reactivity. The findings highlight the importance of including anthropogenic terpene emissions in urban air quality studies and atmospheric chemistry models.
This study presents a new approach to quantify anthropogenic terpene emissions by measuring VOCs...
Summary
This study investigates wintertime volatile organic compound (VOC) and intermediate-volatility organic compound (IVOC) concentrations (C2–C15) in Helsinki, Finland, using in situ TD-GC-MS at an urban traffic supersite alongside offline canister/tube sampling at residential and background sites in winter 2022. The authors show that while terpenes comprise <1% of total measured VOC mass at the traffic site, their high reactivity causes them to dominate nitrate radical (65%) and ozone (59%) reactivity, while serving as potential precursors for wintertime secondary organic aerosol (SOA) formation. Conversely, residential and urban background sites are dominated by biomass burning markers (e.g., benzene, furfural, naphthalene) from wood combustion.
This is an important and high-enough quality data set of wintertime urban measurements, particularly for speciated monoterpene and sesquiterpenes, that it will be of great use and interest to the greater scientific community. The primary evidence for anthropogenic monoterpene emissions from VCP usages presented by the authors is a higher average monoterpene concentration at the traffic site than the “urban background” and residential sites. While this is interesting, I don’t feel like it is a compelling enough argument to support the thesis in the title – “the strong role of [wintertime] anthropogenic terpene emissions in VOC chemistry.” I recommend that a more through analysis be complete before resubmission.
General Comments
The primary conclusion for anthropogenic monoterpenes at the traffic site is comparison to the other two sites; however, there is a large imbalance in the number of samples collected between the various sites. The primary in situ dataset spans over a month (N=609), whereas the spatial comparison across sites (residential vs. background vs. traffic) and C2–C5 NMHC data rely on a 4-day offline sampling window (N=4 canisters). Drawing seasonal or city-wide spatial conclusions from a 4-day window introduces substantial temporal bias.
The analysis relies on the use of OH-, O3-, and NO3-reactivities and SOAP comparisons. Can the author’s also provide more context for the relative importance of the observed reactivities? The overall abundance of the reactive VOCs is low to moderate at best and one would expect the oxidants to also be in low concentration given the low-temperature and low-light conditions. Would one reasonably expect a significant amount of ozone or SOA production under these conditions?
This analysis would be greatly supported by additional information, context, and discussion. Examples I include here are only suggestions and subject to the author’s discretion:
Technical Comments
Minor typos/errors: