the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Drivers of net community production in the bottom of Arctic pack ice
Abstract. The availability of nutrients to sea-ice microbial communities varies as drifting pack ice traverses distinct hydrographic regimes and experiences episodic mixing events. Vertical turbulent fluxes generated by processes such as ice movement and wind can enhance nutrient resupply at the ice–ocean interface, potentially influencing community composition and net community production. In this study, we evaluate the relationships between bottom sea-ice algal communities and oceanic conditions during a sea-ice drift study north of Svalbard, which crossed different branches of the Atlantic Water inflow to the Arctic over the Yermak Plateau and the Sofia Deep. Despite elevated nitrate concentrations in under-ice waters associated with the Svalbard Branch of Atlantic Water inflow, the largest nutrient and heat fluxes to the bottom ice occurred during a storm event. These fluxes coincided with increased biomass-specific net community productivity but also enhanced algal biomass loss through melt. At the same time, snow redistribution during the storm increased snow depths and reduced light availability at the bottom ice, affecting net community production. Independent of nutrient conditions, the transition from net heterotrophy (oxygen consumption) to net autotrophy (oxygen production) occurred when under-ice transmitted photosynthetically active radiation exceeded a daily range of 1.1 to 3.5 µmol m–2 s–1. Although nutrient supply remains important, our results suggest that light availability may exert a stronger control on sea-ice net community production than nutrient supply when nutrients are not critically depleted. We further highlight the importance of episodic storm events in modifying nutrient and heat vertical fluxes, and light availability at the ice–ocean interface, thereby contributing to regional variability in ice algal bloom dynamics.
- Preprint
(1610 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(1593 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- AC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4031 - MSS data', Rosalie McKay, 21 Jul 2026
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4031', Anonymous Referee #1, 17 Aug 2026
The submitted manuscript with the title “Drivers of net community production in the bottom of Arctic pack ice” by McKay et al. provides detailed information on the sea-ice algal community found in the Central Arctic north of Svalbard and how its net community production rates (NCP) respond to changes in nutrient and light availability. This study was undertaken during a sea ice drift of a single floe encountering different water masses and a storm event during the main ice algal growth period in May. While this scenario of changes in habitat conditions is more frequently encountered by ice bottom communities, their impacts are still poorly understood, which makes this unique study an important knowledge contribution. The manuscript is overall well written and structured, presents results in a concise manner and discusses findings in detail. Overall, I suggest minor revisions that should address found inconsistencies in the format of plots, minor technical errors and requests to provide more details for certain method and result descriptions.
I also would like to ask the authors to further look into one larger concern I have with the discussion and drawn conclusions from the presented results that relate to the impact of light limitation on calculated NCP. The authors conclude that the storm event turned the overall NCP budget from net autotrophic to net heterotrophic due to a redistribution of average snow depths above the calculated snow thickness threshold that would allow for positive NCP rates. While this may be true short-term, the authors base this conclusion mainly on modelled, not measured results. Hence, I partly disagree with this conclusion for these reasons:
- Derived photosynthetic parameters from optode measurements (table 3) show a shade acclimation of second-year ice communities with higher alpha and lower compensation irradiance at higher snow depths (one above calculated 26 cm snow thickness threshold). This indicates a capacity of the present ice algae community to acclimate to higher snow depths after storm event to reach positive NCP.
- The possible impact of photoacclimation on NCP rates is only briefly discussed and only for the possibly high-light acclimated FYI community beneath lower snow thicknesses. I find this discussion very incomplete given that there are three more measurements.
- It’s quite striking that the highest NCP rate was found after the storm at the SYI site with snow depths near the threshold and despite a strong decrease in ice algal biomass. I would say this highlights how efficient the shade-acclimated community in the SYI is, especially if nutrient limitation doesn’t play a role. I would even argue that their previous conditioning to low light levels under high snow depth (see site 2, thick snow depth PE parameters) gives them an advantage to high-light acclimated FYI communities after the storm event. And as the authors point out, the floe mainly consisted of SYI, which should decrease the impact of a “struggling” FYI community. Furthermore, under-ice phytoplankton studies have shown that microalgal communities can acclimate to changing light conditions within a few days, which may further make the net heterotrophic state of the floe rather short-lived.
- The authors did not revisit a FYI side after the storm to confirm their conclusions of net heterotrophy. The sampled SYI seems to not support their conclusion. This is somewhat a limitation of this study, which should be acknowledged.
Overall, I think the relationship between NCP and ice algal photophysiology need to be discussed in more detail, similar to the detailed discussion of the impact of nutrient availability on NCP.
I further structured my detailed comments for the authors into two sections (“Specific comments” and “Technical comments”) as suggested by the journal review guidelines.
Specific comments:
Line 14: For a plain language summary, I suggest not using the term “physical forcing” and use something more explanatory such as “changes to habitat conditions”
Line 66: Please further define “topography” – Does it refer to “bathymetry” or “sea ice topography”?
Lines 90 and 91: I suggest clarification “autotrophic and heterotrophic processes WITHIN ICE”
Figure 1: Chlorophyll a concentration in Fig. 1b) should be provided in unit “mg m-2” to match text values. Please include explanation of abbreviation “MSS”. Spelling of first-year and second-year sea ice is incorrect.
Line 150: It would be helpful if it is made clear which of the MSS probes are used to estimate vertical flux later. Otherwise it is somewhat of a surprise in section 2.8.2. And when was the MSS instrument calibrated?
Section 2.5: How optical terms are started is somewhat convoluted and confusing for anyone who isn’t an expert in marine optics. Hence I would suggest some modifications:
- Line 175: Delete the term “irradiance” after radiation (PAR) as the term is now already defined as “photosynthetically active radiation” and doesn’t need the add-on “irradiance”.
- Throughout this section and following, just use “PAR” instead of “irradiance”, “irradiance withing the PAR spectrum”, except for line 176, where you also should add the actual PAR range: “surface downwelling and upwelling irradiance within the PAR spectral range (as photon flux density, 400 – 700 nm, μmol photons m–2 s–1)”.
- State type of radiometer and keep model in brackets to be concise: e.g.
Lines 178 – 180: “Measurements were recorded with a LI–COR LI–1500 logger and the upwelling/downwelling surface PAR was consecutively recorded using an integrated planar PAR sensor (LI–190R 2π, LI–COR)….”
Lines 180 – 181: “Under-ice transmitted PAR was recorded using an integrating scalar PAR sensor (LI–193 4 π)…”
Line 182: Was the snow put back into the hole during the under-ice arm deployment to avoid artificial increase in under-ice light values?
Line 185: Does the used model to calculate surface PAR at the sampling site include the cloud cover during that time period. Please specify. If it’s not included, this could have let to an overestimation of surface PAR.
Lines 195 – 196: Why was only surface water sampled if this study investigated vertical nutrient fluxes from the deeper Atlantic water? This study does not provide any measured or literature AW nutrient values for this region to support their discussion of increased surface nutrient levels due to vertical upwelling. (this comment also applies to lines 505 – 507: try to provide some literature values).
Line 224: Was ice core temperature measurements started from he top or bottom of the core? Please specify.
Line 225: When was the conductivity meter calibrated and what is its accuracy?
Line 235: Can you provide filtration volumes for these parameters, which would enable a repetition of this sampling?
Line 236: For how long and at what temperature were POC/PON filters combusted?
Line 237: How and when was the Turner fluorometer calibrated?
Section 2.8.1: I suggest including the NCP formula that uses all the defined variables. Also see my comment about “E” instead of “I” for irradiance
Lines 360 – 362: In this explanation of how the snow thickness threshold to reach zero NCP was derived, it is not explained if PE parameters were kept the same in the NCP calculation. If so, it should be highlighted in the discussion that this does not necessarily reflect the in situ algal photophysiological response.
Line 382: How was the mixed layer depth derived?
Line 383: How thick was the “warmer AW core” at Site 2?
Line 398: If the statistical test does not show any significant differences between measurement points for silicic acid, you cannot describe it as “decreasing”. The stats result says, there is no change. (also line 501 – “insignificant decrease” – statistically speaking, those two words rule each other out.)
Line 400: Was the diapycnal diffusivity enhanced at all sites?
Line 423: The text says that table 2 is only summarizing physical characteristics, while the table is actually also providing biochemical results. Those aren’t described in the text at all. Please add a description of those results.
Section 3.1.: I suggest including a plot to visualize flow cytometry and total cell abundance results. It’s difficult to grasp these big numbers and differences from the text.
Line 475: Was this transmittance value of 2.56% measured?
Line 548: The floe did not only consist of SYI as stated here.
Line 550: As stated in the methods, ice thickness has a minimal impact on light transmission compared to snow.
Section 4.2.2.: Please see my general comment of a lack of sufficient discussion in this section.
Technical comments:
Line 29: unit is missing term “photons”
Lines 99: Providing more than four digits in GPS coordinates is unreasonable
Throughout manuscript, make sure spelling of first-year sea ice and second-year sea ice is correct (dash is often missing).
The format of all figures should be the same throughout the manuscript, including using the same letter format for “(a)” vs “a)” vs “a”, using variable “depth” (not pressure) with positive numbers for profiles (negative in Fig. 4), and using a “real” minus in axis labels and units. Plot axes should also always start and end with a number and not have numbers only show somewhere in the middle of the axis (Figs. 2 & 4).
Line 132: “sampling site”
Line 133: Figure 1b) does not indicate water sampling at Site 3.
Line 135: Table 1 does not provide coordinates even though text is claiming it does.
Table 1: Table caption or sampling date in the table should indicate which year it was sampled.
Line 185: Specify “The resultant PAR transmittance”
Line 208: Specify “9 cm diameter”
Line 209 (and throughout manuscript): Only biochemical measurements were performed, no “geo”
Line 210: Include “..and TO make data from…”
Line 230: Specify “Nutrient samples from melted sea-ice bottom and water samples..”
Line 235: Specify “Chlorophyll a, POC and PON from melted sea-ice bottom samples…”
Line 245: Use same format “2–20 µm”
Line 247: The term “diluted melt” should be rephrased.
Line 268 (and throughout manuscript): The official symbol for irradiance is “E” not “I” (used in old literature). Hence, it should be “PE” parameters and “Es” and “Ec” for photosynthetic efficiency and photoacclimation parameter, respectively.
Line 270 (and throughout manuscript)” Use “mL” for unit
Lines 272 -273: Be concise “measured with an integrating scalar PAR probe (Walz US–SQS/L) and logger (Walz model ULM–500)” (I’m adding the the term “integrating” because none of these radiometers measures spectral light, they just provide one PAR value)
Line 284: Unit needs capital “L” for liters
Line 313: Equation 1 – variable “z” is not defined (just further below)
Line 340: The used letter for “Under-ice PAR transmittance” as “TS” is misleading as the lower “s” is used in the equation for snow. Hence, I would suggest using “TUI”. Also be careful to define “T” as transmittance, and not “transmission” (Line 241).
Line 370: Can you provide the number of hours for the storm in the text?
Line 371: Does indicated speed refer to “drift speed”?
Figure 3: See general comments. But also, salinity should not have unit. And if the x axis label already says “Days in May”, each measurement day doesn’t need to also say May
Table 2: Explain all used abbreviations in the table caption.
Table 3: Is not just showing PE parameters. It’s also showing NCP and chlorophyll results. This should be included in the table caption. Also these are “integrated” chlorophyll values
Table 4: Again, this table is not just showing PE parameters, but also integrated Chlorophyll. Please include that in the caption.
Lines 477 – 479: The grammar of this sentence is off, which makes it hard to understand. Please try to rephrase.
Line 552: Add “Here, the highest chl a was FOUND in the bottom of FYI…”.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4031-RC1 -
AC2: 'Reply on RC1', Rosalie McKay, 20 Oct 2026
We would like to thank the reviewer for their comments. In response we have expanded several sections of the Discussion, which have improved the clarity and impact of the manuscript. Specifically, we have (1) expanded the discussion of algal photophysiology and NCP (lines 625–635, 722–733), particularly in SYI, and (2) more explicitly acknowledged the limitations associated with not revisiting a FYI site ( lines 675–676). These changes better highlight the implications of our findings in the context of climate-driven changes in sea-ice composition. In particular, the loss of SYI, which may support algal communities capable of more rapid acclimation to changing light conditions, which could alter the response of ice-associated primary producers to changing sea-ice environments. In our response, we copy each of the Reviewer comments, with our responses directly afterwards as bullets.
I also would like to ask the authors to further look into one larger concern I have with the discussion and drawn conclusions from the presented results that relate to the impact of light limitation on calculated NCP. The authors conclude that the storm event turned the overall NCP budget from net autotrophic to net heterotrophic due to a redistribution of average snow depths above the calculated snow thickness threshold that would allow for positive NCP rates. While this may be true short-term, the authors base this conclusion mainly on modelled, not measured results. Hence, I partly disagree with this conclusion for these reasons:
- Derived photosynthetic parameters from optode measurements (table 3) show a shade acclimation of second-year ice communities with higher alpha and lower compensation irradiance at higher snow depths (one above calculated 26 cm snow thickness threshold). This indicates a capacity of the present ice algae community to acclimate to higher snow depths after storm event to reach positive NCP.
- The possible impact of photoacclimation on NCP rates is only briefly discussed and only for the possibly high-light acclimated FYI community beneath lower snow thicknesses. I find this discussion very incomplete given that there are three more measurements.
- It’s quite striking that the highest NCP rate was found after the storm at the SYI site with snow depths near the threshold and despite a strong decrease in ice algal biomass. I would say this highlights how efficient the shade-acclimated community in the SYI is, especially if nutrient limitation doesn’t play a role. I would even argue that their previous conditioning to low light levels under high snow depth (see site 2, thick snow depth PE parameters) gives them an advantage to high-light acclimated FYI communities after the storm event. And as the authors point out, the floe mainly consisted of SYI, which should decrease the impact of a “struggling” FYI community. Furthermore, under-ice phytoplankton studies have shown that microalgal communities can acclimate to changing light conditions within a few days, which may further make the net heterotrophic state of the floe rather short-lived.
- The authors did not revisit a FYI side after the storm to confirm their conclusions of net heterotrophy. The sampled SYI seems to not support their conclusion. This is somewhat a limitation of this study, which should be acknowledged.
Overall, I think the relationship between NCP and ice algal photophysiology need to be discussed in more detail, similar to the detailed discussion of the impact of nutrient availability on NCP.
- Thank you for the encouragement to expand the discussion of ice algal photophysiology and its relationship with NCP, and thereby improve the completeness of the discussion. In response, we have expanded Section 4.2.3 Lines 625–635:
- “A striking finding was that thicker-snow SYI communities displayed higher α* and Ec lower (e.g. the lowest Ec was observed at Site 2 with the thickest snow cover), reflecting greater efficiency of light utilisation and an ability to maintain net photosynthesis at lower irradiances, respectively, consistent with the well-documented capacity of sea-ice algae for low-light photoacclimation (Torstensson et al., 2018; Van Leeuwe et al., 2018). Additionally, Ek values were highest at the last site, suggesting a shift toward higher-light acclimation as irradiance increased. Similar seasonal increases in Ek have been observed in Arctic sea-ice algal communities and interpreted as evidence of improved acclimation to the progressively increasing under-ice light environment (Manes & Gradinger, 2009). Together, these patterns suggest that SYI algal communities were capable of adjusting their photosynthetic physiology across the seasonal light gradient, from strong low-light acclimation under snow-covered conditions toward greater acclimation to higher irradiance later in the season (Galindo et al., 2017).”
- Lines 675–676 “These conditions may result in the initially higher biomass within FYI being particularly vulnerable to loss during periods of elevated heat flux, however, we were not able to sample FYI following the storm.”
- In addition, we added this discussion to Section 4.3. lines 722–733:
- “However, these modelled estimates do not account for the capacity of sea-ice algal communities to photoacclimate to changing light conditions. In particular, the higher α* and lower Ec observed under thicker snow in our SYI communities suggest a capacity for acclimation to low-light conditions (Section 4.2.2). Given that photoacclimation in sea-ice algal communities can occur over timescales of days to weeks (Leu et al., 2015; Lizotte & Sullivan, 1991), it is possible that the heterotrophic conditions predicted by the model represented a transient state, rather than a persistent community-level condition. As irradiance increased, photoacclimation could have progressively increased photosynthetic efficiency and enabled communities to transition towards net autotrophy. Indeed, seasonal observations of Arctic bottom-ice communities have demonstrated such transitions from periods of net heterotrophy to sustained net autotrophy as light availability and algal productivity increased (Campbell et al., 2017; Suzuki et al., 1997). Thus, incorporating physiological acclimation into estimates of sea-ice community production may be important for determining the persistence and ecological significance of modelled heterotrophic conditions and our estimates might overestimate the role of net heterotrophy.”
- We added this condition to the conclusion lines 763–766 “…, though SYI algae in contrast to FYI algae may be predisposed to acclimate more rapidly to changing light conditions. The loss of SYI could therefore alter the response of ice-associated primary producers to changing sea-ice environments.”
I further structured my detailed comments for the authors into two sections (“Specific comments” and “Technical comments”) as suggested by the journal review guidelines.
Specific comments:
Line 14: For a plain language summary, I suggest not using the term “physical forcing” and use something more explanatory such as “changes to habitat conditions”
- Line 14: We have changed this to “environmental changes” and adjusted the wording to maintain a word count of 500 characters.
Line 66: Please further define “topography” – Does it refer to “bathymetry” or “sea ice topography”?
- Line 69: We have changed this to bathymetry.
Lines 90 and 91: I suggest clarification “autotrophic and heterotrophic processes WITHIN ICE”
- Line 95: We have made this change.
Figure 1: Chlorophyll a concentration in Fig. 1b) should be provided in unit “mg m-2” to match text values. Please include explanation of abbreviation “MSS”. Spelling of first-year and second-year sea ice is incorrect.
- We have incorporated these changes. For the chl a values, we have now included the corresponding µg L–1values in the text alongside integrated chl a in Table 3 to facilitate comparison with other studies, which commonly report chl a concentrations in µg L–1.
Line 150: It would be helpful if it is made clear which of the MSS probes are used to estimate vertical flux later. Otherwise it is somewhat of a surprise in section 2.8.2. And when was the MSS instrument calibrated?
- We use the shear probes to estimate the vertical fluxes. The MSS instrument was calibrated just before the cruise for the shear probes, and temperature and salinity were calibrated against the ship-based CTD.
- We added line 150: "The profiler had precision conductivity, temperature, and pressure sensors as well as microstructure sensors including two airfoil shear probes (used for computing the fluxes later)"
Section 2.5: How optical terms are started is somewhat convoluted and confusing for anyone who isn’t an expert in marine optics. Hence I would suggest some modifications:
- Line 175: Delete the term “irradiance” after radiation (PAR) as the term is now already defined as “photosynthetically active radiation” and doesn’t need the add-on “irradiance”.
- Throughout this section and following, just use “PAR” instead of “irradiance”, “irradiance withing the PAR spectrum”, except for line 176, where you also should add the actual PAR range: “surface downwelling and upwelling irradiance within the PAR spectral range (as photon flux density, 400 – 700 nm, μmol photons m–2 s–1)”.
- State type of radiometer and keep model in brackets to be concise: e.g.
- Lines 178 – 180: “Measurements were recorded with a LI–COR LI–1500 logger and the upwelling/downwelling surface PAR was consecutively recorded using an integrated planar PAR sensor (LI–190R 2π, LI–COR)….”
- Lines 180 – 181: “Under-ice transmitted PAR was recorded using an integrating scalar PAR sensor (LI–193 4 π)…”
- We have incorporated the above changes to Section 2.5.
Line 182: Was the snow put back into the hole during the under-ice arm deployment to avoid artificial increase in under-ice light values?
- The measurement was taken using a mechanical L-arm, which positions the sensor 1 m away from the uncovered deployment hole. We have clarified this on lines 182–184.
- “Under-ice transmitted PAR was recorded using an integrating scalar PAR sensor (LI–193 4π, LI–COR) supported by a mechanical L-arm, which was positioned approximately 0.1 m below the ice–ocean interface and 1 m away from the open deployment hole.”
Line 185: Does the used model to calculate surface PAR at the sampling site include the cloud cover during that time period. Please specify. If it’s not included, this could have let to an overestimation of surface PAR.
- Yes, the model incorporated hourly All Sky Surface Total PAR data from NASA, which includes cloud cover. We have specified this on line 186.
Lines 195 – 196: Why was only surface water sampled if this study investigated vertical nutrient fluxes from the deeper Atlantic water? This study does not provide any measured or literature AW nutrient values for this region to support their discussion of increased surface nutrient levels due to vertical upwelling. (this comment also applies to lines 505 – 507: try to provide some literature values).
- Thank you for this comment. The vertical nutrient fluxes computed in the manuscript are focusing in the upper 25 m (Figure 4), and we do not focus on the halocline. The focus of this manuscript is the ice-ocean interface and processes in the ice-ocean boundary layer, as this is the water directly impacting the bottom-ice algae. In an effort to represent more broadly the sources of nutrients for ice algae, water samples were indeed collected from the ship’s CTD which covered the deeper Atlantic Water. We have now included Table S2 in the supplementary materials which highlights the nutrient concentrations at depth during our study, including at 300 m (Atlantic Water core) which is referenced in line 526.
Line 224: Was ice core temperature measurements started from he top or bottom of the core? Please specify.
- These were measured from the top to the bottom and the text has been adapted line 227.
Line 225: When was the conductivity meter calibrated and what is its accuracy?
- The conductivity meter was calibrated before the field season and has an accuracy of ±0.1. This is added to line 229.
Line 235: Can you provide filtration volumes for these parameters, which would enable a repetition of this sampling?
- We have now included the range of volumes filtered for POC and chl a analyses, line 238 (50–200 mL). The volume was adjusted between samples based on the colouration of the filter, with filtration stopped once sufficient material had accumulated for analysis.
Line 236: For how long and at what temperature were POC/PON filters combusted?
- These were at 8 h at 450°C, this has been added to the text line 238.
Line 237: How and when was the Turner fluorometer calibrated?
- We have added lines 243-245 “Prior to the field season, the fluorometer was calibrated using a commercially purchased chl a standard, with a calibration curve generated from a series of standard dilutions.”
Section 2.8.1: I suggest including the NCP formula that uses all the defined variables. Also see my comment about “E” instead of “I” for irradiance
- We have made these changes.
Lines 360 – 362: In this explanation of how the snow thickness threshold to reach zero NCP was derived, it is not explained if PE parameters were kept the same in the NCP calculation. If so, it should be highlighted in the discussion that this does not necessarily reflect the in situ algal photophysiological response.
- We have added lines 310-311 to the methods section: “The PE parameters used in the model were kept constant for each sample/site and were not adjusted dynamically with changes in irradiance or snow thickness.”
- As well as this sentence in the discussion line 706-707. “As PE parameters were held constant, this threshold does not account for potential photoacclimation to changing light conditions.”
Line 382: How was the mixed layer depth derived?
- The mixed layer was derived based on the vertical CTD profiles and the first significant change in density. As we are still in ‘winter’ conditions with a deep mixed layer and surface layer at the freezing temperature without melt water (Figure 3), a determination with density criteria have given a similar result on a few profiles. We added line 389-390: ‘We defined the mixed layer as the first depth (starting from the surface) corresponding to a large increase in density compared to the surface. ‘
Line 383: How thick was the “warmer AW core” at Site 2?
- The warmer AW extended down to 300 m, this information is added in line 392–393.
Line 398: If the statistical test does not show any significant differences between measurement points for silicic acid, you cannot describe it as “decreasing”. The stats result says, there is no change. (also line 501 – “insignificant decrease” – statistically speaking, those two words rule each other out.)
- We have changed line 407-408 to “Silicic acid and PO4 interface water concentrations did not change significantly (Dixon's Q test, p > 0.05).”
Line 400: Was the diapycnal diffusivity enhanced at all sites?
- Yes, the diapycnal diffusivity was enhanced near the ice-ocean interface at all sites, which is a classic result in the Arctic as most of the energy in the comes from the Atmosphere and not from current-bottom interactions for example.
Line 423: The text says that table 2 is only summarizing physical characteristics, while the table is actually also providing biochemical results. Those aren’t described in the text at all. Please add a description of those results.
- We have made this change.
Section 3.1.: I suggest including a plot to visualize flow cytometry and total cell abundance results. It’s difficult to grasp these big numbers and differences from the text.
- We have moved Figure S7 from the Supplementary materials to the manuscript (Figure 5).
Line 475: Was this transmittance value of 2.56% measured?
- This was measured and we have now stated this in the manuscript line 495.
Line 548: The floe did not only consist of SYI as stated here.
- We have changed this to” Snow depth at the SYI sites was, on average, approximately 0.2 m greater than at the FYI locations.” Line 571
Line 550: As stated in the methods, ice thickness has a minimal impact on light transmission compared to snow.
- We have changed this.
Section 4.2.2.: Please see my general comment of a lack of sufficient discussion in this section.
- We have adapted this section as described above.
Technical comments:
Line 29: unit is missing term “photons”
- We have made this change.
Lines 99: Providing more than four digits in GPS coordinates is unreasonable
- We have made this change.
Throughout manuscript, make sure spelling of first-year sea ice and second-year sea ice is correct (dash is often missing).
- We have made this change.
The format of all figures should be the same throughout the manuscript, including using the same letter format for “(a)” vs “a)” vs “a”, using variable “depth” (not pressure) with positive numbers for profiles (negative in Fig. 4), and using a “real” minus in axis labels and units. Plot axes should also always start and end with a number and not have numbers only show somewhere in the middle of the axis (Figs. 2 & 4).
- We have made these changes.
Line 132: “sampling site”
- We have made this change.
Line 133: Figure 1b) does not indicate water sampling at Site 3.
- We have made this change.
Line 135: Table 1 does not provide coordinates even though text is claiming it does.
- We have made this change.
Table 1: Table caption or sampling date in the table should indicate which year it was sampled.
- We have made this change.
Line 185: Specify “The resultant PAR transmittance”
- We have made this change.
Line 208: Specify “9 cm diameter”
- We have made this change.
Line 209 (and throughout manuscript): Only biochemical measurements were performed, no “geo”
- We thank the reviewer for this comment and agree that the distinction between biochemical and biogeochemical measurements should be clarified. While the terms overlap, we consider biogeochemical appropriate in the context of our study, as the measurements extend beyond the biochemical composition of ice algae to include carbon and nutrient concentrations, which are relevant to the cycling of elements within the sea-ice system and its interactions with the surrounding environment. This terminology is consistent with the broader use of sea-ice biogeochemistry in the literature (e.g., Lannuzel et al., 2020), which encompasses biological processes and their interactions with the chemical and physical environment.
Line 210: Include “..and TO make data from…”
- We have made this change.
Line 230: Specify “Nutrient samples from melted sea-ice bottom and water samples..”
- We have made this change.
Line 235: Specify “Chlorophyll a, POC and PON from melted sea-ice bottom samples…”
- We have made this change.
Line 245: Use same format “2–20 µm”
- We have made this change.
Line 247: The term “diluted melt” should be rephrased.
- We have changed this on lines 214, 252 and 257, to salinity-buffered melt
Line 268 (and throughout manuscript): The official symbol for irradiance is “E” not “I” (used in old literature). Hence, it should be “PE” parameters and “Es” and “Ec” for photosynthetic efficiency and photoacclimation parameter, respectively.
- We updated the document to use Ek and Ec for the photoacclimation parameter and compensation irradiance, respectively.
Line 270 (and throughout manuscript)” Use “mL” for unit
- We have made this change throughout the document.
Lines 272 -273: Be concise “measured with an integrating scalar PAR probe (Walz US–SQS/L) and logger (Walz model ULM–500)” (I’m adding the the term “integrating” because none of these radiometers measures spectral light, they just provide one PAR value)
- We have made this change.
Line 284: Unit needs capital “L” for liters
- We have made this change.
Line 313: Equation 1 – variable “z” is not defined (just further below)
- We added line 323: ‘where z is depth (in m).
Line 340: The used letter for “Under-ice PAR transmittance” as “TS” is misleading as the lower “s” is used in the equation for snow. Hence, I would suggest using “TUI”. Also be careful to define “T” as transmittance, and not “transmission” (Line 241).
- We have made this change.
Line 370: Can you provide the number of hours for the storm in the text?
- We have included the total of 35 hours on line 378.
Line 371: Does indicated speed refer to “drift speed”?
- Yes, we refer to drift speed. We have made this change.
Figure 3: See general comments. But also, salinity should not have unit. And if the x axis label already says “Days in May”, each measurement day doesn’t need to also say May
- We fixed the x-label by removing ‘/05’ in all the tick labels. We disagree that salinity should not have units. PSU is a type of unit (Practical Salinity Unit) and it is important to distinguish as there are multiples possible salinity units.
Table 2: Explain all used abbreviations in the table caption.
- We have made this change.
Table 3: Is not just showing PE parameters. It’s also showing NCP and chlorophyll results. This should be included in the table caption. Also these are “integrated” chlorophyll values
- We have made this change.
Table 4: Again, this table is not just showing PE parameters, but also integrated Chlorophyll. Please include that in the caption.
- We have made this change.
Lines 477 – 479: The grammar of this sentence is off, which makes it hard to understand. Please try to rephrase.
- We have rephrased line 499–501 “On 27 May, the mean snow depth over FYI was 0.31 ± 0.14 m. There was a greater likelihood of encountering snow depths below 0.30 m over FYI, with FYI comprising approximately 30% of the study area (Sect. 3.1).”
Line 552: Add “Here, the highest chl a was FOUND in the bottom of FYI…”.
- We have made this change.
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4031', Anonymous Referee #2, 01 Oct 2026
Review of McKay et al. “Drivers of net community production in the bottom of Arctic pack ice”
The manuscript presents field observations of the bottom ice algal community of a drifting ice floe in spring near Svalbard. It presents repeated sea ice biogeochemical and accompanying atmospheric and oceanic measurements over the course of about 10 days. The paper discusses the interplay of light and nutrient availability on ice algae and net community production, including the effects of a storm event. They also estimate the area of the floe that would support net autotrophy vs heterotrophy.
I found the research interesting and valuable, as well as generally thorough and well-presented. The field sampling shows a significant coordinated sampling effort (including at least 12 cores per sea ice site!). My main suggestions surround the estimation of light and some of the presentation of the discussion, somewhat moderate revisions. Also, please note, I do not have technical expertise in turbulence measurements and cannot provide a deep assessment of them.
- The floe-scale NCP estimates are derived using % transmittance to determine a threshold snow depth that separates net autotrophic and net heterotrophic conditions. Given that the NCP curves already provide a compensation irradiance, I would recommend the use of an absolute (transmitted) PAR threshold rather than % transmittance. After all, transmittance is only half of the question—the other half being incident light intensity and duration (as the authors themselves demonstrate in L588-591, noting the effect of clouds). To then scale this, they could use a mean daily incident PAR (from Fig S9) as the starting value and use the downward exponential decay to calculate under-ice (or indeed, bottom-ice) PAR and compare it to the threshold.
- L157-159 and Figure S6 indicate that measurements of ice thickness were measured along the transect. If the authors adopt the approach in Point 1, then they could also consider ice thickness in their calculations, instead assuming a constant ice thickness. Although it is true that the Kd of snow is about 10x that of ice, differences in ice thickness of ~70 cm (e.g., Site 1 vs Site 2) could therefore have about the same difference as ~8 cm of snow (e.g., Site 1 vs Site 2 thin snow).
- I understand the desire to order the discussion topics thematically – nutrients, light, storms, floe-scale estimates. However, I did then find it challenging at times to bounce back and forth between discussions of the different sites and, only upon a second read and with notes, did I feel I was able to pinpoint what the authors believe to be the main explanatory factors at each site. Perhaps consider adding text that clearly conveys the takeaway story for each site. E.g., at Site 1, there was Si depletion and middling NCP; at Site 2 thin snow, there was more N, but negative NCP due to higher heterotrophy; etc.
Specific comments
L82: Please consider being more specific: what kind of effects have been shown for FYI to SYI?
L185: Please specify that the POWER dataset is modelled upon its introduction and also provide a citation.
L187: It’s not clear to me how often the % transmittance is altered although the surface PAR is hourly. I guess it would be with every ice sampling date? Please specify.
L230: Missing a space in “a10%”
L259: Saying “Additional NCP experiments” before the field experiments are introduced was a bit confusing. Please consider rewording or reordering 2.7.3 and 2.7.4.
L262: “Pseudo-nitzschia” should have a dash, here and throughout the text.
Section 2.8.1: Please consider including the actual fitting equation, especially as some of the parameters appear different from Arrigo et al. 2010. Please also clarify/check if Ps is actually the maximum photosynthetic rate or is the saturated photosynthetic rate. I also agree with Reviewer 1 about using the variable E instead of I.
L300: Please change to “estimated transmitted PAR irradiance”
Section 3.1. Environmental conditions: Is it ever discussed that the FYI is far thicker than all the SYI? Do the authors have any ideas as to why this would be the case?
Note that the following section is also labelled 3.1 (Algal abundance and taxonomy in the bottom ice)
Section 3.3-3.4: Please consider presenting the environmental PAR before the lab results, so that your readers may read the lab experiments conducted at 30 umol photons/m2/s in the context of the environment.
L491: Please consider qualifying by time of year/progression of the bloom.
L501: I would just say that the Si(OH)4 is consistent/showed no significant change.
L510. The comma after (p=0.04) should probably be a semi-colon
L513-538. Is there really evidence of Si limitation? It seems like a strong claim, given no relationship between Si and NCP, and a reliance on environmental ratios, rather than nutrient limitation experiments or Ks-based limitation calculations. I would like to see the stoichiometric ratios of ice algae for additional comparison, or for the language in L514, 523 for example to be more conservative than the term “limitation.”
L513: Please consider changing phytoplankton to microalgae due to the scope of the present manuscript. Same on L536.
L554-573: These two paragraphs felt out of place to me in a section that is nominally about light. Please consider moving or separating.
L645: Please change to “snow thickness primarily controls” depending on the choices to consider ice thickness.
L673: “These findings highlight the importance of nutrient fluxes…” I think this conclusion is based on the higher NCP at Site 3 with higher N fluxes due to the storm and underlying nutrient-rich waters, despite lower N in the bottom ice? However, this point wasn’t really discussed; I think it is important and should be added, probably to Section 4.1
L658-680: I don’t think these sentences are doing anything for you and would consider cutting them.
Figures and Tables
Figs. 2, 3, and 4: Please consider labeling the site numbers. I know there are slightly different water and ice sampling dates, but just choosing a convention should be fine.
Please consider adding transmitted PAR or % transmittance to either Table 2 or 3.
Table 2: Please consider consistently using cm or m for snow and ice thickness (you could chose differently for the two metrics) across this table and the rest of the paper.
Please consider moving Figure S7 to the main text, as I think the community composition is important enough to come up multiple times in the Discussion and it would make Section 3.1 easier to digest.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4031-RC2 -
AC3: 'Reply on RC2', Rosalie McKay, 20 Oct 2026
We would like to thank the reviewer for their comments. We have addressed the reviewer’s three main concerns by (1) adding text to clarify our use of % transmittance and the objective of our approach (lines 369–371), (2) acknowledging the uncertainty introduced by focusing on snow depth and using a simplified approach to estimate floe-wide NCP (lines 495-498, 718-722), and (3) adding a site-specific summary near the end of the Discussion to highlight differences in algal communities, environmental conditions, and NCP among the sites (Section: 4.4). We have also addressed the reviewer’s specific comments on a line-by-line basis below. In our response, we copy each of the Reviewer comments, with our responses directly afterwards as bullets. We feel that these changes have improved the clarity of the manuscript and more clearly identify the assumptions and uncertainties associated with our methodology.
1. The floe-scale NCP estimates are derived using % transmittance to determine a threshold snow depth that separates net autotrophic and net heterotrophic conditions. Given that the NCP curves already provide a compensation irradiance, I would recommend the use of an absolute (transmitted) PAR threshold rather than % transmittance. After all, transmittance is only half of the question—the other half being incident light intensity and duration (as the authors themselves demonstrate in L588-591, noting the effect of clouds). To then scale this, they could use a mean daily incident PAR (from Fig S9) as the starting value and use the downward exponential decay to calculate under-ice (or indeed, bottom-ice) PAR and compare it to the threshold.
- Thank you for this suggestion. We agree that absolute PAR is a more direct measure of the light available for photosynthesis than % transmittance. However, our objective was to determine the snow depth at which the daily accumulated NCP transitioned from net autotrophic to net heterotrophic conditions, rather than to identify the instantaneous irradiance that can quickly vary with e.g. changing cloud conditions.
- To account for this, we used the modelled hourly irradiance, including variation in incident light associated with cloud cover, and applied the PE relationship to each of 24 hourly irradiance values. We progressively decreased the PAR transmittance applied to the modelled hourly irradiance and recalculated daily accumulated NCP until NCP equalled zero. The resulting transmittance therefore represents the attenuation required for daily accumulated NCP to reach the compensation point under the modelled daily light regime, and was subsequently related to snow depth using the exponential attenuation relationship. Thus, incident light intensity and its temporal variability were incorporated into the calculation, rather than assuming that a fixed % transmittance alone determined whether conditions were net autotrophic or net heterotrophic. We have clarified this methodology in lines 369–371:
- “To do so, we progressively decreased the PAR transmittance applied to the modelled hourly irradiance and recalculated daily accumulated NCP over 24 hours until NCP equalled zero.”
- We have also clarified that the resulting transmittance threshold represents the light reduction required to reach the daily NCP compensation point under the modelled light regime, rather than a universal PAR transmittance threshold. Adjust lines 495-498 in the results section:
- “At this snow depth, PAR transmittance decreased from the measured 2.56% to a critical threshold of 0.40%, resulting in under-ice PAR of 1.10–3.49 µmol photons m–2 s–1, compared with 7.03–22.3 µmol photons m–2 s–1 at 2.56% transmittance. The resulting hourly PAR values varied around the of 2.48 µmol photons m–2 s–1, such that the integrated NCP over 24 hours equalled zero.”
2. L157-159 and Figure S6 indicate that measurements of ice thickness were measured along the transect. If the authors adopt the approach in Point 1, then they could also consider ice thickness in their calculations, instead assuming a constant ice thickness. Although it is true that the Kd of snow is about 10x that of ice, differences in ice thickness of ~70 cm (e.g., Site 1 vs Site 2) could therefore have about the same difference as ~8 cm of snow (e.g., Site 1 vs Site 2 thin snow).
- We agree that spatial variability in ice thickness could influence under-ice PAR and, consequently, the NCP estimates, given that spatial differences in ice thickness can still meaningfully affect transmitted PAR despite the lower attenuation coefficient of ice relative to snow. We simplified our calculations by holding ice thickness constant because mean ice thickness (2.0 ± 0.3 m) did not differ between FYI and SYI. The modal ice thicknesses were also similar between FYI (1.75 m) and SYI (1.85 m).
- We recognize that the transect measurements show spatial variability in ice thickness and that incorporating this variability could affect the predicted NCP at individual locations. Our interpretations were that the lower snow depths associated with FYI were more likely to result in positive NCP, whereas the greater snow depths associated with SYI would result in predominantly negative NCP. Although greater ice thickness would reduce PAR and could shift some FYI locations toward more heterotrophic conditions, this would not change our overall floe-scale interpretation because the majority of the floe was SYI and was already predicted to be net heterotrophic. Thus, incorporating the observed spatial variability in ice thickness could affect the predicted NCP at individual locations, but is unlikely to change the conclusion that the floe as a whole was predominantly net heterotrophic.
- We have acknowledged spatial variability in ice thickness as a source of uncertainty in the predicted distribution of NCP by including lines 718-722:
- “Though we recognize that spatial variability in ice thickness was not incorporated into the spatial calculations and therefore represents a source of uncertainty in the predicted distribution of NCP, the floe was predicted to be predominantly net heterotrophic. Thus, accounting for locations with greater ice thickness, and consequently lower under-ice PAR, would be expected to further shift NCP towards heterotrophy rather than alter the overall floe-scale conclusion.”
3. I understand the desire to order the discussion topics thematically – nutrients, light, storms, floe-scale estimates. However, I did then find it challenging at times to bounce back and forth between discussions of the different sites and, only upon a second read and with notes, did I feel I was able to pinpoint what the authors believe to be the main explanatory factors at each site. Perhaps consider adding text that clearly conveys the takeaway story for each site. E.g., at Site 1, there was Si depletion and middling NCP; at Site 2 thin snow, there was more N, but negative NCP due to higher heterotrophy; etc.
- Thank you for this suggestion, we have added section: 4.4 Summary of site-specific responses to environmental drivers (lines 680–695).
- “Taken together, the three sites exhibited contrasting combinations of under-ice PAR availability, nutrient conditions, biomass and community composition that were reflected in their NCP. Site 1, the FYI site with the lowest snow depth, had the highest chl a concentration, but also the lowest under-ice water NO3+NO2concentrations and highest POC:PON ratio. Despite high biomass and light availability, this site had lower NCP and , and a greater relative abundance of Pseudo-nitzschia spp. Sites 2 and 3 were both SYI and were dominated by Nitzschia spp., with higher and lower values, indicating a greater photosynthetic affinity for low irradiance. Site 2 provided a contrasting example under intermediate under-ice water NO3+NO2 concentrations in which NCP was negative beneath lower snow despite positive NCP beneath adjacent deeper snow, indicating that greater light availability alone did not result in greater NCP. The Site 2 thin-snow location had a greater relative abundance of flagellate cells, suggesting that differences in community composition may also have contributed to the contrasting NCP response. Site 3, had the lowest chl a concentration but enriched under-ice water NO3+NO2, a lower POC:PON ratio, and elevated . Following the storm, increased under-ice flux of NO3+NO2 and heat led to the highest daily NCP rate but also decreased cellular abundances because of bottom melt. Overall, these contrasting site characteristics suggest that NCP reflected the combined effects of nutrient availability, light conditions and community composition, rather than a single environmental driver.”
Specific comments
L82: Please consider being more specific: what kind of effects have been shown for FYI to SYI?
- We have adapted lines 82–83 to include “with evidence of effects on sea-ice algal community composition and photoacclimation (Campbell et al., 2022).”
L185: Please specify that the POWER dataset is modelled upon its introduction and also provide a citation.
- We have made these changes.
L187: It’s not clear to me how often the % transmittance is altered although the surface PAR is hourly. I guess it would be with every ice sampling date? Please specify.
- Under-ice transmittance was measured at each site. We have specified this in the textline 194.
L230: Missing a space in “a10%”
- We have made this change.
L259: Saying “Additional NCP experiments” before the field experiments are introduced was a bit confusing. Please consider rewording or reordering 2.7.3 and 2.7.4.
- We have reworded this section to be more explicit that additional algal species were collected and cultured for incubation experiments line 269:
- “These cultures were used in NCP incubations as described below (Section 2.7.4.) to determine if highly abundant species within the most dominant taxonomic group observed (pennate diatoms) in the ice would contribute differently to NCP rates.”
L262: "Pseudo-nitzschia" should have a dash, here and throughout the text.
- We have made this change.
Section 2.8.1: Please consider including the actual fitting equation, especially as some of the parameters appear different from Arrigo et al. 2010. Please also clarify/check if Ps is actually the maximum photosynthetic rate or is the saturated photosynthetic rate. I also agree with Reviewer 1 about using the variable E instead of I.
- We have clarified that Ps* is the light-saturated photosynthetic rate in the absence of photoinhibition and included the fitting equation, lines 300 and 298. In agreement with Reviewer 1, we have changed I to E throughout the document.
L300: Please change to “estimated transmitted PAR irradiance”
- We have made this change, line 308.
Section 3.1. Environmental conditions: Is it ever discussed that the FYI is far thicker than all the SYI? Do the authors have any ideas as to why this would be the case?
- Thank you for raising this point. The sampled FYI was indeed thicker than the sampled SYI; however, the transect measurements indicate that ice thickness did not differ substantially between FYI and SYI across the floe. We discuss this point in more detail in response to the main Reviewer comment #2 above.
- With respect to why the FYI was thicker at the sampled sites, we suggest that the lower snow accumulation on the more recently formed FYI may have provided less insulation during winter, allowing greater conductive heat loss and consequently greater ice growth. We have added this potential explanation to lines 425–427:
- “Heavy snowfall occurred in the first half of the winter, resulting in differences in snow accumulation between SYI and FYI (Fig. S1), which may have allowed greater conductive heat loss and consequently increased thermodynamic ice growth beneath the less-insulated FYI.”
Note that the following section is also labelled 3.1 (Algal abundance and taxonomy in the bottom ice)
- We have updated the section numbers.
Section 3.3-3.4: Please consider presenting the environmental PAR before the lab results, so that your readers may read the lab experiments conducted at 30 umol photons/m2/s in the context of the environment.
- We agree that providing the environmental PAR range before presenting the laboratory experiments helps place the experimental irradiance of 30 µmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹ into context. We have therefore added text to the Methods Section 2.7.3 noting that bottom-ice PAR reached approximately 30 µmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹ at the upper end of the observed environmental range (Table 2, Fig. S8).
- Lines 268–269 “representing the upper end of the observed under-ice PAR range, Table 2 and Figure S8”
L491: Please consider qualifying by time of year/progression of the bloom.
- We have clarified with “as blooms progress” Line 515.
L501: I would just say that the Si(OH)4 is consistent/showed no significant change.
- We have made this change.
L510. The comma after (p=0.04) should probably be a semi-colon
- We have made this change.
L513-538. Is there really evidence of Si limitation? It seems like a strong claim, given no relationship between Si and NCP, and a reliance on environmental ratios, rather than nutrient limitation experiments or Ks-based limitation calculations. I would like to see the stoichiometric ratios of ice algae for additional comparison, or for the language in L514, 523 for example to be more conservative than the term “limitation.”
- We have changed lines 537–539 to “Although nitrate is often considered the primary limiting nutrient for microalgal growth in AW (Krisch et al., 2020), reduced availability of Si(OH)4 may have constrained algal growth in our study, consistent with previous findings (Duarte et al., 2021; Renner et al., 2023).” And lines 548–549 “Despite indications of reduced availability of Si(OH)4 across all sites, we found little evidence that variability in Si(OH)4availability explained differences in productivity.”
L513: Please consider changing phytoplankton to microalgae due to the scope of the present manuscript. Same on L536.
- We have made this change.
L554-573: These two paragraphs felt out of place to me in a section that is nominally about light. Please consider moving or separating.
- We have added an additional subsection: 4.2.1. Community composition in the bottom of first-year and second-year ice lines 579–598.
L645: Please change to “snow thickness primarily controls” depending on the choices to consider ice thickness.
- We have made this change line 703.
L673: “These findings highlight the importance of nutrient fluxes…” I think this conclusion is based on the higher NCP at Site 3 with higher N fluxes due to the storm and underlying nutrient-rich waters, despite lower N in the bottom ice? However, this point wasn’t really discussed; I think it is important and should be added, probably to Section 4.1
- We agree that the relatively low nutrient concentrations measured in the bottom ice could be more explicitly discussed in the context of the enhanced nutrient fluxes. We have added text to Section 4.3 clarifying that low bottom-ice nutrient concentrations do not necessarily indicate low nutrient supply, as they may reflect biological uptake, and that the combination of nutrient-rich underlying waters and enhanced storm-driven nutrient fluxes may have sustained nutrient availability at Site 3:
- Lines 643–648 “Although NO3+NO2 concentrations in the bottom ice were relatively low at Site 3, these concentrations may reflect rapid biological uptake rather than low nutrient supply, particularly given the concurrent enhancement of upward nutrient fluxes (Ahmed et al., 2025). Thus, the combination of nutrient-rich underlying waters and increased turbulent nutrient delivery may have sustained nutrient availability to the bottom-ice algal community despite low measured concentrations within the ice.”
L658-680: I don’t think these sentences are doing anything for you and would consider cutting them.
- We have removed these lines from the conclusion.
Figures and Tables
Figs. 2, 3, and 4: Please consider labeling the site numbers. I know there are slightly different water and ice sampling dates, but just choosing a convention should be fine.
- We have included dashed lines and points to highlight dates of ice and water sampling in Figures 2 and 3.
Please consider adding transmitted PAR or % transmittance to either Table 2 or 3.
- We have included % Transmittance in Table 2 (and therefore removed table S2 from the supplementary).
Table 2 Snow depth, ice thickness and percent transmittance from biogeochemical ice coring, concentrations of particulate organic carbon (POC), particulate organic nitrogen (PON) and nutrients in the bottom of first-year (FYI) and second-year ice (SYI)
Site /
ice type
Snow depth
(m)
Ice thickness
(m)
Under-ice
transmittance (%)
POC
(mg L–1)
PON
(mg L–1)
aNO3 + NO2
(µmol L–1)
bPO4
(µmol L–1)
cSi(OH)4
(µmol L–1)
1 / FYI
0.09 ± 0.02
2.06 ± 0.02
1.14
5.73
0.85
3.57
0.84
1.00
2 / SYI
0.30 ± 0.01
1.31 ± 0.02
0.64
3.62
0.58
5.37
0.46
0.55
2 / SYI
0.17 ± 0.03
1.39 ± 0.02
0.68
2.72
0.43
3.21
0.46
0.97
3 / SYI
0.23 ± 0.02
1.44 ± 0.03
2.56
2.86
0.50
2.14
0.39
0.44
Table 2: Please consider consistently using cm or m for snow and ice thickness (you could chose differently for the two metrics) across this table and the rest of the paper.
- We have made this change.
Please consider moving Figure S7 to the main text, as I think the community composition is important enough to come up multiple times in the Discussion and it would make Section 3.1 easier to digest.
- We have made this change.
Data sets
Sea ice biogeochemical data for the BREATHE project: Yermak Plateau 2023 R. McKay, J. Osanen, C. Laber, and K. Campbell https://doi.org/10.21334/NPOLAR.2025.18D7E643
Sea ice core data from BREATHE/SIDRiFT field school, north of Svalbard, May 2023 P. Itkin https://doi.org/10.21334/NPOLAR.2025.44A880E0
Snow pits from BREATHE/SIDRiFT field school, north of Svalbard, May 2023 P. Itkin https://doi.org/10.21334/NPOLAR.2024.A1AB4151
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 337 | 189 | 39 | 565 | 113 | 41 | 43 |
- HTML: 337
- PDF: 189
- XML: 39
- Total: 565
- Supplement: 113
- BibTeX: 41
- EndNote: 43
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
The associated MSS data can be found here:
Koenig, Z. C., Campbell, K., & Saur Heiland, S. (2026). Ocean microstructure profiles (MSS) from the BREATHE cruise, Yermak plateau North of Svalbard, May 2023 [Dataset]. Norwegian Polar Institute. https://doi.org/10.21334/NPOLAR.2026.05015061