the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
An Underappreciated Aqueous Pathway for Particle Oxidative Potential (OP): Mechanistic Insights into OP-Relevant Products from α-Dicarbonyl and Reduced Nitrogen Reactions
Abstract. Aqueous-phase reactions between α-dicarbonyls and reduced nitrogen species represent an understudied pathway generating secondary organic aerosols that exhibit oxidative potential (OP). In this study, we investigated the OP of products formed from methylglyoxal (MG) or glyoxal (GX) reacting with ammonium sulfate (AS) or glycine (Gly) under varying pH (3–7) and reaction times (4–144 h). OP was quantified using dithiothreitol (DTT) depletion and hydroxyl radical (•OH) production assays, while molecular composition was characterized using high-resolution mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The results demonstrate that OP is strongly dependent on precursor identity, pH, and reaction time. Products from the MG+Gly system consistently exhibit the highest OPDTT and OPOH. Molecular analysis indicates that CHO species, including conjugated carbonyls and quinones, are primarily responsible for DTT activity, whereas N-heterocycles with unprotonated N-bases drive •OH formation. Electron-withdrawing substituents adjacent to the unprotonated N atoms enhance electron-transfer capability, thereby increasing the ability of N-heterocycles to generate •OH. N-heterocycles also act synergistically with quinone-like species to promote DTT oxidation, highlighting their dual role in modulating OP. Collectively, these findings reveal that aqueous reactions between α-dicarbonyls and reduced nitrogen species can produce secondary organic aerosols with substantial oxidative capacity, which may contribute to oxidative stress and cause adverse health effects. This work advances mechanistic understanding of aerosol OP and emphasizes the importance of considering aqueous-phase chemistry when evaluating the health-relevant oxidative properties of ambient particulate matter.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.- Preprint
(2117 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(6905 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-3809', Anonymous Referee #1, 24 Jul 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-3809', Anonymous Referee #2, 09 Nov 2026
In this work, the authors studied the aqueous reactions between α-dicarbonyl and reduced nitrogen compounds and how they impacted the oxidative potential of the aerosol. These laboratory experiments showed high OP and an increasing trend with reaction time. Using a variety of chemical characterization techniques (NMR, high resolution MS/MS), they elucidated chemical structures of reactants and proposed some mechanisms for DTT oxidation and OH production. In general, this is a nice study that gives a lot of molecular details, and the results would be very interesting. I also commend the authors for connecting detailed molecular characterization with OP results, which is often difficult to do, even in a laboratory setting. The major area of improvement for this manuscript is the lack of context. In particular, some details are lacking, which leaves me unconvinced how applicable these results are in real atmospheric particles. I recommend publication of this manuscript after some relatively minor revisions.
Major comments:
One of the most striking results is the high OP when compared to naphthoquinone and copper, which are some of the most oxidative compounds found in atmospheric aerosol. However, Figure 1 is presented in absolute DTT consumption or OH production rates, but the concentration of the organic compounds matters. Usually these are presented in terms of mass normalized OP. I tried to find information about the concentration of dicarbonyl / reduced nitrogen mixture but the information is buried in the SI (200 µL of sample in 2mL). At the very least, Figure 1 should be shown as mass normalized OP; otherwise it is very misleading. This is very consequential omission and really needs to be addressed. (Another related point is I am concerned if the organic concentration is high enough to overwhelm the buffer and impact the pH.)
The pH dependence is very interesting, but atmospheric particles are often at low pH (2-4), and since these reactions are promoted at high pH, I think the atmospheric relevance should be discussed. Cloud droplets might have pH 5-7, so this is where these reactions might be more enhanced. So perhaps in the life cycle of a particle, which might go through two or three activation / drying cycles, there might be times where these reactions are more important, and others when they are not?
Similar to the previous comment, why is there such a strong pH dependence? Is there a reaction step in the mechanism that is acid or base catalyzed? Usually this kind of pH dependence means that the de-protonation step leads to the desired product (in this case a more OP-active group of compounds). Line 200 briefly alluded to this, but no detailed discussion. The LC/MS analysis was limited to higher pH, but is there any indication from these experiments that the reactions are indeed suppressed at lower pH?
Drawing an analogy to BrC is interesting, but I would argue that this is a coincidence, and might be more applicable to this system than anywhere else. Here we have reduced nitrogen that forms N heterocycles that are light absorbing and brown, but in other systems OP activity is likely going to come from other functional groups not related to light absorption. A correlation does not mean causation (i.e. OP active does not mean it is brown, or vice versa). It should be stressed that the functional groups convert into light absorbing ones at the same timescale as the OP activity increases, but it does not mean the same functional groups are responsible for both phenomena.
For Figure 5, the molecular structure identification is interesting. I cannot help but wonder how these molecules are formed, which makes me question the proposed structures. Are these confirmed with authentic standards? Some of the structures require C-C formation, which is hard for me to see in an aqueous system (usually just acid-base reactions happen). I also see from the other reviewer comment that also raises this issue. Perhaps the structures are not really that important to show? Or maybe just confirm a few that are important for the discussion in Section 3.3?
Is the NMR capable of identifying alpha-beta unsaturated carbonyls? I see from Figure 6 that both pathways involve alpha-beta unsaturated carbonyls, which has been shown in previously literature to be DTT active.
Specific comments:
- Title: “Underappreciated” is subjective, especially since this study does not directly prove its importance in the atmosphere
- Line 16 and throughout: I find it confusing Gly is not referring to glyoxal
- Line 46: I briefly looked at the three references cited here and I did not see any studies identifying black carbon as important contributors to OP.
- Lines 55–57: The citations provided for the general statement here appear to rely primarily on the authors' own previous work. For a broad claim of this nature, please replace or supplement these with primary, more authoritative references.
- Line 69: I believe Wong et al., 2019 also looked at aqueous phase aging
- Line 86: Glyoxal and methylglyoxal themselves are likely not in aerosol, but rather their oligomeric forms
- Line 107: what does “ultrapure” mean? Are metals removed using a chelating agent?
- Line 119: I believe highly concentrated SOA particles would be at even higher concentrations. Another limitation is the ionic strength, which is likely lower than in real atmospheric particles
- Line 143: were these also the ratios for the OP measurements?
- Line 189-190: show the blank OP (e.g. in the SI)
- Lines 211–216: did the pH change during the experiments?
- Lines 223 – 245: this discussion can be trimmed down since a lot of the text is describing what is shown in the graphs
- Section 3.2: each one of this correlation analysis is done for a single system across reaction time. In other words the associations demonstrated are across reaction time: both OP and BrC are going up with reaction time. What about associations across different experimental condition (e.g. pH) or across different precursor system? (If not done properly, this could potentially end up being a case of Simpson’s paradox.)
- Figure 5: why show CHOS and CHONS when they are so minor? They are not even discussed anywhere in the text
- Figure 5a: likely too many significant digits in the signal fractions
- Section 3.3: The group CHO is so non-specific, which makes the conclusion that “CHO species are OP-active” not terribly useful. (All SOA are essentially CHO species!) I wonder if a more focused analysis with more structurally meaningful conclusions (e.g. examine just a few of the identified unsaturated carbonyls and look at their correlations with OP) would be more insightful.
- Figure 6: why are particular species highlighted?
- Figures 7b and 7c: the color schemes are confusing.
- Lines 391–423: The discussion here feels repetitive as it largely recaps the graph contents. I suggest condensing this text to focus on key takeaways and physical insights.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-3809-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 304 | 180 | 49 | 533 | 183 | 41 | 41 |
- HTML: 304
- PDF: 180
- XML: 49
- Total: 533
- Supplement: 183
- BibTeX: 41
- EndNote: 41
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Pang and co-authors present an interesting study on the oxidative potential (OP) generated entirely by organic compounds formed in binary mixtures of glyoxal, methylglyoxal, ammonia, and glycine. The authors show that the composition and oxidative properties of the reaction products vary substantially with pH. They further propose that COOH-substituted N-heterocycles are responsible for ROS formation. While the OP measurements are convincing, the chemical characterisation of the reaction products is incomplete and selectively presented. In my opinion, the manuscript requires major revision before it can be considered for publication.
1) One of my major concerns is that the manuscript does not provide sufficient NMR and LC-MS data to evaluate the reliability of the structural assignments. At minimum, I would expect the authors to provide representative NMR spectra and a summary table of LC-MS results including exact masses, molecular formulae, tentative structures, and Sirius confidence/ranking scores. Without these data, it is difficult to assess what fraction of the detected organic material is represented by the discussed N-containing structures.
In addition, the NMR experiments were performed without removing water and with the addition of a considerable amount of non-deuterated DMSO. Consequently, the HDO and DMSO signals are expected to dominate the spectra and reduce the dynamic range, particularly in neighbouring chemical-shift regions. This limitation should be discussed, as it affects confidence in peak assignment.
2) The limitations of the analytical methodology are not discussed sufficiently. Although the entire reaction mixture was collected, only the ionisable fraction was analysed by LC-MS under the selected ionisation conditions. Consequently, the reported molecular composition represents only a subset of the reaction products. Furthermore, the discussion of individual heterocycle classes is potentially misleading. The reported percentages may be interpreted either as the fraction of identified compounds or as their relative abundance. Since LC-MS peak areas are only semi-quantitative, an increase in peak intensity can reflect an increase in concentration for a given compound, but peak intensities cannot be directly compared between different molecular species because ionisation efficiencies differ substantially. Moreover, the manuscript does not indicate what fraction of assigned molecular formulae could be structurally annotated, making it difficult to evaluate how representative the proposed structures are.
3) I am not fully convinced by the proposed mechanism presented in Figure 6c. First, the authors propose that an N-containing imine intermediate is crucial for the formation of dimethylglyoxal-derived products, yet this intermediate was neither detected nor experimentally supported. Therefore, this part of the mechanism remains speculative. Second, the authors should compare their proposed reaction pathways and identified structures with those reported by Haan et al. (2009).
Finally, I do not believe that the current evidence is sufficient to conclude that COOH-substituted N-heterocycles are directly responsible for OH formation. The presented experiments demonstrate a correlation between the presence of these compounds and increased OP, but they do not exclude alternative explanations. For example, while N-heterocycles may accelerate ascorbate oxidation, the observed OH production could still arise from traces of metals. The observation that several model heterocycles produce OP signals supports their involvement but does not establish a metal-independent mechanism. A control experiment using a strong metal chelator (e.g., EDTA) would substantially strengthen this conclusion. If the reaction is genuinely metal-independent, the addition of such chelators should not significantly affect the measured OP.
Other comments:
1) The authors have a list of tentative structures obtained from the Sirius analysis. I recommend performing a rank-correlation analysis between the peak areas of all assigned structures and both OP measurements. Such an analysis would help identify which molecular species correlate most strongly with oxidative potential. This analysis should include not only N-heterocycles but also oxygenated compounds, as the latter may also contribute to OP. Notably, none of the tested model heterocycles exhibited OP comparable to Cu2+, whereas the synthetic aerosol extracts exceeded the reference.
2) The manuscript lacks appropriate control experiments for both OP and LC-MS analyses. Although the authors state that the parent compounds exhibited negligible OP, it is unclear whether aged glyoxal or methylglyoxal solutions without nitrogen-containing precursors were analysed. Some reported products (e.g., C6H8O3) could potentially form independently of glycine or ammonia.
3) The Experimental section does not specify the aliquot volumes used for NMR, LC-MS, and OP measurements. Were all analyses performed using 200 μL aliquots?
4) The authors used the original AImod expression, although it was later revised by Koch et al. (https://analyticalsciencejournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/rcm.7433). In the corrected equation, nitrogen contributes to the numerator because it affects the hydrogen deficiency calculation. Alternatively, I recommend avoiding AImod completely in this context, as it assumes that all oxygen atoms are present in carboxyl groups, an approximation that is unlikely to hold for these reaction products.