1950–2100 climate trends in avalanche activity in Haute-Maurienne, French Alps
Abstract. Avalanche activity in alpine regions is sensitive to climate change. However, without consistent historical data, it is challenging to estimate past trends in avalanche activity and assess future avalanche scenarios from climate projections. To tackle this challenge, we use avalanche observations and simulated snowpack conditions to train a machine learning gradient-boosting regression model, which predicts the number of avalanches per day. We focus on a small alpine domain with high-quality data: the Haute-Maurienne valley in the French Alps, where avalanche paths span elevations from approximately 1800 to 2700 m a.s.l. First, we demonstrate that accounting for the uncertainties in avalanche occurrence dates and using only the most recent period (2006–2023) with homogeneous observations during the training step is essential for achieving consistent results. We then use this machine learning model to reconstruct the past avalanche activity (1958–2023) from reanalysed meteorological and snow data, and to project future avalanche activity (1950–2100) from a downscaled ensemble of snow-climate simulations. We evaluate climatic trends in avalanche activity using three indicators: the number of avalanches per winter season, the number of avalanches per month, and the annual maximum number of avalanches in one week, which quantifies the largest avalanche cycles. Based on reanalysed snow-climate simulations, the model estimates that avalanche activity decreased in the past: the mean number of avalanches per year declined by approximately 9 % per decade between 1958 and 2023, with a stronger decrease in spring avalanche activity, and the 30-year return level associated with large avalanche cycles decreased at a slower rate of around 4 % per decade. In the future, avalanche activity is also expected to decrease. For the emission scenarios RCP4.5 and RCP8.5, the annual number of avalanches is expected to decrease by around 5 % and 9 % per decade, respectively, mainly due to a reduction in spring avalanche activity. Large avalanche cycles, quantified by the 30-year return level, are also expected to decrease in intensity but at slower rates: around 2 % per decade for RCP4.5 and 5 % per decade for RCP8.5. This study quantifies the impact of climate change on avalanche activity in an exemplary alpine valley. It demonstrates that combining statistical learning with climate simulations can help produce reference scenarios for mitigation strategies in high mountain environments.
GENERAL COMMENTS
This manuscript analyzes trends in the number of avalanches in a French alpine valley from 1950 to 2100 using historical data and future climate scenarios. The authors combine weather datasets, a snow cover model, and a machine learning approach to predict the daily number of avalanches by aspect sector, calibrated against a long-term observational record.
The study examines changes in total seasonal avalanche counts, monthly distributions, and the most active week each winter. A key strength is moving beyond the binary “avalanche day” metric commonly used in previous climate studies to predicting daily avalanche counts, providing a more informative measure of changes in hazard severity with clear relevance for planning and risk management.
Overall, the manuscript is clearly written and structured, uses high-quality data and methods, and presents and interprets results that are relevant to the natural hazards community. It is well suited for NHESS. I recommend publication after addressing the comments below.
SPECIFIC COMMENTS
TECHNICAL COMMENTS