Why are plate suture zones on the Tibetan Plateau hotspots for rockslides: A case study of Jinsha River area
Abstract. Tectonic suture zones on the Tibetan Plateau, as structurally weak belts, commonly host numerous large to very large rockslides. However, how the material composition and structural architecture of suture zones govern the initiation and evolution of landslides remains poorly understood. This study focuses on the Jinsha River suture zone (JSSZ). Through systematic field geological investigations, laboratory microstructural analyses, and landslide inventory statistics, we elucidate the control of tectonic mélange belt lithology and structure on landslide development, and construct a four-stage dynamic conceptual model from initiation to triggering. The results indicate that the heterogeneous, weak lithologies and complex structures of the suture zone provide the fundamental material and structural basis for landslide initiation. Sliding surfaces are not randomly distributed but predominantly localized along sub-horizontal foliation planes or lithological interfaces. These pre-existing discontinuities, under tectonic uplift and river incision, become preferential pathways for stress release and progressive weakening, resulting in clustered landslide distribution along the suture zone. Accordingly, a four-stage initiation and evolution model is proposed, systematically explaining the complete dynamic process from suture zone formation establishing the material-structural framework, through tectonic uplift and river incision driving rock mass fracturing, freeze–thaw cycles and chemical weathering causing progressive coalescence of the sliding surface, to final triggering of catastrophic failure. This study reveals the fundamental control of suture zone lithology and structure on landslide initiation, shifting the analytical perspective from short-term triggers to long-term dynamic coupling, and from external driving conditions to intrinsic lithological-structural constraints. The findings provide a new theoretical framework for understanding clustered rockslide development on the Tibetan Plateau and similar active orogenic belts, and offer a material-structure-based assessment basis for major engineering site selection and early risk identification.
Dear authors,
the subject you have been working on, i.e. rockslides in suture zones is certainly of great interest.
However, within your approach there is a clear gap : the analysis of macro-structures before investigating micro-structures.
You jump immediately from regional tectonics to thin section scale .. via a few views of outcrops. But, no results of macroscopic
structural geology shown (stereoplots etc).
Then, you present Fig 6 as a schematic representation of your results - outlining apparently special characteristics of rockslides
in suture zones .. while you could present precisely the same rockslide evolution schemes for major mass movements in the European
Alps, very far away from any suture zones. The missing point .. as you have not analysed macro-structures, those features you show in Fig 6
are most of the times related to toppling, .. which can also locally create shear zones after creep (not related to regional tectonics).
So, for me, without a deep macro-structural analysis you are too much generalising your results, to cover examples that have nothing
to do with suture zones.
yours
reviewer H