the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
TAlkEaSy: the Total Alkalinity Earth System Model v1.0 for exploring climate, redox and ocean chemistry over geologic time
Abstract. Here, we present the TAlkEaSy (Total Alkalinity Earth System) model, a framework for exploring the coupling of changes in the major ion balance of the ocean, biogeochemical cycling and global temperature and for testing hypotheses against proxy records. The model incorporates: (1) dynamic biogeochemical cycles of major ions (Ca, Mg, S, Na, K, Cl) and C, O and nutrients (N, P); (2) a complete alkalinity system with major ions and dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) species; (3) novel proxies of Mg, Ca and U stable isotopes, together with C, S and Sr isotopes. The motivation for developing TAlkEaSy was that few existing models incorporate complete biogeochemical cycles of carbon, oxygen, nutrient, and ocean major ions with carbonate chemistry, and they either rely on data-driven approaches, or have problems accurately predicting major ion concentrations over geologic time. This impedes mechanistic understanding of the interactions between Earth’s climate, redox and ocean chemistry. TAlkEaSy is an extension of the COPSE model. We present the model configuration of TAlkEaSy and the functional forms, feedbacks, and parameterization of the biogeochemical processes included. The responses of TAlkEaSy to an idealised pulse injection of CO2 or a step increase in degassing are evaluated, to differentiate the responses to abrupt perturbation and slower changes in forcing.
- Preprint
(11481 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 18 Nov 2026)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-2949', Yves Godderis, 25 Sep 2026
reply
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Xiyuan Chen, 15 Nov 2026
reply
Dear Prof. Yves Godderis:
Thanks for your constructive suggestions!
Our reply and improvement is summarized in the attached PDF file.
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Xiyuan Chen, 15 Nov 2026
reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-2949', Alexander Krause, 14 Nov 2026
reply
Here, the authors present the TAlkEaSy model, which builds upon the tried and tested biogeochemical model of the Earth system, COPSE. TAlkEaSy improves upon the COPSE model by splitting the, previously combined, ocean-atmosphere reservoir into separate entities, allowing for the inclusion of processes such as air-sea gas exchange, and the derivation of the oceanic carbonate system. Modelling of ocean alkalinity is further aided by the addition of a number of new cycles, such as Mg, Ca etc. TAlkEaSy provides a rival, finally, to the MAGic model in terms of the completeness of the biogeochemical cycles necessary to gain a comprehensive understanding of the evolution of the Earth system through deep time. The model construction is detailed and clearly expressed in the paper. However, there are some errors and omissions, particularly in the review of existing models - which could have been cross-checked with the Cosslett-Kemeny et al. review which was published last year. The experiments section also requires some expansion.
Major comments
For the experiments in section 3, there could be some discussion as to why this particular rate of CO2 injection with that isotopic signature was modelled – is this meant to represent a particular theorised injection rate for a climate event during the Phanerozoic? Same with increasing the degassing 2 fold over 100 Myr, what’s the reasoning behind modelling this specifically? Because of this lack in a link between the test and real-world scenarios, the discussion is thinner than it could be in terms of whether the scale of the outputs make sense.
As the model is built upon the COPSE framework it should be able to output everything for the entire Phanerozoic – it would be good to see these model outputs. Does the model recover modern day values, does it output O2, CO2 etc which align well with geochemical proxies?
Because so many more biogeochemical cycles, and thus processes, have been included, some with broad uncertainties (e.g. the K cycle), the results should at least include a Monte Carlo ensemble to explore these uncertainties (e.g. over modern day flux sizes and isotope values). But also, again linking to the above comment, what is the effect on Phanerozoic predictions compared to the COPSE model. Are any of the additions having a significant effect on predictions?
With the alkalinity, because the B cycle isn’t explicitly modelled, what is the effect on the model outputs if this is taken out of the alkalinity equation? Similarly, because the acid dissociation constants are calculated using modern day temperatures, what would the model outputs look like if these were calculated at a range of temperatures (e.g. 5 – 25 deg C)?
For equations 14 and 21, Higgins and Schrag (2015) note that the 9 deg C offset is somewhat arbitrary but that the temperatures they derived for ridge flank systems over the Cenozoic are consistent with the range of temperatures which Gillis and Coogan (2011) report for low-temperature hydrothermal calcite veins. Are the temperatures obtained via TAlkEaSy also consistent?
Minor comments
For Table 1:
- Set the model name to ‘none’ or ‘NA’ instead of a / as this could be misinterpreted in some cells as being e.g. a continuation of comparing previous iterations of the same model, such as LOSCAR
- The COPSE model in Tostevin and Mills (2020) does not include prescribed [Ca] in the equation for gypsum burial.
- The SCION model does not use prescribed [Ca] either.
- GEOCARBSULFOR does not have an N or P cycle.
- GEOCARBSULFOR does not model Sr but uses the Sr isotope record to calculate Xvolc - the fraction of basaltic to granitic weathering.
- Mills et al. (2016), which is a hybrid IMB-forwards model, is missing from the table.
- GENIE should be changed to cGENIE to reflect that the model has evolved significantly from its original GENIE roots.
- EONS also models methane.
- The model by Kukla et al. (2023) is missing from the table.
- The work by Zhao et al. (2023 etc) is called the CHEES model.
- Krissansen-Totton and Catling (2020) should be included as they output the same parameters as 2018 but with a different framework.
- Because they investigate seawater ion chemistry, Arvidson et al. (2011) should also be included for the MAGic model. Their 2013 paper also used the SO4/Ca data as a prescribed parameter.
- You output pH but don't include this in your list of outputs for TAlkEaSy.
- There is the SCION-AMMONITE model, which is in review with Gondwana Research, preprint is here: https://doi.org/10.31223/X5CB9P
Within the text/figures:
- L74-75: And Berner's (2001) GCA paper.
- L84: Plus Berner (2008).
- L85: Plus Krause et al. (2024)
- L85-89 and Table 1: I think the incorporation of the N cycle began and ended with the Arndt et al. (2011) paper.
- L95 and Table 1: Plus a methane cycle – Reinhard et al. (2020)
- L97: EONS doesn’t have a 1D ocean, it is a 0D 2-box ocean.
- L100: The two Alcott et al. papers should not be listed in this, as they do not include an iron cycle, only the flux of P bound to Fe oxides.
- L129 and Table 1: Although it is not clear from the paper itself, the Tostevin and Mills version of COPSE includes a uranium cycle and predicts both oceanic concentrations and isotopic signatures.
- Table 6: Shouldn’t the C isotope standard be VPDB?
- It would be useful to include the uncertainties on the sizes and isotopic signatures of the fluxes on the biogeochemical cycle figures (e.g. Fig. 2), as well as the values chosen for the model.
- For figure 2, there appears to be a random sink flux arrow in the top right of the figure.
- For the calcium section, I would reiterate that isotopes are set to the NIST SRM915a standard, as there are three other standards often used and reported for Ca isotopes.
- There is a weak dependency on temperature for Ca isotope fractionation when it comes to carbonate burial, which I think the Gussone (2005) paper shows, if I remember correctly, and could be included.I believe there is also a weak dependency on temperature for gypsum burial too, but cannot remember the paper which looks at this.
- Also, even if it’s not included in the model, it is worth discussing the formation of anhydrite in high temperature systems (with a smaller isotopic fractionation compared to gypsum precipitation), and the impact that periods of increased MOR spreading would have on the Ca isotope signature of the ocean as a result.
Generally, the paper is well written, but it could do with another read through and a few edits to add in some words and to ensure it’s in the correct tense throughout for greater readability, e.g., L254-255, change from,
“The related air-sea exchange O2 flux equations are following the Henry’s law and described in Appendix Table A1 and A3.”
To
“The related O2 air-sea gas exchange flux equations follow Henry’s law and are described in Tables A1 and A3.”
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-2949-RC2
Model code and software
POEM-TAlkEaSy v1.0: source code and input files for Chen and Lenton model description paper Xiyuan Chen and Timothy M. Lenton https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20208350
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 398 | 124 | 62 | 584 | 57 | 52 |
- HTML: 398
- PDF: 124
- XML: 62
- Total: 584
- BibTeX: 57
- EndNote: 52
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
General Comments
The development of "deep time" Earth system models built on a physical basis often limits the number of processes that can be explored, primarily because the underlying physics of the system remains incompletely understood. Conversely, the development of more "phenomenological" models—which incorporate numerous biogeochemical cycles and processes within a global-scale representation of the Earth’s surface—is particularly valuable for exploring complex couplings and feedback mechanisms.
The current evolution of the COPSE model, presented here as the TALkEaSy model (though TALES would arguably be a cleaner acronym, this remains the authors' choice), belongs to this second category. TALkEaSy is arguably the most comprehensive model currently available for describing the geological evolution of biogeochemical cycles. While spatially resolved models typically include only the carbon, alkalinity, and occasionally phosphorus and oxygen cycles, TALkEaSy further simulates the calcium, sodium, potassium, and chlorine cycles from a global perspective. However, introducing these additional cycles inevitably brings a large number of new parameters and assumptions regarding the mathematical expressions of the associated fluxes.
The introduction provides a thorough and highly useful review of existing models, clearly outlining their respective capabilities and objectives.
The model description is clear and easy to follow. A major step forward from COPSE is the division of the single atmosphere-ocean reservoir into two distinct reservoirs with dynamic exchange. This upgrade allows for a dynamic representation of ocean-atmosphere behavior in response to massive perturbations, moving past COPSE’s steady-state assumption of an instantaneous balance between silicate rock weathering and solid Earth degassing.
Main Comment
Regarding the results section, the evaluation is less convincing. The authors present results from two "academic" test simulations designed to simplify output interpretation and verify model mechanics. However, given the vast number of added parameters, a sensitivity analysis of the key outputs is essential. To what extent does the CO2 response to a sudden degassing burst depend on specific parameter choices? Identifying the most critical parameters controlling this response would significantly strengthen the paper.
Minor Points
Recommendation
This is a high-quality contribution that will serve as a valuable reference for future users of the TALkEaSy model. It merits publication in Geoscientific Model Development (GMD) once the authors address the parameter sensitivity and clarify the underlying structural assumptions noted above.