| 11 Jun 2026
Straw and biochar co-application: A strategy to reduce Cd–Zn bioavailability, alleviate microbial nutrient limitations and enhance soil C stability
Abstract. Biochar is widely used to remediate heavy metal-contaminated soils; however, it can increase C limitation in soil microorganisms, potentially compromising soil ecological sustainability. Effective strategies are, therefore, needed to reduce heavy metal bioavailability while maintaining microbial activity and soil fertility. To this end, we aimed to evaluate the effects of different straw–biochar ratios on heavy metal availability, microbial nutrient limitation, C cycling and soil fertility and to identify an optimal remediation strategy for Cd- and Zn-contaminated soil. Cd- and Zn-contaminated soils were amended with varying straw–biochar ratios (S4C0, S3C1, S2C2, S1C3, S0C4 and control) and incubated for 90 days. Soil heavy metal bioavailability, microbial nutrient limitation, CO2 emissions, enzyme activities and organic C stability were analysed. Compared with the control, the straw–biochar treatment at a 1:3 ratio (S1C3) reduced diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid–extractable Cd and Zn by 30.22–32.81% and 21.31–23.06%, respectively. S1C3 significantly improved soil organic C content and stability, enhanced available nutrients (N, P and K), increased microbial biomass and elevated enzyme activities related to C, N and P acquisition and alleviated microbial C limitation. The optimized straw–biochar ratio (1:3) provides a novel integrated approach for remediating heavy metal-contaminated agricultural soils while simultaneously enhancing soil C stability, nutrient availability and microbial activity. This strategy offers a practical foundation for sustainable farmland management.
Review
Title : Straw and biochar co-application: A strategy to reduce Cd–Zn bioavailability, alleviate microbial nutrient limitations and enhance soil C stability
The manuscript idea is wonderful and interesting, as the study aims to evaluate the effect of different ratios of straw to biochar (incubation experiment for 90 day) to provide an optimal strategy for treating soil contaminated with cadmium and zinc, and to study their ability to treat soil contaminated with these heavy metals, and also to study the availability of microbial nutrients, the carbon cycle, and the elements available in the soil (soil fertility). The topic is important, and manuscript fits with the scope of the journal. The manuscript is very well written, the effort is very evident, and the way the results are presented is excellent. But it has some weaknesses associated with the presented data and discussion have shortcomings as discussed below. Therefore, the current version of the manuscript needs major revision to be published in (egusphere). There are several issues must be addressed.
Major comments
Overall, the research is very good and the idea is excellent, but please cite more references in the discussion as there are sections without definitive references. Also, please include the original measured value compared to the control or initial value, and not just the percentage increase or decrease. The number itself indicates the actual concentration.