How rain shapes cloud-scale dynamics and mass flux in the trades
Abstract. Trade wind cumuli often precipitate, but the effect of rain processes on their dynamics and organization is still poorly understood. Previous observations of the vertical wind inside clouds were limited to non-precipitating conditions because the mean Doppler velocity from cloud radars is dominated by hydrometeor motion in precipitating clouds. Here, we retrieve the vertical air motion inside precipitating clouds by using the Doppler velocity spectrum from the ground-based Ka-band radars at the Barbados Cloud Observatory. We validate it against available lidar measurements. We combine the in-cloud radar-derived wind with lidar observations outside of clouds into a unified dataset spanning six years (2019–2025) at high (2s) resolution. We show that precipitating cumuli act as shallow squall lines, as predicted by recent large-eddy simulations. These clouds feature a narrow updraft at the gust front that develops up to cloud top. The wider precipitation downdraft is triggered slightly below cloud top, where the rain content is large enough, and extends down to the surface where it forms a cold pool. We show that updrafts and downdrafts contribute nearly equally to the cloud base mass flux. Their balance hinges on the downdraft intensity, likely controlled by microphysical processes. These observations can improve our understanding of tropical convection, shed light on the assumptions behind convective parameterizations and constrain cloud-resolving simulations.
Competing interests: Some authors are members of the editorial board of journal Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
Review comments: How rain shapes cloud-scale dynamics and mass flux in the trades by Poydenot et al.
This manuscript presents an observational analysis of cloud-scale dynamics and mass flux in precipitating trade shallow cumulus using six years of measurements from the Barbados Cloud Observatory (BCO). The authors derive vertical wind statistics in precipitating clouds and investigate how rain modifies the cloud-base mass flux and shallow-convective dynamics using Doppler velocity spectra from the ground-based radars and validate the results against lidar measurements. The study addresses an important question in shallow-convection research and provides valuable observational insights relevant for cloud parameterization and evaluation of LES. Findings about the effects of precipitation on coupled updraft-downdraft structures and cloud-base mass flux are very interesting and potentially important for the development of convection parameterizations. The manuscript is generally well written, and I believe it is suitable for publication after addressing the points below.
Specific comments: