Exploring the Cenozoic Earth system with extraterrestrial 3He
Abstract. A key method for contextualizing climate today and into the future is to draw upon the past. Marine sediments accumulating at the bottom of the ocean serve as the only continuous archive of Earth's climate history spanning tens of millions of years. From the earliest studies of marine sediments, reconstructed changes in the inputs of sedimentary constituents such as volcanic glass, ice-rafted debris, particulates carried by rivers, desert dust, organic and inorganic remnants of organisms and biological process, and even extraterrestrial material, have been used to discern past environmental conditions. Specifically, it is the rate at which these different components of sediments from the bottom of the ocean accrue over time that can provide unique and important insight into how Earth system dynamics operated in the near and distant past. Traditional techniques for quantifying sediment mass accumulation rates (MARs) contain numerous complexities that can lead to erroneous MAR determinations. Constant flux proxies (CFPs), particularly extraterrestrial 3He (3HeET) delivered in interplanetary dust particles from space, are underutilized geochemical tools that alleviate these issues as long as key assumptions can be constrained. In this perspective, we review CFP 3HeET as a CFP and outline its benefit for understanding Cenozoic climate beyond the Quaternary. Ultimately, we suggest that the application of 3HeET is valuable for providing the broader paleoclimate and paleoceanography communities with accurate records of Cenozoic Earth system change from a MAR perspective.
General comments
Good research on paleoclimate. Please, follow my specific comments to improve your manuscript.
Specific comments
Lines 34-36. “High resolution archives that are also temporally expansive are integral for understanding the modern Earth system”. Insert further and recent literature on Cenozoic climate changes registered in the sedimentary record:
- Medici, G., Marianelli, D., Gori, F., Cornacchia, I., Brandano, M. 2026. Multi-disciplinary approach to paleokarst occurrence in the Eocene–Oligocene succession of the Apulia Carbonate Platform (Salento, Italy). Facies, doi: 10.1007/s10347-026-00729-5
- Jaramillo-Vogel D, Strasser A, Frijia G, Spezzaferri S (2013) Neritic isotope and sedimentary records of the Eocene-Oligocene greenhouse–icehouse transition: the Calcare di Nago Formation (northern Italy) in a global context. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 369:361–376
Line 94. “Goals”. I would stick with “objectives” as you have done a few lines below.
Line 134. You have many equations and this one is obvious. Can you avoid at least Equation 3?
Line 212. Eleven equations are too many for me in a non-engineering manuscript. Some equations are very basic in this manuscript.
Line 464. A clear conclusion that re-calls your good four objectives would be useful.
Figures and tables
Figure 2. The figure can be divided in two separate figures, one with the maps and one with the graphs.
Figure 3. This figure works also in smaller size.
Figure 3. The caption is too long. Some detail can be moved to the main body of the manuscript.
Figure 4. Increase the graphic resolution in terms of dpi.
Figure 6. The caption is too long also for this figure. Some detail can be moved to the main body of the manuscript.
Figure 7. The timescale is missing and unclear.