Tropospheric Circulations Modulating the Boreal Winter Lower Stratospheric Polar Vortex
Abstract. Here we present an observational study of the variations in the lower stratospheric polar vortex (LSPV) associated with the main tropospheric circulation patterns in the Northern Hemisphere in winter (November to March). The LSPV is based on daily geopotential height at 100 hPa, and the circulation patterns are based on the empirical orthogonal function analysis of geopotential height anomalies at 500 hPa. The LSPV is found to strengthen with the Ural trough and the negative phase of the Pacific-North America (PNA-) pattern, and to weaken with the Ural ridge and the PNA+ pattern. These relations result first from the anomalous poleward, isentropic transport of oceanic air masses on the western flank of the positive tropospheric geopotential height anomalies, and of continental air masses on the eastern flank of the negative anomalies. Secondly, they result from troposphere-stratosphere propagation of anomalies, which may intensify or flatten the stationary anomalies in the stratosphere. In particular, the northeast Asia trough is deepened during the Ural ridge, and the Alaska ridge is enhanced during PNA+ regimes, which increase meridional fluxes of heat and cause a weakening of the polar vortex. This work thus supports wave-propagation-and-interferences based theory for polar vortex variations in previous studies, while highlighting the role of certain tropospheric circulation patterns. The large-scale anomalous advection of airmasses explain coherently tropospheric and stratospheric changes associated with the circulation patterns, and suggest covariations of the LSPV with clouds, latent heating, precipitation, and radiative feedbacks in the Arctic atmosphere.
The manuscript presents an observational analysis of the variations in the lower stratospheric polar vortex (LSPV) associated with the main tropospheric circulation patterns in the Northern Hemisphere in winter. The authors focus on daily geopotential height at 100 hPa, and the tropospheric circulation patterns are based on the empirical orthogonal function analysis of geopotential height anomalies at 500 hPa. The authors found that the LSPV is found to strengthen with the Ural trough and the negative phase of the Pacific-North America (PNA-) pattern, and to weaken with the Ural ridge and the PNA+ pattern.
I do think that this is an important study with important results as I don’t feel that the community appreciates enough the importance of Ural ridging/troughing to polar vortex variability. However I do wish that the authors could have done more. Two analyses that I strongly suggest that the authors include are: Rossby wave energy propagation (wave activity flux) associated with all the different teleconnection patterns and the surface temperature pattern with each of the different teleconnection patterns. I would also be curious to see an analysis that shows which ridging patterns are associated with stretched polar vortex events and which are associated with sudden stratospheric warmings. Otherwise I feel that the manuscript is in good shape.
I have some more minor suggested edits below. I recommend that the manuscript be accepted pending minor revisions.
Minor comments:
Â
Reference:
Kretschmer, J. Cohen, V. Matthias, J. Runge and D. Coumou,. 2018: The different stratospheric influences on cold extremes in northern Eurasia and North America, npj Climate and Atmospheric Science, doi: 10.1038/s41612-018-0054-4.
Judah Cohen