Estimation of vertical profiles of raindrop size distribution and cloud microphysical processes in stratiform rainfall using vertical-pointing X- and VHF-band radars
Abstract. Simultaneous vertical pointing observations by X- and VHF-band radars were conducted in Japan, and these data were used to estimate vertical profiles of drop size distribution (DSD) parameters of raindrops, assuming a gamma distribution, for a stratiform rainfall event. We used X-band reflectivity, vertical Doppler velocity, and spectral width, combined with VHF-band vertical air motion data. The estimation considers non-Rayleigh scattering and the influence of vertical air motion, and accounts for the contamination of spectral broadening using a forward convolution technique. We demonstrated that for stratiform rainfall, broadening by wind shear may be neglected, even with a relatively coarse radar range resolution of 150 metres. Cloud physical quantities (median volume diameter, liquid water content, normalised intercept parameter) retrieved from the estimated DSD parameters were compared with operational X-band polarimetric radar data and found to be highly accurate. We also point out the potential applicability of this method to satellite-borne radars. Among the estimated parameters, the shape and slope parameters generally increased with decreasing altitude. These changes are attributed to collision-coalescence and breakup based on variations in the cloud physical quantities, likely due to the humid environment. This study suggests that retrieving cloud physical quantities from DSD parameters estimated from vertical observations enables robust discussions on cloud physical processes.
General comments:
The authors proposed a method for estimating the vertical distributions of DSD parameters and cloud microphysics-related parameters for layered rainfall events using vertically pointing observations from X-band and VHF-band radars. Although the validation was limited to specific regions and cases, their analysis was conducted with great care and is considered highly valuable. However, whilst the technical steps undertaken are listed in the main text, the reasons for undertaking them and their advantages are generally absent, and the relationships between them remain unclear, rendering the text very difficult to read. Consequently, the novelty of this research is hard to discern. There must be pros and cons associated with each radar used; these should be explicitly stated whilst reviewing relevant prior research.
Furthermore, the advantages gained from combining these radars and how they differ from previous research should be clearly stated in the introduction. Relatedly, within the methodology section, it would be preferable to include a brief explanatory sentence at the beginning of each subsection to clarify the context within the text.
Â
Specific comments:
Â
Technical Corrections: