Evaluation of the vertical microphysical properties of fog as simulated by Meso-NH during the SOFOG3D experiment

Abstract. This study evaluates the representation of fog microphysics in high-resolution simulations from the Meso-NH model using the two-moment LIMA microphysical scheme, based on data from the SOFOG3D field campaign. This campaign combines remote sensing and vertical microphysical observations from a tethered balloon. Two fog events were simulated in order to assess the model's ability to reproduce their life cycle and identify any missing physical processes. The analysis focuses on the vertical microphysical structure, observed consistently by the various instruments, and on the simulated processes during the different phases of fog development (i.e. before, during, and after the transition from thin to thick fog). The model realistically reproduces the thermodynamic and dynamic evolution of fog, resulting in a satisfactory simulation of its development stages. A comprehensive analysis of microphysical processes is conducted throughout the entire height of the fog, based on a comparison with observations and a budget of modelled processes. While microphysics is generally well represented, certain systematic errors emerge: excessive liquid water content values vertically during the thin-to-thick transition and adiabatic phases, due to excessive condensation; an inaccurate representation of the droplet side distribution, with the absence of the largest droplets; and an inability to capture the droplet concentration vertical gradient, with values that are too high near the ground. While some of these shortcomings can be explained by dynamic biases, and more cases are needed to confirm our results, various recommendations are proposed. These include assessing the impact of drizzle and representations that could benefit all warm clouds.