Scaling and exceedance probability of sinkhole collapse in evaporite karst (Dead Sea, Jordan)
Abstract. Quantitative analysis of sinkhole collapse hazard requires robust data in both space and time. It also needs a clear understanding of the factors and processes that contribute to observed sinkhole locations and dimensions. In many karst settings, these criteria are difficult to meet because of the millennia-long time scales over which sinkhole populations are generated and because of uncertainties around how geomorphological processes link to sinkhole dimensions. This study presents new data on the scaling and probability of sinkhole formation in evaporite karst on the eastern Dead Sea shore (Jordan). Several thousand cover collapse sinkholes have formed there in the past 40 years with minimal post-collapse modification. Genetic processes and timescales are thus well constrained. Utilising high-resolution satellite imagery (Pleiades, PNEO) from 2017–2024, integrated with prior datasets, we present an updated inventory of sinkhole occurrence, extent and dimensions through time over the period 1992–2024. The sinkhole number increased by 43 % from 1565 in 2018 to 2247 in 2024, reflecting a 22 % increase in the sinkhole-affected land area to c. 179610 m² (17.9 ha). Formation of new karst subsidence features has continued a northward and seaward advance, consistent with control from the decline of the Dead Sea base level. However, we also observed a localised revival in 2021–2022 of sinkhole formation in an area that had been apparently inactive since 2002. This combination of continued and renewed sinkhole formation poses significant challenges to agriculture, housing and infrastructure in the area. Sinkhole average diameters range from 0.8 to 72.9 m; their frequency follows a log-normal distribution, rather than a power-law. Representative annualised exceedance probabilities for formation of sinkholes with diameters greater than 5, 10 and 50 m are c. 70 %, 30 % and 0.5 % respectively. Exceedance probabilities show some dependence on sampling time interval and on the nature of near-surface materials in which sinkholes form. Given their log-normal size distribution, the Dead Sea cover collapse sinkholes are not scale-free; instead they are scale-bound by the evaporite karst system’s geometrical and mechanical properties.
General comments:
The paper by Schulten et al. entitled “Scaling and exceedance probability of sinkhole collapse in evaporite karst (Dead Sea, Jordan)” presents new data on the scaling and probability of sinkhole formation in evaporite karst on the eastern Dead Sea shore (Jordan). Utilising high-resolution satellite imagery from 2017–2024, integrated with prior datasets, the research presents an updated inventory of sinkhole occurrence, extent, and dimensions through time over the period 1992-2024 for local geohazard and risk management at the eastern Dead Sea.
Overall, this is an appropriate subject area for the NHESS journal, and the developed research could help to improve the local geohazard and risk management at the eastern Dead Sea. The manuscript is well-written and developed even for inexperienced readers. However, I believe that minor improvements can be made, for example, by adding some aspects related to data processing, error assessment of outputs, and comparison with direct field surveys. Moreover, it is also required to add some details of previous works to have a complete understanding of the whole research. This work can be interesting and useful for the scientific community with some improvements, by better explaining the innovative aspects of the research and the insights it provides for improving the monitoring of sinkholes.
Specific comments:
Typing errors