How unstable was the environment during the Penultimate Glacial in the South-Western Mediterranean? Vegetation, climate and human dynamics during MIS 6
Abstract. The impact of rapid climate variability on Neanderthal population in Europe during the Last Glacial (Marine Isotope Stages 4-2), including Dansgaard-Oeschger cycles and Heinrich events, has been the subject of a long-standing debate. However, few studies have focused on the nature and impact of such rapid variations on human population during earlier periods. A growing number of high-resolution paleoclimatic archives supports the persistence of rapid oscillations during the penultimate glaciation (MIS 6), and the close response of Mediterranean ecosystems to these. Still, few palynological sequences in the Mediterranean region offer sufficient resolution to document vegetation dynamics during this time. Pollen records are especially lacking in the western Mediterranean, a key region to understand the connection between North Atlantic and Mediterranean climatic influences. This region is also traditionally considered a climatic refugium for human population during unfavourable periods. We provide new palynological data covering MIS 6 from the long and continuous marine record of ODP 976 in the Alboran Sea. A total of 200 samples, spanning the interval from 196 to 127 ka Before Present (BP), reveal both long-term trends and rapid fluctuations in regional vegetation composition. A multi-method approach, including modern analogues, regression, and machine learning approaches, was applied to ODP 976 pollen assemblages to reconstruct the annual/seasonal temperatures and precipitation. Results show that three phases can be identified. The first phase (187–166 ka BP) is characterized by significant oscillations of temperate trees and rather cool and humid conditions during early MIS 6, coincident with a sapropel layer deposition in both the western and eastern Mediterranean. In the second phase (165–144 ka BP), arid herbaceous vegetation is dominant, marking the main imprint of glacial maxima conditions and reduced climate variability. The third phase (144–129 ka BP) is marked by the development of Ericaceae and increased annual precipitations. At the end of MIS 6 glaciation, an strong cooling and intense episode of steppe and semi-desert expansion is identified as Heinrich Stadial 11 (135–129 ka BP), marking a distinct pattern for Termination II in the Western Mediterranean. Rapid oscillations appear like a pervasive feature of the Penultimate glacial in the SW Mediterranean, though they present reduced amplitude and frequency compared to the Last Glacial. A synthesis of human occupation shows that a mosaic of traditional (Mode 2) and innovative (Mode 3) technological features is observed. Although the data are scarce, Neanderthal seems to have continuously inhabited Western Mediterranean regions across the penultimate glacial. The severe climate conditions during Heinrich Stadial 11 (~133–129 ka BP) might have played a role in the apparent population contraction at the end of MIS 6, and perhaps also in the definitive abandonment of Lower Palaeolithic industries.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Climate of the Past.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
In this study Charton et al. carried out a high-resolution pollen analysis of the penultimate glaciation part of a marine core from the Alboran Sea. The authors discussed the pollen data and deduced vegetation changes and climate inferences and compared them to other paleoclimatic records from the study area making some interesting inferences. Detailed records from the MIS6 glaciation in the western Mediterranean are quite rare so that adds interest to this study.
I suggest publication in Egusphere but some changes should be done before publication. Here below are my comments:
-Line 43: This sentence is not clear - explain this further.
-Line 44: in plural: neanderthals seem to have..
-Line 128: be more specific?
-Line 136: chose a better word than connect. relate? correlate?
-Line 157: Not really a climate reference for the study area
-Line 165: Picea does not grow naturally in the study area
-Line 169: The Atlantic currents? which ones? can you be more specific for your study site?
-Line 194: add: correlation to orbital configuration
-Line 199: The chronological control of the sequence is based on direct correlation to very distant and various records, such as a speleothem in China and a record from the coast off Portugal, which in turn was aligned to the Antarctic temperature record (even considering the bipolar seesaw...) ...the authors then assumed that vegetation changes in the Mediterranean were synchronous to Chinese and Antarctic temperatures. There is a possibility that this can be true but this approach limits the output in terms of lags or leads of the response of the vegetation in your record to climate events worldwide... For example, in lines 402-403: How is it possible to observe a delay for TII in your record if the chronology was tuned to that particular speleothem record? If there is not an objective direct chronological control of your core you cannot really discuss about this matter
-Line 215: change "here" for "In this study"
-Line 224: Change "along" for "in"
-Line 234: remove "As already pointed out,"
-Figure 3. I imagine this figure was meant to be represented horizontally. However, vertically the numbers in the scales are upside down and should be rotated 180º.
-Lines 294-314. In this section, the results are already interpreted in terms of climate - I would leave those interpretations for the discussion and just describe the results here
-Line 303: Ericaceae rather indicates humid conditions, not cold climate
-Line 341: Present-day climatic conditions are shown in Figure 5 by stars - are those from the location of the marine site? from any other specific location? please specify
-Line 341: Remove "all along" and change it for "during"
-Figure 5 and text: The substages MIS6e-a were defined in an isotopic record but do not seem to agree with the results here - why do you pay so much attention to that?
-Fig. 5 legend: it is a black star (not red)
-Lines 380-381. This sentence is too vague...the pollen results do not really agree with the MIS6 glacial substages (a-e) and/or D-O dynamics that are only defined for the last glaciation...maybe it would be better to say "D-O-like dynamics" and I would remove the glacial substages.
-Lines 382-391: As these three phases don't coincide with the previously defined substages, I would remove those from the text and add ages when those phases occur in your record
-Line 402-403. Please give the ages for the beginning and end of the termination II in your record and describe how you identified that termination in the ODP 976 pollen record
-Line 407: W?
-Line 413: Do you mean the abrupt drop of temperatures at the beginning of HS11?
-Line 416: I would rather call this section "Hydroclimate connection..."
-In Figure 3. Pioneer vegetation is represented by brown color, as Ericaceae here. Please be consistent and use the same color for the different categories in all figures
-Line 455: Could you please explain why deciduous forest is important in better noticing the MIS7-6 transition?
-Lines 477-486. Maybe representing site MD01-2444 in Figure 6 would be usefull, even though it is not a Mediterranean site "per se", it looks like ODP 976 share a lot of similarities with it
-Lines 481-486: Could it be due to lower summer insolation generating lower evaporation in summer and favoring the growth of Ericaceae, which requires humidity throughout the year?
-Line 498: I would just say Moroccan Mountains - Cedrus could also originate from the Atlas
-Line 505: Change across for throughout
-Line 507: Not just rapid, but enhanced development of forest in that area
-Line 508: Please explain why altitude is important here
-Line 523: Please be more specific of why do you think it is compatible with DO-like variabilty. Is it the duration of the events? the intensity?
-Line 527: What does "disentangle the character" mean? investigate?
-Line 529. What do you mean with consistent? similar? in what? time? intensity? be more specific
-Line 532: Remove "the" and change it for "its more semiarid"
-Line 434. Confirm this, as earlier you said Ericaceae was a "cold" indicator (see line 303) - be consistent
-Line 539. This affirmation is very vague. There are significant differences between the Cueva Gitana and ODP 976, for example maximum humidity seems to occur at 148 kyr, which is not replicated in your record
-Fig. 7. The text of the legends of the different plots should be written in a bigger size.
Also, the scale in the synthetic pollen figure from ODP 976 is missing
In addition, the pollen data do not really agree with the substage subdivision done by Railsback fro MIS 6 - I would remove that subdivision.
-Lines 566-572: This paragraph is repetitive, see the beginning of the discussion in lines 382-415. I would remove it or synthesize those two paragraphs in one. Also, check more text in this section for further repetition
-Lines 573-583. Check for repetitions in the sapropel discussion with the previous section about the ORLs - this could be synthesized...maybe adding the ORL text in this section?
-Line 589. How do the isotopic and sea surface temperature records reflect precipitation? Please explain
-The size of figure 9 as it is shown in the pdf here is too small - one can barely read the text-numbers so it should be bigger.
-Line 903: replace "consistent with" with similar to
-Line 917: Change "double u for "W"