Weathering without inorganic CDR revealed through cation tracing

Abstract. Enhanced Weathering using basalt rock dust is a scalable carbon dioxide removal (CDR) technique, but quantifying rock weathering and CDR rates poses a critical challenge. Here, we investigated inorganic CDR and weathering rates by treating mesocosms planted with corn with basalt (0, 10, 30, 50, 75, 100, 150 and 200 t ha⁻¹) and monitoring them for 101 days. Surprisingly, we observed no significant inorganic CDR, as leaching of dissolved inorganic carbon did not increase, and soil carbonate content even declined over time.

To gain insights into the weathering processes, we analyzed the mass balance of base cations, which can be linked with anions (including HCO₃^-) through charge balance. This mass balance showed that most base cation charges were retained as (hydr)oxides in the reducible pool of the top soil, while increases in the exchangeable pool were about a factor 10 smaller. Soil base cation scavenging exceeded plant scavenging by approximately two orders of magnitude. From the base cations in all pools (soil, soil water and plants), we quantified log weathering rates of -11 mol TA m^-2 basalt s^-1 and a maximum CO₂ removal potential of the weathered base cations (i.e., CDR potential) of 18 kg CO₂ t⁻¹ basalt.

For climate change mitigation, not only the amount of CDR potential is important, but also the timescale at which that CDR would be realized. Our data suggests that the lag time for realization of inorganic CDR may be larger than commonly assumed. In conclusion, we observed that inorganic CDR was not directly linked to rock weathering in the short-term. Still, the observed increases in secondary minerals and base cation exchange may provide valuable benefits for soil fertility and organic matter stabilization in the long-term.