Preprints
https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2024-3619
https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2024-3619
29 Nov 2024
 | 29 Nov 2024
Status: this preprint is open for discussion.

Quantifying economic risks to dairy farms from volcanic hazards in Taranaki, New Zealand

Nicola J. McDonald, Leslie Dowling, Emily P. Harvey, Alana M. Weir, Mark S. Bebbington, Nam Bui, Christina Magill, Heather M. Craig, Garry W. McDonald, Juan Monge, Shane J. Cronin, Thomas M. Wilson, and Duncan Walker

Abstract. The volcanic hazard and risk science for Taranaki Mounga (Taranaki volcano) in New Zealand is in an advanced state, with robust probabilistic data and a series of direct impact scenarios modelled for the region. Here we progress this work and demonstrate a method to provide risk information that is nuanced for factors such as location and economic sector, and considers the dynamic nature of volcanism with hazards potentially repeated over time. Recognising the fundamental importance of the dairy sector to Taranaki Region, this paper provides valuable insights on the potential impacts and risks to heterogeneous dairy cattle farms within the region from volcanic hazards. We provide volcanic impact and risk metrics in economic or monetary terms in order to improve its relevance to decision makers while reducing the complexity of the impacts. To do this, we developed a dynamic, multi-event farm system model of response and recovery, which takes in hazard intensity metrics from a series of volcanic events, and generates the resulting annualised revenues, expenditures and recovery costs through time. The model is formulated in a generalised way such that it can be used for various other hazard types and agricultural land uses. In our application of the model, we create and apply a suite of ten thousand simulations that capture different iterations of possible future volcanic activity over a 50-year period. These include the generation of lahars following eruptions and associated failures for transport and water supply networks. Farms at five case study locations were modelled, to capture the diversity in farm management and the spatial variation in hazard intensities and likelihoods across the region. We provide summaries of the distributions of economic impacts generated, both for individual events and for the 50-year volcanic future horizon. Drawing the information together, we also summarise the results for each case study farm in terms of the Value at Risk statistic. For the case study farms with negligible lahar risk we find, with 90 % confidence, that volcanic losses over the next 50 years will not exceed around 10 % of property value. By comparison, for the farm with the most severe lahar and ashfall exposure, we find that at the same level of confidence, losses extend to approximately half the property value. These results indicate that with access to sufficient risk information, we should anticipate volcanic risk as playing an important role in shaping the future dairy sector in Taranaki Region. The modelling pipeline and assessment metrics demonstrated in this paper could be used to assess mitigation and adaptation strategies to reduce the risk from volcanic hazards and improve the resilience of farm businesses.

Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
Nicola J. McDonald, Leslie Dowling, Emily P. Harvey, Alana M. Weir, Mark S. Bebbington, Nam Bui, Christina Magill, Heather M. Craig, Garry W. McDonald, Juan Monge, Shane J. Cronin, Thomas M. Wilson, and Duncan Walker

Status: open (until 10 Jan 2025)

Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor | : Report abuse
Nicola J. McDonald, Leslie Dowling, Emily P. Harvey, Alana M. Weir, Mark S. Bebbington, Nam Bui, Christina Magill, Heather M. Craig, Garry W. McDonald, Juan Monge, Shane J. Cronin, Thomas M. Wilson, and Duncan Walker
Nicola J. McDonald, Leslie Dowling, Emily P. Harvey, Alana M. Weir, Mark S. Bebbington, Nam Bui, Christina Magill, Heather M. Craig, Garry W. McDonald, Juan Monge, Shane J. Cronin, Thomas M. Wilson, and Duncan Walker
Metrics will be available soon.
Latest update: 29 Nov 2024
Download
Short summary
We quantify future economic impacts of volcanic events for dairy farms in Taranaki, New Zealand. The model we develop could be applied to other hazard and agricultural land use contexts. To address uncertainty, 10,000 possible volcanic futures are simulated, and results are collated in risk-type metrics and data visualisations. The results highlight variation in risk exposure across the farms and that volcanic risk could play an important future role in shaping Taranaki’s dairy sector.