the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Infilling of Missing Rainfall Radar Data with a Memory-Assisted Deep Learning Approach
Abstract. Incomplete spatio-temporal meteorological observations can result in misinterpretations of the current climate state, uncertainties in early warning systems, or inaccuracies in nowcasting models and can thereby pose signficant challanges in hydrology research or similar applications. Traditional statistical methods for infilling missing precipitation data demand substantial computational resources and fail over large areas with sparse data – like temporary outages of weather radars. Although recent machine learning advancements have shown promise in addressing missing meteorological or satellite observations, they typically focus on spatial aspects, overlooking the complex spatio-temporal variability characteristic of precipitation, especially during extreme events. We propose a deep convolutional neural network enhanced with a temporal memory component to better account for temporal changes in precipitation fields. This approach can analyse arbitrary sequences from before and/or after the incomplete observation of interest. Our model is trained and evaluated on the hourly RADKLIM dataset, which features 1-km resolution precipitation derived from combined radar and weather station data across Germany. By infilling both synthetic and actual data gaps of RADKLIM, the study demonstrates the model's effectiveness, providing detailed insights into its capabilities during significant rainfall events, such as those in May 2012 and July 2021, including those responsible for the Ahrtal flood. This novel approach represents a step forward in hydrological applications, potentially improving the way we predict and manage water-related events by increasing the accuracy and reliability of precipitation data analysis.
- Preprint
(10857 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (extended)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2024-1392', Anonymous Referee #1, 17 Dec 2024
reply
The study of Meuer et al entitled “Infilling of Missing Rainfall Radar Data with a Memory-Assisted Deep Learning Approach” explores the use of machine learning for infilling of the RADOLAN precipitation product of the German Weather Service. The approach comprises a comparison with baseline and channel-based results. Although the proposed method is technically more demanding, it results in increased accuracy and in filled data gaps respecting the temporal and spatial pattern of the precipitation event.
The manuscript is written in a concise way, is well-structured and makes use of good English. However, to my impression, the actual discussion is missing and only few remarks could be interpreted as discussion. Therefore, please enlarge the discussion part and make use of more references to guide the interpretation. In this context, a broader discussion on the uncertainty of each infilling technique would also help to improve this section. Why were the events of May 2012 and July 2021 presented only?
To conclude, the manuscript requires further improvements my opinion before recommending it for publication in this journal.
Specific comments:
- 1, l. 2: “challenges”
p.2, l. 24: Please correct the figure number
- 3, l. 63: “depending” instead of “pending”
- 3, l. 70: Please add the specific product name (RADOLAN YW and RADOLAN RW)
- 4, l. 90: Please introduce the abbreviation
- 4, l. 95: this fact deserves a reference
- 5, l. 116: this reference is given twice, please remove one
- 9, l.189 – p.10, l. 191: please specify the hardware resources you used and give advice on some minimal requirement
- 10, l. 193: this may be the true final step, while “final” was already used on p. 7, l. 174. Please correct this.
Figure 1: Please add to the caption the data source and reference to the product.
Figure 7. The caption is the same as the one of Figure E1 although the maps are different. Please check the captions.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2024-1392-RC1
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
284 | 81 | 22 | 387 | 16 | 13 |
- HTML: 284
- PDF: 81
- XML: 22
- Total: 387
- BibTeX: 16
- EndNote: 13
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1